Background Independent research on non-bioengineered plants has found that 10 - 1,000 plants per m of...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Background Independent research on non-bioengineered plants has found that 10 - 1,000 plants per m of floor space (about the space you have around a chair) would be required to remove VOCS from an indoor environment (Cummings & Waring, 2020). If these values were applied to Neoplants' claim that the Neo P1 removes 30 times the VOCs of regular plants, then around 0.3-33.3 Neo P1 plants per m of floor space would be needed to remove VOCs from an indoor space. For a living room with 25 m of floor space, this would mean purchasing 8- 833 Neo P1 plants at an upfront cost of between AU$2,160 and AU$224,910, although costs would be significantly lower if cuttings from one plant were used to make new plants. Neoplants' website doesn't mention these figures. Instead, the website claims that the Neo P1 is "The first and only plant built to purify the air in your home." They also use the tagline "Fighting air pollution. One home at a time." and claim that the Neo P1 is "Good for the world, gorgeous for your home. This is a superplant with superpowers." In media interviews, the company is more cautious. Lionel Mora, one of Neoplant's co- founders, mentioned in an interview with Wired that the Neo P1 "will be the first time in history that such a product exists...The first computers, they weren't so great. But they were revolutionary." An online exchange between a user of the Y Combinator message board and the Chief Technical Officer (CTO) of Neoplants also alludes to the fact that learnings from developing the Neo P1 - alongside associated sales revenue - will be used to support the development of new, more impactful bioengineered plants. Note that the exchange has been edited for length and clarity: User: "I would love to see some numbers and comparisons. As I said in a reply below, I suspect this is functionally ineffectual and that 30x the air cleaning of a regular plant is like saying 30x the intelligence of a regular plant. I suspect this is functioning as a shiny, attractive prototype to fund further research to develop a 300x or 3000x plant or something in that neighbourhood. No judgment from me for that, prototype funding a bigger plan is a cool business model. I'd just love to get some absolute data." Reply: "Patrick here, CTO of Neoplants, thanks you so much for spending the time learning about what we've built...Even though our first product, Neo P1, is "only" 30x better than normal indoor plants, it's already a great improvement over anything that's been done in the scientific literature to date (usually improving phytoremediation by 2 or 3x), and this is just the start of the adventure. As you said, we expect to continue to leverage our metabolism and microbiome engineering technologies to have even more performant [sic] plants every year." Indeed, in other public commentary, such as in their Wired interview, representatives from Neoplants have spoken of using bioengineering to develop new plant variants that address other pressing societal needs, such as enhanced rates of carbon capture and absorbing toxins in contaminated environments. Neoplants also invests $20 from the sale of each Neo P1 to fund further research and development aimed at addressing climate change. Ethical analysis-10 marks Drawing on the material outlined in the background to this question, describe the ethical tension associated with Neoplants' current claims and future aspirations. As part of your answer, outline a strategy for how you would seek to address this tension. Background Independent research on non-bioengineered plants has found that 10 - 1,000 plants per m of floor space (about the space you have around a chair) would be required to remove VOCS from an indoor environment (Cummings & Waring, 2020). If these values were applied to Neoplants' claim that the Neo P1 removes 30 times the VOCs of regular plants, then around 0.3-33.3 Neo P1 plants per m of floor space would be needed to remove VOCs from an indoor space. For a living room with 25 m of floor space, this would mean purchasing 8- 833 Neo P1 plants at an upfront cost of between AU$2,160 and AU$224,910, although costs would be significantly lower if cuttings from one plant were used to make new plants. Neoplants' website doesn't mention these figures. Instead, the website claims that the Neo P1 is "The first and only plant built to purify the air in your home." They also use the tagline "Fighting air pollution. One home at a time." and claim that the Neo P1 is "Good for the world, gorgeous for your home. This is a superplant with superpowers." In media interviews, the company is more cautious. Lionel Mora, one of Neoplant's co- founders, mentioned in an interview with Wired that the Neo P1 "will be the first time in history that such a product exists...The first computers, they weren't so great. But they were revolutionary." An online exchange between a user of the Y Combinator message board and the Chief Technical Officer (CTO) of Neoplants also alludes to the fact that learnings from developing the Neo P1 - alongside associated sales revenue - will be used to support the development of new, more impactful bioengineered plants. Note that the exchange has been edited for length and clarity: User: "I would love to see some numbers and comparisons. As I said in a reply below, I suspect this is functionally ineffectual and that 30x the air cleaning of a regular plant is like saying 30x the intelligence of a regular plant. I suspect this is functioning as a shiny, attractive prototype to fund further research to develop a 300x or 3000x plant or something in that neighbourhood. No judgment from me for that, prototype funding a bigger plan is a cool business model. I'd just love to get some absolute data." Reply: "Patrick here, CTO of Neoplants, thanks you so much for spending the time learning about what we've built...Even though our first product, Neo P1, is "only" 30x better than normal indoor plants, it's already a great improvement over anything that's been done in the scientific literature to date (usually improving phytoremediation by 2 or 3x), and this is just the start of the adventure. As you said, we expect to continue to leverage our metabolism and microbiome engineering technologies to have even more performant [sic] plants every year." Indeed, in other public commentary, such as in their Wired interview, representatives from Neoplants have spoken of using bioengineering to develop new plant variants that address other pressing societal needs, such as enhanced rates of carbon capture and absorbing toxins in contaminated environments. Neoplants also invests $20 from the sale of each Neo P1 to fund further research and development aimed at addressing climate change. Ethical analysis-10 marks Drawing on the material outlined in the background to this question, describe the ethical tension associated with Neoplants' current claims and future aspirations. As part of your answer, outline a strategy for how you would seek to address this tension.
