# Question: In one study physicians were asked to estimate the probability

In one study, physicians were asked to estimate the probability of a malignant cancer given that a test showed a positive result. They were told that the cancer had a prevalence rate of 1%, the test has a false positive rate of 10%, and the test is 80% accurate in correctly identifying a malignancy when the subject actually has the cancer. (See Probabilistic Reasoning in Clinical Medicine by David Eddy, Cambridge University Press.)

a. Find P(malignant | positive test result).

b. Find ^(positive test result | malignant).

c. Out of 100 physicians, 95 estimated P(malignant | positive test result) to be about 75%. Were those estimates reasonably accurate, or did they exhibit confusion of the inverse? What would be a consequence of confusion of the inverse in this situation?

a. Find P(malignant | positive test result).

b. Find ^(positive test result | malignant).

c. Out of 100 physicians, 95 estimated P(malignant | positive test result) to be about 75%. Were those estimates reasonably accurate, or did they exhibit confusion of the inverse? What would be a consequence of confusion of the inverse in this situation?

**View Solution:**## Answer to relevant Questions

What does the symbol ! represent? Four different people can stand in a line 4! different ways. What is the actual number of ways that four people can stand in a line? Winning the jackpot in the Florida Lotto requires that you choose six different numbers from 1 to 53, and your numbers must match the same six numbers that are later drawn. The order of the selected numbers does not matter. ...You want to obtain cash by using an ATM machine, but it’s dark and you can’t see your card when you insert it. The card must be inserted with the front side up and the printing configured so that the beginning of your ...Listed below are the differences (in years) between the ages of actresses and actors when they won Oscars. The differences are found by subtracting the age of the male winner from the age of the female winner: (actress age) ...For 200 births, the probability of exactly 90 girls is 0.0208 and the probability of 90 or fewer girls is 0.089. a. Is exactly 90 girls in 200 births unlikely? b. Among 200 births, is 90 girls an unusually low number of ...Post your question