Acme Aviation (AA) entered into an agreement with the Fast Deliveries (FD) for AA to fly...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Acme Aviation (AA) entered into an agreement with the Fast Deliveries (FD) for AA to fly packages for FD on an "as needed" basis. The agreement was for three years. After the first year, AA was not making any money on this agreement and notified FD that it would no longer honor the agreement. Fast Deliv- eries was forced to find another company to fly the packages that previously would have been flown by Acme. Fast Deliveries claimed that the cost of the new carrier added $250,000 a year to its expenses. Four years after Acme Aviation defaulted on the contract, Fast Deliveries filed for bankruptcy. In a subsequent lawsuit, Fast Deliveries sued Acme Aviation for $6 million, claiming that AA's de- fault on the delivery contract caused FD to incur sig- nificant additional costs, and this eventually forced them into bankruptcy. During discovery the follow- ing issues were uncovered: FD used AA for about 20 percent of its deliver- ies during the one year the contract was oper- ating. An internal AA memo states that the market- ing manager said, "I don't care what our legal obligations are under the contract with FD, we are losing money so end it." (the contract). During the three years prior to the start of the AA/ FD contract, FD had earnings (losses) of $125,000, $(150,000), and $(175,000) respectively. In an AA internal memo, the company stated that it had lost about $300,000 in the first year of the FD contract due, in part, to the varying volume of deliveries requested by FD throughout the year. AA fired the marketing person who secured the FD contract and used the FD contract as an ex- ample of poor analysis of potential sales con- tracts as part of the documentation for the firing. An FD accounting department analysis of FD's de- livery costs showed that direct costs of delivery were $140,000 per year higher for the delivery service used to replace AA. The other $110,000 of additional costs was corporate overhead allo- cated to the delivery service contract. FD's financial statements showed that it had loss- es of $(175,000) and $(260,000) during the two years after the end of the AA contract but before FD filed for bankruptcy. FD's asset book value at the date bankruptcy was filed was $3,500,000, but the estimated liqui- dation value of its assets was estimated at only $1,000,000. An FD accounting department analysis estimated that during a six-month period after AA defaulted on the delivery contract, FD had trouble finding acceptable delivery alternatives. As a result, the analysis found that the firm lost approximately $800,000 in delivery sales. The issue of liability here is primarily a legal one. There is little chance that accounting issues will be addressed in determining liability. For purposes of this conflict, assume that the three-year contract was binding and that AA is liable for damages result- ing from the two years it did not honor the contract. You are an expert that has been hired by Fast Deliveries to develop a damages estimate for them that you will defend in deposition and at trial, if necessary. Using the information pro- vided prepare a preliminary damages estimate and explain the basis for your opinion on each item. Identify any questions or information you would like to see or analyze to support your damages estimate. a. b. You are an expert that has been hired by Acme Aviation to develop a damages estimate for them that you will defend in deposition and at trial if necessary. Using the information pro- vided prepare a preliminary damages estimate and explain the basis for your opinion on each item. Identify any questions or information you would like to see or analyze to support your damages estimate. Acme Aviation (AA) entered into an agreement with the Fast Deliveries (FD) for AA to fly packages for FD on an "as needed" basis. The agreement was for three years. After the first year, AA was not making any money on this agreement and notified FD that it would no longer honor the agreement. Fast Deliv- eries was forced to find another company to fly the packages that previously would have been flown by Acme. Fast Deliveries claimed that the cost of the new carrier added $250,000 a year to its expenses. Four years after Acme Aviation defaulted on the contract, Fast Deliveries filed for bankruptcy. In a subsequent lawsuit, Fast Deliveries sued Acme Aviation for $6 million, claiming that AA's de- fault on the delivery contract caused FD to incur sig- nificant additional costs, and this eventually forced them into bankruptcy. During discovery the follow- ing issues were uncovered: FD used AA for about 20 percent of its deliver- ies during the one year the contract was oper- ating. An internal AA memo states that the market- ing manager said, "I don't care what our legal obligations are under the contract with FD, we are losing money so end it." (the contract). During the three years prior to the start of the AA/ FD contract, FD had earnings (losses) of $125,000, $(150,000), and $(175,000) respectively. In an AA internal memo, the company stated that it had lost about $300,000 in the first year of the FD contract due, in part, to the varying volume of deliveries requested by FD throughout the year. AA fired the marketing person who secured the FD contract and used the FD contract as an ex- ample of poor analysis of potential sales con- tracts as part of the documentation for the firing. An FD accounting department analysis of FD's de- livery costs showed that direct costs of delivery were $140,000 per year higher for the delivery service used to replace AA. The other $110,000 of additional costs was corporate overhead allo- cated to the delivery service contract. FD's financial statements showed that it had loss- es of $(175,000) and $(260,000) during the two years after the end of the AA contract but before FD filed for bankruptcy. FD's asset book value at the date bankruptcy was filed was $3,500,000, but the estimated liqui- dation value of its assets was estimated at only $1,000,000. An FD accounting department analysis estimated that during a six-month period after AA defaulted on the delivery contract, FD had trouble finding acceptable delivery alternatives. As a result, the analysis found that the firm lost approximately $800,000 in delivery sales. The issue of liability here is primarily a legal one. There is little chance that accounting issues will be addressed in determining liability. For purposes of this conflict, assume that the three-year contract was binding and that AA is liable for damages result- ing from the two years it did not honor the contract. You are an expert that has been hired by Fast Deliveries to develop a damages estimate for them that you will defend in deposition and at trial, if necessary. Using the information pro- vided prepare a preliminary damages estimate and explain the basis for your opinion on each item. Identify any questions or information you would like to see or analyze to support your damages estimate. a. b. You are an expert that has been hired by Acme Aviation to develop a damages estimate for them that you will defend in deposition and at trial if necessary. Using the information pro- vided prepare a preliminary damages estimate and explain the basis for your opinion on each item. Identify any questions or information you would like to see or analyze to support your damages estimate.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
a Expert preliminary damages estimate from Fast deliveries point of view Losses incurred two years by Fast Deliveries after AcmeAviation defaulted the... View the full answer
Related Book For
Intermediate Accounting Reporting and Analysis
ISBN: 978-1285453828
2nd edition
Authors: James M. Wahlen, Jefferson P. Jones, Donald Pagach
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
In 1988, Semetex entered into an agreement with the Al-Mansour Factory in Baghdad, Iraq, an enterprise owned and operated by the government of Iraq, in which Semetex agreed to provide Al-Mansour with...
