MAYER v. BELICHICK 605 F.3d 223 (3rd Cir.) Season ticket-holder brought action against the New England...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
MAYER v. BELICHICK 605 F.3d 223 (3rd Cir.) Season ticket-holder brought action against the New England Patriots and league, alleging various causes of action, including tortuous interference with contract as well as causes of action under consumer fraud and deceptive practice statutes, arising out of the team's alleged practice of surreptitiously videotaping the sig- nals of opposing teams. The United States District Court for the District of New Jersey granted defendant's motions to dismiss, and the ticketholder appeale COWEN, Circuit Judge Plaintiff Carl J. Mayer appeals from the order of the United States District Court for the District of New Jersey granting the respective motions to dismiss filed by Defendants Bill Belichick and the New England Patriots ("Patriots") as well as by Defendant National Football League ("NFL"). We will affirm. 1. This highly unusual case was filed by a disap- pointed football fan and season ticket-holder in response to the so-called "Spygate" scandal. This scandal arose when it was discovered that the Patri- ots were surreptitiously videotaping the signals of their opponents. Mayer, a New Jersey resident and New York Jets season ticket-holder, initially filed his complaint on September 7, 2007. He named as Defendants the Patriots, headquartered in Massachusetts, as well as the team's head coach, Belichick, a Massachusetts resident. Mayer even- Massachusetts, as well as the team's head coach, Belichick, a Massachusetts resident. Mayer even- tually filed an amended complaint on August 19, 2008, which added the NFL, with its headquarters in New York, as a Defendant. We, like the Dis- trict Court before us, must look to the amended complaint, accepting its well pleaded factual alle- gations as true for purposes of this appeal. The Preliminary Statement of the Case section of this extensive pleading provided a fair description of the gist of Mayer's case, at least against the Patri- ots and Belichick: 2. This case is brought by a New York Jets season ticket-holder on behalf of all similarly situated New York Jets season ticket-holders and other New York Jets ticket-holders against the Defen- dant New England Patriots and their coach, Defendant Bill Belichick. The core of this action is that the Defendants, during a game with the New York Jets on September 9, 2007, instructed 96 t r O V ti pla Ru par on an agent of the Defendants to surreptitiously vid- eotape the New York Jets coaches and players c the field with the purpose of illegally recording, capturing and stealing the New York Jets signals and visual coaching instructions. The Defendants were in fact subsequently found by the National Football League ("NFL") to have improperly engaged in such conduct. This violated the con- tractual expectations and rights of New York Jets ticket-holders who fully anticipated and con- tracted for a ticket to observe an honest match played in compliance with all laws, regulations and NFL rules. anisla, priboste daildst.ol At their most fundamental level, the various claims alleged here arose out of the repeated and surreptitious violations of a specific NFL rule. This rule provides that "no video recording devices of any kind are per- mitted to be in use in the coaches' booth, on the field, or in the locker room during the game"" and that "all video for coaching purposes must be shot from loca- tions 'enclosed on all sides with a roof overhead."" On September 9, 2007, the Jets and the Patriots played the season opener in Giants Stadium, East Rutherford, New Jersey. Mayer possessed tickets and parking passes to this game, and the Patriots ultimately >> CASE QUESTIONS 1. What was the legal basis for Mayer's claims? 2. What does it mean when the court holds that "Mayer failed to set forth a legally cognizable right, interest, or injury"? 3. Why did the District Court and the Third Circuit dismiss Mayer's claims? MAYER v. BELICHICK 605 F.3d 223 (3rd Cir.) Season ticket-holder brought action against the New England Patriots and league, alleging various causes of action, including tortuous interference with contract as well as causes of action under consumer fraud and deceptive practice statutes, arising out of the team's alleged practice of surreptitiously videotaping the sig- nals of opposing teams. The United States District Court for the District of New Jersey granted defendant's motions to dismiss, and the ticketholder appeale COWEN, Circuit Judge Plaintiff Carl J. Mayer appeals from the order of the United States District Court for the District of New Jersey granting the respective motions to dismiss filed by Defendants Bill Belichick and the New England Patriots ("Patriots") as well as by Defendant National Football League ("NFL"). We will affirm. 1. This highly unusual case was filed by a disap- pointed football fan and season ticket-holder in response to the so-called "Spygate" scandal. This scandal arose when it was discovered that the Patri- ots were surreptitiously videotaping the signals of their opponents. Mayer, a New Jersey resident and New York Jets season ticket-holder, initially filed his complaint on September 7, 2007. He named as Defendants the Patriots, headquartered in Massachusetts, as well as the team's head coach, Belichick, a Massachusetts resident. Mayer even- Massachusetts, as well as the team's head coach, Belichick, a Massachusetts resident. Mayer even- tually filed an amended complaint on August 19, 2008, which added the NFL, with its headquarters in New York, as a Defendant. We, like the Dis- trict Court before us, must look to the amended complaint, accepting its well pleaded factual alle- gations as true for purposes of this appeal. The Preliminary Statement of the Case section of this extensive pleading provided a fair description of the gist of Mayer's case, at least against the Patri- ots and Belichick: 2. This case is brought by a New York Jets season ticket-holder on behalf of all similarly situated New York Jets season ticket-holders and other New York Jets ticket-holders against the Defen- dant New England Patriots and their coach, Defendant Bill Belichick. The core of this action is that the Defendants, during a game with the New York Jets on September 9, 2007, instructed 96 t r O V ti pla Ru par on an agent of the Defendants to surreptitiously vid- eotape the New York Jets coaches and players c the field with the purpose of illegally recording, capturing and stealing the New York Jets signals and visual coaching instructions. The Defendants were in fact subsequently found by the National Football League ("NFL") to have improperly engaged in such conduct. This violated the con- tractual expectations and rights of New York Jets ticket-holders who fully anticipated and con- tracted for a ticket to observe an honest match played in compliance with all laws, regulations and NFL rules. anisla, priboste daildst.ol At their most fundamental level, the various claims alleged here arose out of the repeated and surreptitious violations of a specific NFL rule. This rule provides that "no video recording devices of any kind are per- mitted to be in use in the coaches' booth, on the field, or in the locker room during the game"" and that "all video for coaching purposes must be shot from loca- tions 'enclosed on all sides with a roof overhead."" On September 9, 2007, the Jets and the Patriots played the season opener in Giants Stadium, East Rutherford, New Jersey. Mayer possessed tickets and parking passes to this game, and the Patriots ultimately >> CASE QUESTIONS 1. What was the legal basis for Mayer's claims? 2. What does it mean when the court holds that "Mayer failed to set forth a legally cognizable right, interest, or injury"? 3. Why did the District Court and the Third Circuit dismiss Mayer's claims?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 Mayers claims were based on the NFLs rules regarding the use of video recording devices The NFLs r... View the full answer
Related Book For
Behavioral Finance Psychology Decision-Making and Markets
ISBN: 978-0324661170
1st edition
Authors: Lucy Ackert
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these law questions
-
The norm of a linear transformation TA: Rn Rn can be defined by where the maximum is taken over all nonzero x in Rn. (The subscript indicates that the norm of the linear transformation on the left is...
