Question: In November and December 2003 more than 100 firefighters in
In November and December 2003, more than 100 firefighters in the New Haven Fire Department took written and oral examinations to qualify for promotion to lieutenant or captain. A written component counted for 60 percent of an applicant's score and an oral component constituted the remainder of the score. Candidates with a total combined score of 70 percent or better earned a passing score and were eligible for promotion. The pass rate for black candidates was roughly one-half of the corresponding pass rate for white candidates. Given the pool of candidates who passed the exam and the number of vacancies at the lieutenant and captain ranks, no black candidates would have received a promotion to either rank. Officials of the City of New Haven- who, according to a local ordinance, were required to certify the test results and the promotion lists for them to be official-voted not to certify the results. The officials' decision was motivated by a desire to avoid making promotion decisions that disproportionately adversely impacted black candidates and risked violating Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act as a result. Frank Ricci and 16 other white candidates, along with one Hispanic candidate, who passed the examination, but who were denied a chance at promotions due to the officials' decision not to certify the results, sued the City of New Haven, Mayor John DeStefano, and a number of other officials for, among other things, violating Title VII. They claimed that, by discarding the test results, the defendants discriminated against them based on their race. Was the city justified in refusing to certify the exam results and promotion lists due to its concern about potential disparate impact liability? Or were the plaintiffs correct that the city's decision resulted in disparate treatment against them because of their race?
Answer to relevant QuestionsAzteca, which operates a chain of restaurants, employed Sanchez from October 1991 to July 1995. Throughout his tenure at Azteca, Sanchez was subjected to a relentless campaign of insults, name-calling, and vulgarities. Male ...Brian Petty was both a police officer in Nashville, Tennessee, and an officer in the Army Reserve. In October, he informed the department that he would be deployed to Iraq at the end of the year. While in Iraq, Petty was ...Don King and Scott Willson worked together on improving and selling an electronic payment system. To develop the system, they pooled their money and labor, with King providing financing and Willson contributing his time and ...Jake Coombs, Yemi Ogarra, and Wade Stram formed a financial services consulting partnership. The partnership's ordinary business was to provide investment advice to businesses with assets between $500,000 and $40,000,000. ...Labrum & Doak, LLP, was a law partnership that began in 1904 in Pennsylvania. John Seehousen, Jonathan Herbst, and James Hilly were partners of Labrum & Doak. They withdrew from the partnership in 1993, 1995, and 1997. They ...
Post your question