-
In 1991, EnerSys entered into an agreement with Exide Technologies to purchase substantially all of Exide's battery business for about $135 million. To formalize this sale, the parties entered into...
-
On January 1, 2011, Hunter Ltd. entered into an agreement to lease a truck from Situ Ltd. Both Hunter and Situ use IFRS. The details of the agreement are as follows: Carrying value of truck for Situ...
-
Format only cells with values greater than maxim 4 tab and select Red color from the pallet (bottom ro Format only cells with values less than minimum and select Yellow color from the pallet (bottom...
-
A Gallup poll asked 511 randomly selected adults if they favor the death penalty for a person convicted of murder, with 64% saying yes. The margin of error is 4 percentage points. a. Based on the...
-
Should an auditor wishing to assess the adequacy of separation of functions examine a data flow diagram or a system flowchart? Why?
-
Choose a country from three of the regions presented in Table 6.7. Using the Internet, collect as much information as you believe is needed to identify the potential for market segments based on age,...
-
Entries for Acquisition of Assets Presented below are information related to Rommel Company. 1. On July 6 Rommel Company acquired the plant assets of Studebaker Company, which had discontinued...
-
Suppose that T: R R is a linear map, and . . . 2 2 3 T2 3 T1 = 2 and T 0 2 5 0 Then 2 T4 7
-
An aluminium alloy member having the cross-section shown in the figure below is 3 m in length. If the shear stress is not to exceed 30 MN/m 2 and the applied torque is 134 N-m, determine the required...
-
Air is contained within a cylinder in which heat is being transferred to it via a heating coil. Initially the air is at a temperature T and is heated until a final temperature of T2. The total heat...
-
Esther and Moses got engaged during December 2020 are happily anticipating their upcoming nuptials in December 2021. One of their friends informed them that they could choose the type of matrimonial...
-
If you were analyzing The New York Times with Ahrefs, what report would you use to determine the list of sites that The New York Times links to?
-
In what ways do cultural and social capital intersect with economic capital to shape individuals' mobility prospects, and how can interventions promote the accumulation of these assets among...
-
You've been managing your time for years, so you probably already have some ideas about what works for you. What are some effective time management strategies that you have used at home, at school,...
-
How do structural barriers such as intergenerational wealth disparities, unequal access to education, and systemic discrimination inhibit upward social mobility, and what policy interventions can...
-
What was the goal of structured design ensure that loops were the only way to repeat code O eliminate jumps to any statement in a program ensure that blocks of code are used to define operations O...
-
Data on weekday exercise time for 20 females, consistent with summary quantities given in the paper An Ecological Momentary Assessment of the Physical Activity and Sedentary Behaviour Patterns of...
-
1. Cash dividends on the $10 par value common stock of Garrett Company were as follows: 1st quarter of 2016 ...... $ 800,000 2nd quarter of 2016 ...... 900,000 3rd quarter of 2016 ...... 1,000,000...
-
The following are the inventory for the years 2016, 2017, and 2018 for parry Company: Required: 1. Assume the inventory that existed at the end of each year was sold in the subsequent year. Prepare...
-
What is the meaning of the following terms? (a) Authorized capital stock, (b) Issued capital stock, (c) Outstanding capital stock, and (d) Treasury stock? What is the difference between the number of...
-
One end of a wire is tied to a point A on the ceiling and the other end is tied to a point on a ring of radius \(R\) and negligible mass. The ring therefore hangs from the wire in a vertical plane...
-
A particle moves in a cylindrically symmetric potential \(U(ho, z)\). Use cylindrical coordinates \(ho, \varphi\), and \(z\) to parameterize the space. (a) Write the Lagrangian for an unconstrained...
-
A particle of mass \(m\) slides inside a smooth paraboloid of revolution whose axis of symmetry \(z\) is vertical. The surface is defined by the equation \(z=\alpha ho^{2}\), where \(z\) and \(ho\)...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App