1. What are the ethical issues involved? 2. Has the researcher undertaken sufficient steps to safeguard ethical...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
1. What are the ethical issues involved?
2. Has the researcher undertaken sufficient steps to safeguard ethical principles? What additional steps are needed?
3. Should the research study be discontinued? Why or why, not?
Transcribed Image Text:
Ethical dilemmas in research A financial services company implements a new information technology system that gives email capability to all employees, irrespective of grade. After 12 months, company directors are anxious to know if the investment is providing a financial payback. One indicator is whether the email facility is improving inter-employee communication and general productivity. Hence, they want an analysis of email traffic. An external researcher is commissioned to conduct the study. She decides to use a blend of quantitative and qualitative methods. On the quantitative side, negotiating access to the information poses no problems, since all she has to do is contact the head of information services. Given that this is a legitimate company project, commissioned by the executive board, he is obliged to give the researcher free access to whatever information she requests. For the qualitative side of the research she wants to interview a sample of 40 employees. Believing that imposing herself on these people would be unethical, she writes to all of them individually requesting access, and provides details of the purpose of the research, how the information is being collected, and who will read the final report. She had made a request to the executive board that she should be allowed to provide a summary of the final report to all respondents but this was refused. Despite her reassurances, only 12 of the original sample agree to being interviewed, most excusing themselves on the basis that they are too busy. One option would be to obtain an instruction from the managing director, ordering everyone to cooperate. She decides, however, that, not only would this be counter-productive, it would be unethical on a number of grounds not least because the responses would no longer be voluntary. Eventually, she decides that these 12 in-depth interviews will be sufficient to yield high-quality data. p.95 Ethical dilemmas in research A financial services company implements a new information technology system that gives email capability to all employees, irrespective of grade. After 12 months, company directors are anxious to know if the investment is providing a financial payback. One indicator is whether the email facility is improving inter-employee communication and general productivity. Hence, they want an analysis of email traffic. An external researcher is commissioned to conduct the study. She decides to use a blend of quantitative and qualitative methods. On the quantitative side, negotiating access to the information poses no problems, since all she has to do is contact the head of information services. Given that this is a legitimate company project, commissioned by the executive board, he is obliged to give the researcher free access to whatever information she requests. For the qualitative side of the research she wants to interview a sample of 40 employees. Believing that imposing herself on these people would be unethical, she writes to all of them individually requesting access, and provides details of the purpose of the research, how the information is being collected, and who will read the final report. She had made a request to the executive board that she should be allowed to provide a summary of the final report to all respondents but this was refused. Despite her reassurances, only 12 of the original sample agree to being interviewed, most excusing themselves on the basis that they are too busy. One option would be to obtain an instruction from the managing director, ordering everyone to cooperate. She decides, however, that, not only would this be counter-productive, it would be unethical on a number of grounds not least because the responses would no longer be voluntary. Eventually, she decides that these 12 in-depth interviews will be sufficient to yield high-quality data. p.95
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Ethical dilemmas in research Introduction Ethical codes and principles express how people behave individually and as a society They provide moral judgment when making decisions or guide peoples behavi... View the full answer
Related Book For
Principles of Supply Chain Management A Balanced Approach
ISBN: 978-1285428314
4th edition
Authors: Joel D. Wisner, Keah-Choon Tan, G. Keong Leong
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these organizational behavior questions
-
392 CHAPTER 17 Teams and Teamwork ethics> KNOW RIGHT FROM WRONG > The student complained that free riders were making it hard for her team to perform well. Social Loafing Is Hurting Team Performance...
-
What are the ethical issues involved in NOAC's proposal?
-
What are the ethical issues in this situation?
-
Figure 11-31 shows a cooling curve for a Pb-Sn alloy. Determine (a) The pouring temperature; (b) The superheat; (c) The liquidus temperature; (d) The eutectic temperature; (e) The freezing range; (f)...
-
Dr. Alyx Hemmings is employed by Mesa Dental. Mesa Dental recently installed a computerized job-order costing system to help monitor the cost of its services. Each patient is assigned a job number...
-
A liquid is compressed in a reversible adiabatic process. What is the change in T?
-
Look over the Judicial Council form for an Abstract of Judgment in California, provided in Exhibit 18.2. Once you fill out the form, find out how you file and record it.
-
Red Corporation wants to set up a manufacturing facility in a mid western state. After considerable negotiations with a small town in Ohio, Red accepts the following offer: land (fair market value of...
-
Total sales Cost of sales Gross profit Selling, general, and administrative expenses 2006 2005 610.1 557.5 (500.2) (369) 109.9 188.5 (40.5) (38.6) (24.6) (21.6) (3.6) (3.8) Research and development...
-
Complete Form 941 for the 4th quarter for TCLH Industries (which is located at 202 Whitmore Avenue, Durham, NC 27701; Employer Identification #44-4444444). Assume that all necessary deposits were...
-
Michonne has invested in bonds issued by Alpha Beta Inc., while Rick owns their preferred shares and Carl owns their common shares. In the event of liquidation or dissolution of Alpha Beta Inc., who...
-
Identify four major types of working papers.
-
Identify the owner(s) of a proprietorship, a partnership, and a corporation.
-
Describe and explain the operation of a phase-shift oscillator.
-
For each of the users of accounting information, indicate whether they are an external decision maker (E) or an internal decision maker (I). a. Marketing manager b. Canada Revenue Agency c. Investor...
-
Using recent news headlines, describe an example of teaming in which a group of people came together briefly to solve a complex problem.
-
Solve the exponential equation algebraically. Round your result to three decimal places. Use a graphing utility to verify your answer. 6(10-9-x) + 4 = 2401 x =
-
A company pledges their receivables so they may Multiple Choice Charge a factoring fee. Increase sales. Recognize a sale. Collect a pledge fee. Borrow money. Failure by a promissory notes' maker to...
-
Should GM help to improve the tight cash situations at some of the dealers? Why or why not?
-
Describe what C-TPAT and FAST are. Which transportation modes use these?
-
How can CJI assure continued contract compliance and additional contract business from Great Lakes in the future?
-
Use the properties of the mean and median to determine which are the correct mean and median for the following histogram. (i) Mean is 3.0; median is 4.1 (ii) Mean is 4.2; median is 3.2 (iii) Mean is...
-
In a study of Facebook users conducted by the Pew Research Center, the mean number of Facebook friends per user was 245 and the median was 111. If a histogram were constructed for the numbers of...
-
The National Center for Health Statistics reported in a recent year that the mean height for U.S. women aged 2029 was 64.3 inches, and the median was 64.2 inches. If a histogram were constructed for...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App