2. Exercises in Using the AHP In this section, six exercises (called EX1-EX6) that can be...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
2. Exercises in Using the AHP In this section, six exercises (called EX1-EX6) that can be used in class problems or as homework problems on the AHP are presented. 2.1. EX1: Choosing the Best Automobile This basic example illustrates the key aspects of the AHP and its implementation by the Expert Choice software. The hierarchy is easy to build and the instructor can demonstrate the replication command that simplifies the building of the hierarchy. The over- all goal of the example is to choose the best automo- bile with respect to the four criteria. Figure 2.1 gives the data for the problem. The student can readily see that there is no one best alternative, as none of the automobiles is best across all criteria (as indicated by the asterisks). The problem has both quantitative and qualitative data. The price data can be used directly in the EC comparison matrix by the data entry mode, but the data entry has to be inverted (invert button) in that a low price is better than a higher price (EC considers a higher number as being better than a lower number unless told otherwise). Note that the prices are of the same order of magnitude-we are not comparing a Figure 2.1 Data for Automobile Purchase Example Alternatives Price ($) Miles/Gallon (MPG) Prestige Comfort. Avalon 15,000* 26 Low Good Babylon 18,000 28' Fair Fair Carryon 24,000 20 High' High' Asterisk* denotes best alternative. cheap Ford Falcon to a Jaguar. Comparing items of the same "Order of Magnitude" is an axiom of the AHP. The price data can also be used indirectly by ask- ing the usual pairwise comparison question, e.g., "Is Avalon preferred to Babylon with respect to price and how more is it preferred?" Here the preference needs to be established using the 1-9 scale (or equivalent verbal scale) and the student has to decide how the $15,000 compares to the $18,000. Using the 1-9 scale for the dollar figures tends to build a utility evalua- tion on the dollars the dollar spent for the cheaper auto has a greater utility than a dollar spent on a more expensive auto. The data entry mode treats all dollars as having the same utility. We suggest that the fac- ulty member first illustrate the data entry mode and then illustrating the 1-9 pairwise comparison mode. The final rankings will probably stay the same but the weights assigned to the different elements will prob- ably be different. The MPG numbers are direct data entry; the weights obtained are just the individual auto's MPG number divided by the sum of all the MPG numbers. For pres- tige and comfort, the student must make pairwise comparisons that respect the individual criterion tran- sitivity relationship (High>Good>Fair>Low). The 1-9 scale does a very good job in capturing the preferences (e.g., High/Low = 7, High/Good = 5, High/Fair=3, and so on). 2. Exercises in Using the AHP In this section, six exercises (called EX1-EX6) that can be used in class problems or as homework problems on the AHP are presented. 2.1. EX1: Choosing the Best Automobile This basic example illustrates the key aspects of the AHP and its implementation by the Expert Choice software. The hierarchy is easy to build and the instructor can demonstrate the replication command that simplifies the building of the hierarchy. The over- all goal of the example is to choose the best automo- bile with respect to the four criteria. Figure 2.1 gives the data for the problem. The student can readily see that there is no one best alternative, as none of the automobiles is best across all criteria (as indicated by the asterisks). The problem has both quantitative and qualitative data. The price data can be used directly in the EC comparison matrix by the data entry mode, but the data entry has to be inverted (invert button) in that a low price is better than a higher price (EC considers a higher number as being better than a lower number unless told otherwise). Note that the prices are of the same order of magnitude-we are not comparing a Figure 2.1 Data for Automobile Purchase Example Alternatives Price ($) Miles/Gallon (MPG) Prestige Comfort. Avalon 15,000* 26 Low Good Babylon 18,000 28' Fair Fair Carryon 24,000 20 High' High' Asterisk* denotes best alternative. cheap Ford Falcon to a Jaguar. Comparing items of the same "Order of Magnitude" is an axiom of the AHP. The price data can also be used indirectly by ask- ing the usual pairwise comparison question, e.g., "Is Avalon preferred to Babylon with respect to price and how more is it preferred?" Here the preference needs to be established using the 1-9 scale (or equivalent verbal scale) and the student has to decide how the $15,000 compares to the $18,000. Using the 1-9 scale for the dollar figures tends to build a utility evalua- tion on the dollars the dollar spent for the cheaper auto has a greater utility than a dollar spent on a more expensive auto. The data entry mode treats all dollars as having the same utility. We suggest that the fac- ulty member first illustrate the data entry mode and then illustrating the 1-9 pairwise comparison mode. The final rankings will probably stay the same but the weights assigned to the different elements will prob- ably be different. The MPG numbers are direct data entry; the weights obtained are just the individual auto's MPG number divided by the sum of all the MPG numbers. For pres- tige and comfort, the student must make pairwise comparisons that respect the individual criterion tran- sitivity relationship (High>Good>Fair>Low). The 1-9 scale does a very good job in capturing the preferences (e.g., High/Low = 7, High/Good = 5, High/Fair=3, and so on).
