Cases in Business Ethics Back to Blog /ethics-center/ethicsblog/silicon-valley.cfm? Unchartered Territory: When Innovation Outpaces Regulation David Johnson...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Cases in Business Ethics Back to Blog /ethics-center/ethicsblog/silicon-valley.cfm? Unchartered Territory: When Innovation Outpaces Regulation David Johnson holds a major leadership position within an established biotechnology firm. The firm has successfully pursued wildly innovative research utilizing DNA that has pushed the boundaries of science. Many potential clients - from universities and medical centers to private institutions - expressed a strong interest in the company's technology. Knowing that this technology was both powerful and relatively unregulated by the government, both Johnson and the company were keen to monitor who they sold their products to. The company's solution was to investigate potential clients and only sell to those who demonstrated "bona fide use," i.e. a legitimate use that would be carried out in good faith. However, determining what was and was not bona fide use proved to be tricky. Some researchers wanted to use the technology to investigate the genes of specific ethnic groups in order to understand common genetic diseases within that group. While this particular project was intended to benefit people, the company was concerned about how that information could potentially be used in the future, not to mention the company's culpability for that use given that its technology was used in the research. The company was concerned that the kind of information the potential customer would have access to could be used to discriminate against people with certain genetic markers, particularly by insurance companies looking to increase rates for clients at a higher risk for illness. At the same time, the investors of the biotech firm expect a return, given the high costs of research and development as well as the amount of risk they took on funding the project. Does the firm have an obligation to self-regulate their product? Are their "bona-fide use" standards sufficient? Cases in Business Ethics Back to Blog /ethics-center/ethicsblog/silicon-valley.cfm? Unchartered Territory: When Innovation Outpaces Regulation David Johnson holds a major leadership position within an established biotechnology firm. The firm has successfully pursued wildly innovative research utilizing DNA that has pushed the boundaries of science. Many potential clients - from universities and medical centers to private institutions - expressed a strong interest in the company's technology. Knowing that this technology was both powerful and relatively unregulated by the government, both Johnson and the company were keen to monitor who they sold their products to. The company's solution was to investigate potential clients and only sell to those who demonstrated "bona fide use," i.e. a legitimate use that would be carried out in good faith. However, determining what was and was not bona fide use proved to be tricky. Some researchers wanted to use the technology to investigate the genes of specific ethnic groups in order to understand common genetic diseases within that group. While this particular project was intended to benefit people, the company was concerned about how that information could potentially be used in the future, not to mention the company's culpability for that use given that its technology was used in the research. The company was concerned that the kind of information the potential customer would have access to could be used to discriminate against people with certain genetic markers, particularly by insurance companies looking to increase rates for clients at a higher risk for illness. At the same time, the investors of the biotech firm expect a return, given the high costs of research and development as well as the amount of risk they took on funding the project. Does the firm have an obligation to self-regulate their product? Are their "bona-fide use" standards sufficient?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Ans The resounding answer is yes Companies no matter the size do not operate in a bubble The decisio... View the full answer
Related Book For
Intermediate Accounting principles and analysis
ISBN: 978-0471737933
2nd Edition
Authors: Terry d. Warfield, jerry j. weygandt, Donald e. kieso
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these general management questions
-
Does the firm have an obligation to self-regulate their product? Are their bona-fide use standards sufficient? David Johnson holds a major leadership position within an established biotechnology...
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Googles ease of use and superior search results have propelled the search engine to its num- ber one status, ousting the early dominance of competitors such as WebCrawler and Infos- eek. Even later...
-
There are three general methods of allocating overhead costs: plantwide rates, rates for each expense category, and departmental rates. Describe when each is the most useful.
-
David Ricupero suspected his wife Polly of having an affair, so he taped her phone conversations and, based on what he heard, sued for divorce. Davids lawyer, William Wuliger, had the recorded...
-
Newton Manufacturing produces scientific calculators. The models are N350, N450, and the N900. Newton has planned its distribution of these products around eight customer zones: Brazil, China,...
-
The bidask spread (II) Consider the spot quotations in pounds per dollar (/\($)\) and dollars per pound (\($/)\) in Table 3.15: a. Compute the bid quotations in American and European terms. b....
-
Echo Canyon Muffins sells its muffins to restaurants and coffee houses for an average selling price of $ 27 per case. The following information relates to the budget for Echo Canyon Muffins for this...
-
Paretti Company purchased Skinner Inc. 10 years ago and recorded $500,000 of goodwill in connection with the acquisition. Skinner is considered to be a reporting unit of Paretti. Last year, Pare...
-
Explain why it would be incorrect to calculate the experimental ground-state energy of lithium by taking - (E2s + 2E1s), where E2s is the experimental energy needed to remove the 2s electron from...
-
Carry out a mini-research and share with the class any interesting article that you have seen or read about that is related to careers or latest trends and technology in the Database Industry. Be...
-
Marin Inc. began work on a $8,100,000 non-cancellable contract in 2020 to construct an office building. During 2020, Marin Inc. incurred costs of $1,764,000, billed its customers for $1,200,000...
-
Kathy Winslow worked as an employment representative in the human resource department of Community Hospital. One day she received a visit from Ed Smith, business office manager, who was actively...
-
Amanda has been a shareholder of Les Masques et les Plumes Inc. since 2004. She holds 1,000 Class A ordinary shares. Despite record profits, the directors, Rayane, Karina and Carlos have not declared...
-
Sam went to his doctor because he was feeling a pain in his chest. His doctor sent him to a cardiologist who advised Sam that, if he did not have a heart bypass operation, it was likely that he would...
-
Written News Legal Commentary #1 Students will quickly discover that much of what makes up the news and commentary in the media involve issues of a legal nature, such as matters involving...
-
Question 2 (45%) Reviewing the cash-flow forecasts of a new investment project that appear in the following table, the company's manager noted that there was no mention of any effect of the...
-
The Home Depot is the leading retailer in the home improvement industry and one of the 10largest retailers in the United States. The company included the following on its January 29, 2012, balance...
-
What are the principal considerations of a board of directors in making decisions involving dividend declarations? Discuss briefly.
-
Describe the reporting of pension plans for a company with multiple plans, some of which are underfunded and some of which are overfunded.
-
For each of the following, determine the expected cashflows. Cash Flow EstimateProbability Assessment $ 3,800 6,300 7,500 20% 50% 30% 30% 50% 20% $ 5,400 7,200 8,400 $(1,000) 2,000 5,000 10% 80% 10%
-
George Binkleys car is seven years old. The car is no longer under warranty and requires frequent repairs. George is trying to decide whether to buy a new car. He has asked you what you think about...
-
The managers at Miami Manufacturing Company are considering replacing the industrial mixer used in the companys factory. Information about the old mixer: Cost Estimated useful life Estimated residual...
-
John Paul Hudik, president of J. P. Hudik Boat Hauling, is considering replacing the companys industrial lift used to haul boats. The new lift would allow the company to lift larger boats out of the...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App