Case Study: The Sourcing Decision at Forever Young Forever Young is a retailer of trendy and...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Case Study: The Sourcing Decision at Forever Young Forever Young is a retailer of trendy and low-cost apparel in the United States. The company divides the year into four sales seasons of about three months each and brings in new merchandise for each season. The company has historically outsourced production to China, given the lower costs there. Sourcing from the Chinese supplier costs 55 yuan/unit (inclusive of all delivery costs), which at the current exchange rate of 6.5 yuan/$ gives a variable cost of under $8.50/unit. The Chinese supplier, however, has a long lead time, forcing Forever Young to pick an order size well before the start of the season. This does not leave the company any flexibility if actual demand differs from the order size. A local supplier has come to management with a proposal to supply product at a cost of $10/unit but to do so quickly enough that Forever Young will be able to make supply in the season exactly match demand. Management is concerned about the higher variable cost but finds the flexibility of the onshore supplier very attractive. The challenge is to value the responsiveness provided by the local supplier. Uncertainties Faced by Forever Young To better compare the two suppliers, management identifies demand and exchange rates as the two major uncertainties faced by the company. Over each of the next two periods (assume them to be a year each), demand may go up by 10 percent, with a probability of 0.5, or down by 10 percent, with a probability of 0.5. Demand in the current period was 1,000 units. Similarly, over each of the next two periods, the yuan may strengthen by 5 percent, with a probability of 0.5, or weaken by 5 percent, with a probability of 0.5. The exchange rate in the current period was 6.5 yuan/$. Ordering Policies with the Two Suppliers Given the long lead time of the offshore supplier, Forever Young commits to an order before observing any demand signal. Given the demand uncertainty over the next two periods and the fact that the margin from each unit (about $11.50) is higher than the loss if the unit remains unsold at the end of the season (loss of about $8.50), management decides to commit to an order that is somewhat higher than expected demand. Given that expected demand is 1,000 units over each of the next two periods, management decides to order 1,040 units from the Chinese supplier for each of the next two periods. If demand in a period turns out to be higher than 1,040 units, Forever Young will sell 1,040 units. However, if demand turns out to be lower than 1,040, the company will have leftover product for which it will not be able to recover any revenue. The short lead time of the local supplier allows Forever Young to keep bringing product in a little bit at a time, based on actual sales. Thus, if the local supplier is used, the company is able to meet all demand in each period without having any unsold inventory or lost sales. In other words, the final order from the local supplier will exactly equal the demand observed by Forever Young. A Potential Hybrid Strategy The local supplier has also offered another proposal that would allow Forever Young to use both suppliers, each playing a different role. The Chinese supplier would produce a base quantity for the season and the local supplier would cover any shortfalls that result. The short lead time of the local supplier would ensure that no sales are lost. In other words, if Forever Young committed to a base load of 900 units with the Chinese supplier in a given period and demand was 900 units or less, nothing would be ordered from the local supplier. If demand, however, was larger than 900 units (say, 1,100), the shortfall of 200 units would be supplied by the local supplier. Under a hybrid strategy, the local supplier would end up supplying only a small fraction of the season's demand. For this extra flexibility and reduced volumes, however, the local supplier proposes to charge $11/unit if it is used as part of a hybrid strategy. Study Questions 1. Draw a decision tree reflecting the uncertainty over the next two periods. Identify each node in terms of demand and exchange rate and the transition probabilities. 2. If management at Forever Young is to pick only one of the two suppliers, which one would you recommend? What is the NPV of expected profit over the next two periods for each of the two choices? Assume a discount factor of k=0.1 per period. 3. What do you think about the hybrid approach? Is it worth paying the local supplier extra to use it as part of a hybrid strategy? For the hybrid approach, assume that management will order a base load of 900 units from the Chinese supplier for each of the two periods, making up any shortfall in each period at the local supplier. Evaluate the NPV of expected profits for the hybrid option assuming a discount factor of k=0.1 per period. Case Study: The Sourcing Decision at Forever Young Forever Young is a retailer of trendy and low-cost apparel in the United States. The company divides the year into four sales seasons of about three months each and brings in new merchandise for each season. The company has historically outsourced production to China, given the lower costs there. Sourcing from the Chinese supplier costs 55 yuan/unit (inclusive of all delivery costs), which at the current exchange rate of 6.5 yuan/$ gives a variable cost of under $8.50/unit. The Chinese supplier, however, has a long lead time, forcing Forever Young to pick an order size well before the start of the season. This does not leave the company any flexibility if actual demand differs from the order size. A local supplier has come to management with a proposal to supply product at a cost of $10/unit but to do so quickly enough that Forever Young will be able to make supply in the season exactly match demand. Management is concerned about the higher variable cost but finds the flexibility of the onshore supplier very attractive. The challenge is to value the responsiveness provided by the local supplier. Uncertainties Faced by Forever Young To better compare the two suppliers, management identifies demand and exchange rates as the two major uncertainties faced by the company. Over each of the next two periods (assume them to be a year each), demand may go up by 10 percent, with a probability of 0.5, or down by 10 percent, with a probability of 0.5. Demand in the current period was 1,000 units. Similarly, over each of the next two periods, the yuan may strengthen by 5 percent, with a probability of 0.5, or weaken by 5 percent, with a probability of 0.5. The exchange rate in the current period was 6.5 yuan/$. Ordering Policies with the Two Suppliers Given the long lead time of the offshore supplier, Forever Young commits to an order before observing any demand signal. Given the demand uncertainty over the next two periods and the fact that the margin from each unit (about $11.50) is higher than the loss if the unit remains unsold