-
Suppose that f: Rn R and g: Rn Rn are differentiable on Rn and that there exist r > 0 and a Rn such that Dg(x) is the identity matrix, I, for all x Br(a). Prove that there is a function h: Br(a) {a}...
-
Let 5: Rn Rn and T: Rn Rn be linear transformations with matrices A and B respectively. [Theorem 3.] (a) Show that B2 = B if and only if T2 = 7 (where T2 means T o T). (b) Show that B2 = 1 if and...
-
Pew Research published survey results from two random samples. Both samples were asked, Have you listened to an audio book in the last year? The results are shown in the table below. a. Find and...
-
A study by the Pew Internet and American Life Project (pewinternet.org) found that Americans had a complex and ambivalent attitude toward technology. (Data extracted from M. Himowitz, "How to Tell...
-
Simplify the given algebraic expressions. aZ [3 (aZ + 4)]
-
When water discharges from a tank through an opening in its bottom, a vortex may form with a curved surface profile, as shown in Fig. P6.41. Assume that the velocity distribution in the vortex is the...
-
Kenny Co. began operations on January 1, 2010, by issuing at $15 per share one half of the 950,000 shares of $1 par value common stock that had been authorized for sale. In addition, Kenny has...
-
The following information was obtained from the annual report of A Ltd of the current year. Income statement: Sales 4200 Cost of sales -1680 Other operating expenses -630 Profit before interest and...
-
Refer to Fig. 9.15, which shows three pipes inside a larger pipe. The inside pipes carry water at 200°F and the large pipe carries water at 60F. The average velocity of flow is 25.0 ft/s in each...
-
i need help solving the error coding below, i use programing language c# please provide steps of how you fixed these problems, showed how you fixed them, and making sure the code runs fine thank you,...
-
According to a study, the probability that a randomly selected person has hearing problems is 0.149. The probability that a randomly selected person has vision problems is 0.085. Can we compute the...
-
You have just purchased a car and taken out a $52,000 loan. The loan has a five-year term with monthly payments and an APR of 5.7%. a. How much will you pay in interest, and how much will you pay in...
-
Experiment with a compression utility (e.g., compress, gzip, or pkzip). What compression ratios are you able to achieve? See if you can generate data files for which you can achieve 5:1 or 10:1...
-
What is the value of resistor \(R\) in Figure P23.22? Figure P23.22 1002 AV = 5.0 V 1532 R wwwwwww I= 100 mA
-
Use estimation to select the best response in Problems 5-10. Do not calculate. Of these three means of travel, the safest is A. car B. train C. plane
-
The International Accounting Standard's Board (IASB) has published the Framework for the Preparation and Presentation of Financial Statements which guides the preparation of financial statements....
-
By referring to Figure 13.18, determine the mass of each of the following salts required to form a saturated solution in 250 g of water at 30 oC: (a) KClO3, (b) Pb(NO3)2, (c) Ce2(SO4)3.
-
What do experimental bubble markets teach us about the likelihood of bubbles in the real world? In what sense does this research have its limitations?
-
In a regression of perceived long-term investment value (LTIV) on size (S), book to market (B/M), and management quality (MQ), the following coefficients (all significant) were estimated: LTIV = -.86...
-
What does research based on the game show Deal or No Deal tell us about path-dependence and integration vs. segregation of gambles?
-
A hydraulic lift in a service station has a \(32.50-\mathrm{cm}\)-diameter ram that slides in a \(32.52-\mathrm{cm}\)-diameter cylinder. The annular space is filled with SAE 10 oil at \(20^{\circ}...
-
A 10-kg block slides down a smooth inclined surface as shown in Fig. P1.80. Determine the terminal velocity of the block if the \(0.1-\mathrm{mm}\) gap between the block and the surface contains SAE...
-
Oil (absolute viscosity \(=0.0003 \mathrm{lb} \cdot \mathrm{s} / \mathrm{ft}^{2}\), density \(=50\) \(\mathrm{lbm} / \mathrm{ft}^{3}\) ) flows in the boundary layer, as shown in Fig. P1.82. The plate...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App