Muniz was arrested on a charge of driving under the influence of alcohol. He was taken to a booking center, where he was asked several questions by a police officer without first being given the Miranda warnings. Videotape (which included an audio portion) was used to record the questions and Muniz's answers. The officer asked Muniz his name, address, height, weight, eye color, date of birth, and current age. Muniz stumbled over answers to two of these questions. The officer then asked Muniz the date of his sixth birthday, but Muniz did not give the correct date. At a later point, Muniz was read the Miranda warnings for the first time. He was later convicted of the charged offense, with the trial court denying his motion to exclude the videotape (both video and audio portions) from evidence. Assume that the video portion of the tape violated neither the Fifth Amendment nor Miranda. Should all or any part of the audio portion of the tape (which contained Muniz's stumbling responses to two questions plus his incorrect answer to the sixth birthday date question) have been excluded as a violation of either the Fifth Amendment or Miranda?
Answer to relevant QuestionsA federal statute, 18 U.S.C. § 1037, prohibits a variety of misleading electronic mail-related actions in commercial settings. These include instances in which a person who, with knowledge of doing so, "materially falsifies ...Tampa, Florida, law enforcement officers who sought to apprehend Kevin Dewayne Powell in connection with a robbery investigation entered an apartment rented by Powell's girlfriend. After spotting Powell coming from a ...The Hearst Corporation publishes the Houston Chronicle, an edition of which included an article headlined "Justice Under Fire." Written by Evan Moore, the article contained pointed criticisms of the Smith County, Texas, ...Allen Baize owned a Kentucky lumber yard and sawmill known as Greenville Log and Lumber Co. Baize hired Darrell Hargis on an independent contractor basis to haul logs to and from Greenville and various other locations. ...Tracey Bantz and Crystal Kiesau served as deputy sheriffs for the Buchanan County, Iowa, Sheriff's Department. In connection with her employment, Kiesau was involved with a K-9 training program for dogs. The website for the ...
Post your question