1. As the judge in this case, would you agree with the four disciplined union members or the union? Why?

2. The efforts of the four union members to either switch union positions to nonunion positions or vote the new union out were not supported by the employees. Do you think the union should have ignored the four rather than disciplining them?

3. Do you think it is right for a union and an employer to agree in a collective bargaining agreement that all of the workers subject to the collective bargaining agreement have to join the union in order to keep their job?