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these marketing questions
-
Describe how to construct the function cpo ((D E), v) of two cpos (D, vD) and (E, vE). Prove that ((D E), v) is a cpo. (You may use facts about least upper bounds provided you state them clearly.)...
-
Natureview Farm It was a crisp Vermont morning in February 2000. Christine Walker, vice president of marketing for Natureview Farm, Inc., a small yogurt manufacturer, paused to collect her thoughts...
-
To meet the demand for parking, your town has allocated the area shown here. As the town engineer, you have been asked by the town council to find out if the lot can be built for $11,000. The cost to...
-
Define reversible reaction.
-
1. What guidance does the economic theory of the correction of externalities offer regarding the amounts of financial penalties to be imposed on polluters? 2. Why might the Chinese government...
-
Specify how each of the following items would be reported in the financial statements of Tanaka Enterprises for its current fiscal year. Also specify the amount that would appear on the statement....
-
Continental Photo, Inc., is a portrait photography company. Alex Riley, a black man, applied for a position as a photographer with Continental. Riley submitted an application and was interviewed. In...
-
5. Smoothit Inc is facing a problem with their 4th quarter earnings on December 25. Their earnings target is $2,500,000 and the data so far is as follows: Direct None Sales Revenue Variable COGS...
-
Explain the steps that could have been taken to prevent disruption of the earth in the following scenario. The 2016 Olympics are going to be held in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. A team of engineers is...
-
Find the temperature at which the surface tension of water becomes zero. What is the physical significance of this temperature?
-
Search the literature or web and discuss briefly the principles behind the following flowmeasurement devices: a Pitot tube; a hot-wire anemometer; a laser-Doppler velocity meter; and a...
-
Chandrasekhar (1961) has shown that the above (Bnard) problem can be solved in terms of the vorticity, which reduces the problem to a sixth-order eigenvalue problem for the perturbation in...
-
Extend the analysis of the laminar-flow reactor for a power-law fluid. Perform some computations using the PDEPE solver, and show how the power-law index affects the conversion in the reactor.
-
A vertical plate \(3 \mathrm{~m}\) long is at a temperature of \(400 \mathrm{~K}\) and exposed to air at \(300 \mathrm{~K}\). Calculate the thickness of the boundary layer and the value of the local...
-
Please provide an argument for and an argument against. 3. This question studies how labor income has evolved over the past 50 years relative to GDP. a. Using FRED, acquire the following data series:...
-
You are a Loan Officer with an Investment Bank. Today you need to set your lending parameters. They are: LTV: 55% 10 Year T-Bill: TBD Rate Markup: 300 Basis Points Term: 30 Years Amortization: 30...
-
Find an equation of the sphere that passes through the point (4, 3, -1) and has center (3, 8, 1).
-
Find the derivative. Simplify where possible. F(t) = ln(sinh t)
-
Determine whether the statement is true or false. If it is true, explain why. If it is false, explain why or give an example that disproves the statement. If c n x n is convergent, then c n (-6) n is...
-
A nurse at a medical center claims that the median number of flu shots they give per day is 30. To test the claim, the nurse randomly selects 20 days during the months of September, October, and...
-
A medical researcher believed the number of ear infections in swimmers can be reduced if the swimmers use earplugs. A sample of 10 people was selected, and the number of infections for a four-month...
-
The Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission allows travelers to use a purchased Easy Pass for tolls on the Pennsylvania Turnpike. A researcher hypothesizes that the median of the number of Easy Pass users...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App