The risk of harm accompanying the bats use extends beyond the player who holds the bat in

Question:

“The risk of harm accompanying the bat’s use extends beyond the player who holds the bat in his or her hands.” —Selley, Justice 

Facts: While pitching in an American Legion baseball game, 18-year-old Brandon Patch was struck in the head by a batted ball hit by a batter using a model CB-13 aluminum bat manufactured by Hillerich & Bradsby Company (H&B). Brandon died from his injuries. A baseball hit by an aluminum bat travels at a higher velocity than a ball hit by a traditional wooden baseball bat, thus increasing an infielder’s required reaction time. Brandon’s parents, individually and as representatives of Brandon’s estate, sued H&B for strict liability, asserting that H&B failed to warn Brandon of the alleged defect in the aluminum bat, that is, the increased speed of a ball hit by H&B’s bat. In defense, H&B first alleged that there was no defect of failure to warn, and second it did not have a duty to warn a nonuser of the bat. The jury found failure to warn and awarded the plaintiffs $850,000 against H&B. H&B appealed. 

Issue: Did H&B fail to warn Brandon of the increased risk of injury caused by its aluminum bat? 

Language of the Court: The bat is an indispensable part of the game. The risk of harm accompanying the bat’s use extends beyond the player who holds the bat in his or her hands. A warning of the bat’s risks to only the batter standing at the plate inadequately communicates the potential risk of harm posed by the bat’s increased exit speed. H&B is subject to liability to all players in the game, including Brandon, for the physical harm caused by its bat’s increased exit speed. 

Decision: The Supreme Court of Montana upheld the jury’s finding of failure to warn by H&B and affirmed the award of $850,000 damages. 

Ethics Questions: Do you think that H&B should have been found liable in this case? Do baseball leagues and teams owe an ethical duty to ban the use of aluminum bats?

Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!

Step by Step Answer:

Related Book For  book-img-for-question
Question Posted: