A director of a mental health agency over-represents the number of clients his agency served for...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
A director of a mental health agency over-represents the number of clients his agency served for the previous year. The agency gets funds from the state based on how many clients it serves each year. The director knows that if he were to report the correct number of clients, the agency would get significantly less money to use for the next year. A reduction in funds would mean that some staff would have to be laid off, causing the agency to help even fewer clients. A supervisor allows her staff to take an hour for lunch even though company policy allows only 30 minute lunch breaks. The supervisor's philosophy is that as long as her employees get their work done, it won't make a difference if they are allowed an hour for lunch instead of 30 minutes. A big brother raised in a family who believes that honesty is always the best policy tells his little sister that she looks great in her new dress, even though he thinks she looks terrible. The examples above involve people in leadership positions. A leader is someone people look up to and are willing to follow; it is a person who is able to get others to reach a goal, who is in a position to guide and influence others' behavior and professional and personal lives; and it is a person of integrity. So based on that definition, any one of us can be, and have been, leaders at one time or another. A professor is a leader in his or her classroom; a director is the leader of an agency; a supervisor is the leader of her department; and an older brother is, or should be, a leader of his younger siblings. What the leaders in the above examples have in common is that they are bending the rules. Bending the rules means going against policy, regulations, or rules, whether they are set by the leader, as in the professor's dassroom policy of failing students with poor attendance, or set by an organization, such as the policy of 30-minute lunch breaks for all employees. There are two thoughts about this concept of "bending the rules": One is that it is unethical and the other is that is it necessary. Those who believe it is necessary to bend the rules will say that all rules are meant to be broken. Proponents of bending the rules say that it's a moral cop-out when leaders choose not to bend the rules in situations where bending the rules, going against policy, is actually the right and ethical thing to do. For example, in the first situation above, the reason why that one student missed so many days during the semester is because he had cancer and his treatments often made him too sick to come to class. In this case, say the supporters of bending the rules, for the professor to say, "I must abide by my policy," would be a moral cop-out against doing the responsible thing. Sometimes, they say, a leader has to bend the rules for the bigger good. However, critics of leaders who bend the rules say that a policy is a policy-it's there for a reason and should be followed at all times. If a leader doesn't like the policy or rule, that leader should do what is necessary to change the policy so that he or should won't have to bend it. So, these critics might say in the previous example that the professor, in her policy, should state that allowances should be made for students who miss classes due to a long-term illness. If that wasn't stated in her policy, then it would be unethical for her to break the policy, no matter the reason. Bending the rules breaks trust with others. Critics hold leaders to a higher standard than other employees. Because leaders are, or should be, role models, anything they do is often accepted and copied by others. So, if a leader breaks a policy, what they are saying to others is that it is okay to bend the rules and break policies. What Do You Think? In the first situation, do you think it is unethical for the professor to bend the rules under those circumstances? If you were one of the students failed because of high absenteeism and you found out that the professor didn't fail another student for his high absenteeism, would you think you were being treated unfairly? What would you do? Do you think what the leaders did in the other examples was ethical? Why or why not? In the example with the brother, is it okay to lie in this situation? Do you consider lying as unethical? Are there ever times when lying is better than telling the truth? What are some situations in which bending the rules might be more ethical than following policy? A director of a mental health agency over-represents the number of clients his agency served for the previous year. The agency gets funds from the state based on how many clients it serves each year. The director knows that if he were to report the correct number of clients, the agency would get significantly less money to use for the next year. A reduction in funds would mean that some staff would have to be laid off, causing the agency to help even fewer clients. A supervisor allows her staff to take an hour for lunch even though company policy allows only 30 minute lunch breaks. The supervisor's philosophy is that as long as her employees get their work done, it won't make a difference if they are allowed an hour for lunch instead of 30 minutes. A big brother raised in a family who believes that honesty is always the best policy tells his little sister that she looks great in her new dress, even though he thinks she looks terrible. The examples above involve people in leadership positions. A leader is someone people look up to and are willing to follow; it is a person who is able to get others to reach a goal, who is in a position to guide and influence others' behavior and professional and personal lives; and it is a person of integrity. So based on that definition, any one of us can be, and have been, leaders at one time or another. A professor is a leader in his or her classroom; a director is the leader of an agency; a supervisor is the leader of her department; and an older brother is, or should be, a leader of his younger siblings. What the leaders in the above examples have in common is that they are bending the rules. Bending the rules means going against policy, regulations, or rules, whether they are set by the leader, as in the professor's dassroom policy of failing students with poor attendance, or set by an organization, such as the policy of 30-minute lunch breaks for all employees. There are two thoughts about this concept