A forensic scientist received an analysis request (discipline not relevant) and was asked to compare a...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
A forensic scientist received an analysis request (discipline not relevant) and was asked to compare a set of questioned specimens with a set of reference samples to evaluate, as per the request, whether or not the two sets share a common origin. After conducting a comparative examination, the expert observes some concordances and also some dissimilarities between the compared features of the two sets of items. The expert estimates that the balance between similarities and dissimilarities is expected with a probability of 80% for items actually matching. The expert also consults a database of similar objects and estimates a random match probability of 1/2000. Considering the uncertainties related to her observations, the expert decides to report her findings following the principles of evidence interpretation originally enunciated by Evett. a) Discuss each principle by Evett as specifically applied to the present scenario (note: I am not asking for what the principles say in general, but how you apply them to this scenario) (6 points). b) Based on the present scenario, how is the evidential value expressed numerically? (Note: I am asking for numbers, not theoretical (2 points). explanations) c) Following the logic in a) and b), how should the expert report the evidential value in her report? (2 points). A forensic scientist received an analysis request (discipline not relevant) and was asked to compare a set of questioned specimens with a set of reference samples to evaluate, as per the request, whether or not the two sets share a common origin. After conducting a comparative examination, the expert observes some concordances and also some dissimilarities between the compared features of the two sets of items. The expert estimates that the balance between similarities and dissimilarities is expected with a probability of 80% for items actually matching. The expert also consults a database of similar objects and estimates a random match probability of 1/2000. Considering the uncertainties related to her observations, the expert decides to report her findings following the principles of evidence interpretation originally enunciated by Evett. a) Discuss each principle by Evett as specifically applied to the present scenario (note: I am not asking for what the principles say in general, but how you apply them to this scenario) (6 points). b) Based on the present scenario, how is the evidential value expressed numerically? (Note: I am asking for numbers, not theoretical (2 points). explanations) c) Following the logic in a) and b), how should the expert report the evidential value in her report? (2 points).
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
aThe first principle is that the analyst should make no assumption about the hypothesis being tested and should instead base their report only on the ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Business Law Principles and Practices
ISBN: 978-1133586562
9th edition
Authors: Arnold J. Goldman, William D. Sigismond
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
Which one of the following results from the latest decision round are least important in providing guidance to company managers in making their strategic moves and decisions to improve their...
-
On November 1, 20X6, Smith Imports Inc. contracted to purchase teacups from England for 30,000. The teacups were to be delivered on January 30, 20X7, with payment due on March 1, 20X7. On November 1,...
-
An \(R C\) series circuit is excited by a sinusoidal source \(v(t)=V_{\mathrm{A}} \cos (\omega t+\phi) \mathrm{V}\). Determine the effects on the magnitudes of the current, voltages, and impedances...
-
An electronic instrument of mass \(10 \mathrm{~kg}\) is mounted on an isolation pad. If the base of the isolation pad is subjected to a shock in the form of a step velocity of \(10 \mathrm{~mm} /...
-
This problem continues the Draper Consulting, Inc., situation from Problem 7-42 of Chapter 7. Draper reviewed the receivables list from the January transactions (from Chapter 6). Draper identified on...
-
Derive a formula for the thermal resistance, R., for a spherical shell assuming one- dimensional heat flux in the radial direction. The inside and outside radii of the spherical shell are r; and r.,...
-
Calculate the following four reliability coefficients using the Pearson product-moment correlation formula, correlate the scores to determine the reliability coefficient (xx). Show your work. 3....
-
A company can purchase an item they need for a project for $13,500 and it has daily operating costs of $160, or they Can lease the item for $540 per day. Perform a lease-or-buy analysis to decide if...
-
What qualitative factors should analysts consider when evaluating a companys likely future financial performance?
-
What is the equity multiplier?
-
Indicate whether each of the following statements is true or false by writing T or F in t he a nswer c olumn. A use tax is a tax to a consumer who uses goods within a state, as opposed to buying them...
-
What is a proxy fight?
-
Identify and write out the equations for four profitability ratios.
-
You and a project team member haven't been on the same page since the project started. A lot can get lost in translation in written communication.Unfortunately, this is a person you have to work...
-
Suppose that the laptop of Prob. 2.16 is placed in an insulating briefcase with a fully charged battery, but it does not go into sleep mode, and the battery discharges as if the laptop were in use....
-
Nathan, a 22- year- old nurse, worked in the surgical ward of Presbyterian Hospital in New York City. She was exposed for a period of about twelve days to a patient who had tuberculosis. As a result,...
-
Curran bought a new car from Superior Motors. He paid $ 1,000 in cash and gave a promissory note for the balance of the purchase price. Superior negotiated the note to Calumet Bank and received cash...
-
In order for a consumer to successfully sue and win her case against a seller (e. g., a manufacturer) for injury under the theory of strict liability, what proof must be introduced in court?
-
For an ideal solution, isotherm on an enthalpy-concentration diagram will be (a) Parabola (b) Hyperbola (c) Sine curve (d) Straight line
-
For a reversible process, change in entropy of the system (a) Approaches to zero (b) Increases (c) Decreases (d) Remains constant
-
For a multi-component system, the chemical potential is equivalent to (a) Molar free energy (b) Molar concentration difference (c) Molar free energy change (d) Partial molar free energy
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App