4. Simpson's Paradox. Simpson's parador occurs when groups of data shouw one particular trend, but this...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
4. Simpson's Paradox. Simpson's parador occurs when groups of data shouw one particular trend, but this trend is reversed when the groups are combined together. Understanding and identifying this paradox is important for correctly interpreting data. In this problem, we explore how UC Berkeley almost got sued for sex discrimination. The following tables summarize the graduate school admissions from 1973. The variables X and U represent admission status for women (X) and men (Y), where 1 indicates and acceptance into the program and 0 represents rejection. There are also 6 departments, summarized by the random variables Y (for women) and V (for men), where each value corresponds to a different department. Table 1: Admission data for Women Y = 1 Y = 2 Y = 3 Y = 4 Y = 5 Y = 6 X = 0 X = 1 0.011 0.004 0.213 0.133 0.163 0.173 0.048 0.009 0.110 0.072 0.051 0.013 Table 2: Admission data for Men V = 1 V = 2 V = 3 V = 4 V = 5 V = 6 U = 0 U = 1 0.116 0.080 0.076 0.104 0.051 0.130 0.190 0.129 0.045 0.051 0.020 0.008 a) Are X and Y independent? What about U and V? Justify your answers mathematically, and explain what this means in terms of the problem (keep your explanation as simple as possible). b) Find the narginal dintributions of X and U. Explain what this meato in terma of the problem. Do you see why UC Berkley we being mued? c) Now consider only those studenta who applied for department 4. Find the conditional distribution of X given that Y 4 and the conditional distribution of U given that V=4. Conditional on this department, is there a strong differenoe between the admission rates c) Repeat part e), conditional on each departament Y-1,2,6 and fill in the following table. In the end, do you think UC Berkeley committed gender dliscrimination? Table k Conditional Probahilities Women Men P(X = 1Y = 1) PU-1V = 1) P(U = 1|V = 2) P(U - 1|V -3) P(U - V = 4) P(X = 1{Y = 2 P(X =1Y = 3) P(X = 1|Y = 4) P(X - 1Y-5) PU = 1|V -5) P(U - 1V = 6) P(X = 1|Y =6) 4. Simpson's Paradox. Simpson's parador occurs when groups of data shouw one particular trend, but this trend is reversed when the groups are combined together. Understanding and identifying this paradox is important for correctly interpreting data. In this problem, we explore how UC Berkeley almost got sued for sex discrimination. The following tables summarize the graduate school admissions from 1973. The variables X and U represent admission status for women (X) and men (Y), where 1 indicates and acceptance into the program and 0 represents rejection. There are also 6 departments, summarized by the random variables Y (for women) and V (for men), where each value corresponds to a different department. Table 1: Admission data for Women Y = 1 Y = 2 Y = 3 Y = 4 Y = 5 Y = 6 X = 0 X = 1 0.011 0.004 0.213 0.133 0.163 0.173 0.048 0.009 0.110 0.072 0.051 0.013 Table 2: Admission data for Men V = 1 V = 2 V = 3 V = 4 V = 5 V = 6 U = 0 U = 1 0.116 0.080 0.076 0.104 0.051 0.130 0.190 0.129 0.045 0.051 0.020 0.008 a) Are X and Y independent? What about U and V? Justify your answers mathematically, and explain what this means in terms of the problem (keep your explanation as simple as possible). b) Find the narginal dintributions of X and U. Explain what this meato in terma of the problem. Do you see why UC Berkley we being mued? c) Now consider only those studenta who applied for department 4. Find the conditional distribution of X given that Y 4 and the conditional distribution of U given that V=4. Conditional on this department, is there a strong differenoe between the admission rates c) Repeat part e), conditional on each departament Y-1,2,6 and fill in the following table. In the end, do you think UC Berkeley committed gender dliscrimination? Table k Conditional Probahilities Women Men P(X = 1Y = 1) PU-1V = 1) P(U = 1|V = 2) P(U - 1|V -3) P(U - V = 4) P(X = 1{Y = 2 P(X =1Y = 3) P(X = 1|Y = 4) P(X - 1Y-5) PU = 1|V -5) P(U - 1V = 6) P(X = 1|Y =6)
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Above table indicates the graduate school admission There are two tables one for women and the other ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Fundamentals of Investments Valuation and Management
ISBN: 978-0077283292
5th edition
Authors: Bradford D. Jordan, Thomas W. Miller
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
In this problem we explore the use of singular value decomposition (SVD) as an alternative to the discrete Fourier transform for vector coding. This approach avoids the need (or a cyclic prefix, with...