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
Entrepreneurial Finance
ISBN: 978-0538478151
4th edition
Authors: J . chris leach, Ronald w. melicher
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these economics questions
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
CANMNMM January of this year. (a) Each item will be held in a record. Describe all the data structures that must refer to these records to implement the required functionality. Describe all the...
-
Suppose that in a particular area the consumption of water varies tremendously throughout the year, with average household summer use exceeding winter use by a great deal. What effect would this have...
-
Tram's advice averages 10 minutes per caller but varies according to an exponential distribution. The average time between calls is 25 minutes, exponentially distributed. Generating calls in this...
-
Large Group Ltd is assessing a business investment opportunity. The estimated cash flows for which are as follows: Jan. 2023 400,000 (Initial investment) The net operating annual cash flows arising...
-
What specific relationships may be determined in making an analytical review of long-term debt balances?
-
1. Liam Richardson is the business manager for the Smith & Lyngate Insurance agencies in the state of Maryland. Liam is interested in increasing the number of agents in Baltimore and plans to buy...
-
what extent do you perceive that your personal values align with the core ethos and culture of the organization?
-
Please explain what a= and what b= 8 7 b S f(x)dx f f(x)dx = f f(x)dx 5 5 a
-
The U.S. dollar price of a Swedish krona changes from \($.1572\) to \($.1730\). a. Has the dollar depreciated or appreciated against the krona? b. Has the krona appreciated or depreciated against the...
-
Two approximations to Planck's Law are useful in the extreme low and high limits of \(\lambda T\). a. Show that in the limit where \(\left(C_{1} / \lambda T ight) \gg 1\) that Planck's spectral...
-
What is the current yield on a bond? Why do interest rates change when bond prices change?
-
Suppose you are able-bodied and intelligent, but lazy. Youd rather sit home and watch television than work, even though you know you could find an acceptable job if you looked. a. Are you officially...
-
It is sometimes said that the Federal Reserve System is a nonpolitical agency. In what sense is this true? Why might you doubt that politics have no effect on Fed decisions?
-
QUESTION 9 Find out the Earth's magnetic field intensity when a 6cm X 3cm magnet is used. For the toolbar, press ALT+F10 (PC) or ALT+FN+F10 (Mac). BIUS Paragraph Arial 10pt *** ||| > A v 2 points...
-
Calculate the change in entropy when 100 kJ of energy is transferred reversibly and isothermally as heat to a large block of copper at (i) 0 C, (ii) 50 C.
-
What is meant by a ventures operating cycle? Also, describe the cash conversion cycle (C3).
-
Lets assume that Phil Young does develop and successfully market the Pedal Pusher product discussed in Problems 1 and 7. Phils venture will purchase materials for making the product from others,...
-
Calculate the conversion price formula (CPF) and market price formula (MPF) prices for an offering involving an existing conversion price of $1, a hypothesized market price of $2, and a new offering...
-
This exercise considers the data described in the Section 13.2.2 ratemaking classification example using data in Table 13.3 Table 13.3 . a. Fit a gamma regression model using a log-link function with...
-
This exercise considers data from the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (MEPS) described in Exercise 1.1 and Section 11.4. Our dependent variable consists of the number of outpatient (COUNTOP) visits....
-
Verify that the Tweedie distribution is a member of the linear exponential family of distributions by checking equation (13.9). In particular, provide an expression for \(S(y, \phi)\) (note that...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App