at the end of the season (loss of about $8.50), management decides to commit to an order that is somewhat higher than expected demand. Given that expected demand is 1,000 units over each of the next two periods, management decides to order 1,040 units from the Chinese supplier for each of the next two periods. If demand in a period turns out to be higher than 1,040 units, Forever Young will sell 1,040 units. However, if demand turns out to be lower than 1,040, the company will have leftover product for which it will not be able to recover any revenue. The short lead time of the local supplier allows Forever Young to keep bringing product in a little bit at a time, based on actual sales. Thus, if the local supplier is used, the company is able to meet all demand in each period without having any unsold inventory or lost sales. In other words, the final order from the local supplier will exactly equal the demand observed by Forever Young. A Potential Hybrid Strategy The local supplier has also offered another proposal that would allow Forever Young to use both suppliers, each playing a different role. The Chinese supplier would produce a base quantity for the season and the local supplier would cover any shortfalls that result. The short lead time of the local supplier would ensure that no sales are lost. In other words, if Forever Young committed to a base load of 900 units with the Chinese supplier in a given period and demand was 900 units or less, nothing would be ordered from the local supplier. If demand, however, was larger than 900 units (say, 1,100), the shortfall of 200 units would be supplied by the local supplier. Under a hybrid strategy, the local supplier would end up supplying only a small fraction of the season's demand. For this extra flexibility and reduced volumes, however, the local supplier proposes to charge $11/unit if it is used as part of a hybrid strategy. Study Questions 1. Draw a decision tree reflecting the uncertainty over the next two periods. Identify each node in terms of demand and exchange rate and the transition probabilities. 2. If management at Forever Young is to pick only one of the two suppliers, which one would you recommend? What is the NPV of expected profit over the next two periods for each of the two choices? Assume a discount factor of k=0.1 per period. 3. What do you think about the hybrid approach? Is it worth paying the local supplier extra to use it as part of a hybrid strategy? For the hybrid approach, assume that management will order a base load of 900 units from the Chinese supplier for each of the two periods, making up any shortfall in each period at the local supplier. Evaluate the NPV of expected profits for the hybrid option assuming a discount factor of k=0.1 per period.
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
Fundamental financial accounting concepts
ISBN: 978-0078025365
8th edition
Authors: Thomas P. Edmonds, Frances M. Mcnair, Philip R. Olds, Edward
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these general management questions
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Children's Hospital & Clinics COO Julie Morath set out to change the culture by instituting a policy of blameless reporting, which encourages employees to report anything that goes wrong or seems...
-
A certain radioactive isotope is a by - product of some nuclear reactors. Due to an explosion, a nuclear reactor experiences a massive leak of this radioactive isotope. Fortunately, the isotope has a...
-
Data on Goodman Company's direct labor costs is given below: Standard hours allowed...................................30,000 Actual direct labor hours.................................29,000 Labor...
-
Perform the same computation as in Sec. 32.4, but change the force to 1.5 and the spring constantsto Spring 1 ? 3 0.75 1.5 0.5 2
-
A semiconductor product consists of three layers. Suppose that the variances in thickness of the first, second, and third layers are 25,40 , and 30 square nanometers, respectively, and the layer...
-
Discuss what types of HR changes could have affected reductions in workers compensation expenses, employee turnover, and increases in customer satisfaction.
-
We have a game of invasion of France by the Allies and defense by the Germans. Both can play C (Calais) or N (Normandy). The following matrix shows the payoffs of each player in utility levels (more...
-
During orientation, unique group roles emerge. This becomes particularly apparent while working on case presentations. The following interaction occurred during a brainstorming session: Joan: "We are...
-
Is it reasonable to expect companies to be able to have total visibility across their supply chain? Please answer "Yes" or "No" or "It depends," and then provide details to support your answer.
-
One item is omitted in each of the following summaries of balance sheet and income statement data for four different corporations, AL, CO, KS, and MT. Enter the missing amounts. Beginning of the...
-
A 10 m thick metal sheet of size 10 cm 10 cm is annealed in a pure nitrogen atmosphere with pN2 = 10 atm, until a uniform concentration of N atoms is established within the sheet. Then the sheet is...
-
Suppose Kenny is involved in an accident that was not his fault and the other driver has 50/100/25 coverage limits. Kenny's injuries amount to $20,000. How much will the other driver's policy cover...
-
1. Management activities are divided into four functions, which are: Planning, Organizing, Directing and Coordinating Controlling. You are employed as the manager of XYZ FBO, with approximately ten...
-
Lucy runs an order taking and customer service department for an online store selling high end shoes at low prices. Lucy has been the manager of the customer service representatives for over 10...
-
medical student get nervous for final exam and breath rapidly describe it metabolic acidosis O metabolic alkalosis O respiratory acidosis respiratory alkalosis
-
1. Using the information from Problem 16-4B, prepare a statement of cash flows for Lim Garden Supplies Inc. using the direct method of presenting cash flows from operating activities. 2. How does Lim...
-
The three typical accounting events associated with borrowing money through a bond issue are 1. Exchanging the bonds for cash on the day of issue. 2. Making cash payments for interest expense and...
-
Dugan Sales had the following transactions for jackets in 2013, its first year of operations: During the year, Dugan Sales sold 830 jackets for $40 each. Required a. Compute the amount of ending...
-
A hurricane destroyed the inventory of Franklin Feed Store on September 21 of the current year. Although some of the accounting information was destroyed, the following information was discovered for...
-
What role does the HAL play in the platform?
-
If your logic analyzer is capable of on-the-fly disassembly, use it to display bus activity in the form of instructions, rather than simply 1s and 0s.
-
Draw UML state diagrams for device 1 and device 2 in a four-cycle handshake.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App