-
In this problem we explore another method fur the approximate realization of a matched filter, this time using the simple resistance-capacitance (RC) low-pass filter shown in Figure. The frequency...
-
Discrimination occurs when disadvantaged groups like women or African-Americans are segmented into low-wage markets. Explain how each of the following practices, which prevailed in some cases until...
-
Pritchett Company reported the following year-end data: Cash $ 25,000 8,000 Short-term investments Accounts receivable (current) Inventory 19,500 27,500 Prepaid (current) assets 11,000 Total current...
-
Myrtle loaned Sven $150,000 for his gardening supplies company. A drought occurred during the year. Because Sven was unable to repay the loan, Myrtle accepted the following plan to extinguish Svens...
-
Assume the following scenarios. Scenario 1. During 2015, Makers Consulting provides services of $100,000. The company receives an initial payment of $75,000 with the balance to be received the...
-
In June 2014, Biltmore Construction Company (BCC) was hired by the City of Phoenix, Arizona, to assist in constructing its new Trade Center complex. The construction agreement called for work to...
-
Use the following financial statements and additional information to (1) Prepare a statement of cash flows for the year ended June 30, 2009, using the indirect method, and (2) Compute the companys...
-
'Despite its undisputed significance, the principle of supremacy has not been firmly established in the EU Legal order.' Critically discuss this statement. In your answer, refer to relevant...
-
Comprehensive Problem 1 - Part 1: Taxpayer information, Form 1040, Schedules 1, 2, 3 and 4, Schedule A, and Schedule B. Noah and Joan Arc's Tax Return Note: This problem is divided into three parts....
-
Solve the initial value problem (2+^2) +2 = 0, (0)=0, (0)=5. If the solution is =0+1+2^2+3^3+4^4+5^5+6^6+7^7+ enter the following coefficients: 0= 1= 2= 3= 4= 5= 6= 7=
-
Assume that it is now January 1, 2022. Wayne-Martin Electric Inc. (WME) has developed a solar panel capable of generating 200% more electricity than any other solar panel currently on the market. As...
-
The electronic components of a computer consume 0.1 kW of electrical power. To prevent overheating, cooling air is supplied by a 40-W fan mounted at the inlet of the electronics enclosure. At steady...
-
Factor by grouping. 10x-xw-5x+2w
-
Some argue that globalization promotes diversity, but others say that it makes cultures the same. Does globalization help spread cultural diversity, or does it result in global monoculture?
-
You invested a portfolio of commons stocks six years ago. The stock had the following annual returns. Year 1 (10%) Year 2 12% Year 3 8% Year 4 15% Year 5 (6%) Year 6 (5%) Given this information,...
-
(CO 2) A calculated field may contain the following elements except an arithmetic operator. a hyperlink. a built in function with built in calculations. a constant or value that doesnt change.
-
What is the order p of a B + -tree? Describe the structure of both internal and leaf nodes of a B + -tree.
-
What is the PE ratio reported for stocks in The Wall Street Journal? In particular, how is it computed?
-
What are the conditional prepayment rates for seasoned 50 PSA, 200 PSA, and 400 PSA mortgages if the 100 PSA benchmark is 5 percent per year? How do you interpret these numbers?
-
Donna Doni, CFA, wants to explore inefficiencies in the futures market. The TOBEC stock index has a spot value of 185 now. TOBEC futures are settled in cash and underlying contract values are...
-
The long run a. is a period in which a firm can adjust all its inputs. b. can vary in length from industry to industry. c. is a period in which all costs are variable costs. d. is characterized by...
-
Which of the following most accurately describes the long-run period? a. The long run is a period of time in which a firm is unable to vary some of its factors of production. b. In the long run, a...
-
The short run a. is a period too brief for any inputs to be varied. b. is a period that involves no fixed costs. c. is normally a period of 1 year. d. is none of the above.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App