of "bending the rules": One is that it is unethical and the other is that is it necessary. Those who believe it is necessary to bend the rules will say that all rules are meant to be broken. Proponents of bending the rules say that it's a moral cop-out when leaders choose not to bend the rules in situations where bending the rules, going against policy, is actually the right and ethical thing to do. For example, in the first situation above, the reason why that one student missed so many days during the semester is because he had cancer and his treatments often made him too sick to come to class. In this case, say the supporters of bending the rules, for the professor to say, "I must abide by my policy," would be a moral cop-out against doing the responsible thing. Sometimes, they say, a leader has to bend the rules for the bigger good. However, critics of leaders who bend the rules say that a policy is a policy-it's there for a reason and should be followed at all times. If a leader doesn't like the policy or rule, that leader should do what is necessary to change the policy so that he or should won't have to bend it. So, these critics might say in the previous example that the professor, in her policy, should state that allowances should be made for students who miss classes due to a long-term illness. If that wasn't stated in her policy, then it would be unethical for her to break the policy, no matter the reason. Bending the rules breaks trust with others. Critics hold leaders to a higher standard than other employees. Because leaders are, or should be, role models, anything they do is often accepted and copied by others. So, if a leader breaks a policy, what they are saying to others is that it is okay to bend the rules and break policies. What Do You Think? In the first situation, do you think it is unethical for the professor to bend the rules under those circumstances? If you were one of the students failed because of high absenteeism and you found out that the professor didn't fail another student for his high absenteeism, would you think you were being treated unfairly? What would you do? Do you think what the leaders did in the other examples was ethical? Why or why not? In the example with the brother, is it okay to lie in this situation? Do you consider lying as unethical? Are there ever times when lying is better than telling the truth? What are some situations in which bending the rules might be more ethical than following policy?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
These scenarios raise complex ethical questions about leadership rule adherence and the balancing act between following policies and doing what is morally right Lets break down each scenario and consi... View the full answer
Related Book For
Introduction To Health Care Management
ISBN: 9781284081015
3rd Edition
Authors: Sharon B. Buchbinder, Nancy H. Shanks
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these psychology questions
-
Jim McNerney is racking up quite a record at 3M. Now, can he rev up its innovation machine? Jim McNerney was one of those boys: up early in the morning climbing trees while everybody else in the...
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
Which statement about the pass-by-reference is NOT true? a.Every time you pass a reference variable to a method, you also pass the object referred by the refenerece variable to the method. b.In the...
-
How does a change the supply of money change the interest rate in the short run?
-
Based on the following information, calculate the expected return and standard deviation for the two stocks. Rate of Return If State Occurs Probability of State of Economy State of Economy Stock A...
-
A 1:16 model of a bus is tested in a wind tunnel in standard air. The model is \(152 \mathrm{~mm}\) wide, \(200 \mathrm{~mm}\) high, and \(762 \mathrm{~mm}\) long. The measured drag force at \(26.5...
-
Presented below are incomplete manufacturing cost data. Determine the missing amounts for three different situations. Direct Materials Total Manufacturing Costs Direct Labor Used Factory Overhead...
-
What is the future value of $2,400 in 17 years assuming an interest rate of 7.9 percent compounded semiannually? Deposit Number of years Interest rate Times compounded per year $ 2,400 17 7.9% 2...
-
Conduct a regression analysis to explain the dollar sales volume of a salesperson using the data from your Marketing research and financial reports. Discuss the results (signs of coefficients,...
-
What is meant by the statement Programmer time is an efficiency consideration? Give an example of a situation in which programmer time is used to justify the choice of an algorithm (possibly at the...
-
In Chapter 6, we discussed how to store a linked list in an array of nodes using index values as pointers and managing our list of free nodes. We can use these same techniques to store the nodes of a...
-
If node 1 is to be deleted, the value in which node could be used to replace it? The numbers on the nodes are labels so that we can talk about the nodes; they are not key values within the nodes. 4 2...
-
Extend the class GraphType in this chapter to include a DeleteVertex operation, which deletes a vertex from the graph. Deleting a vertex from a graph is more complicated than deleting an edge....
-
1. Declare a two-dimensional array, decadeWeather, of WeatherType components, to be indexed by values of type MonthType in the first dimension. 2. Draw a picture of decadeWeather. 3. Assign the value...
-
You just had terry, one of your team members from marketing, give a presentation to the engineering group about the new product and its importance to the companys product line. The presentation...
-
Chicago Company sold merchandise to a customer for $1,500 cash in a state with a 6% sales tax rate. The total amount of cash collected from the customer was $558. $600. $642. $636. Nevada Company...
-
In an absorption refrigeration system, the heat energy \(Q_{1}\) is supplied at temperature \(T_{1}\) while the system absorbs heat energy \(Q_{3}\) from a cold space at temperature \(T_{3}\). If the...
-
In an ideal gas mixture consisting of components \(A\) and \(B\), the mole fraction of component \(A\) is equal to (a) \(n_{\mathrm{A}}=\frac{p_{\mathrm{A}}+p_{\mathrm{B}}}{P}\) (b)...
-
The availability of a system (a) Depends upon the conditions of the system only (b) Is independent of the conditions of the surroundings (c) Does not depend upon the conditions of the system (d)...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App