Course Code BMGT380 Course Name: Business Ethics Assessment: Assignment 2 (Case Study) Submission Deadline: 5/3/2020 Instructions:...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Course Code BMGT380 Course Name: Business Ethics Assessment: Assignment 2 (Case Study) Submission Deadline: 5/3/2020 Instructions: Read the case study below, then answer the questions that follow At iCare Hospital, Dr. Jole received six patients who looked very ill. After running some blood tests and reading the results, he found out that all of the patients were suffering from disease X Unfortunately, and due to certain situations taking place in the country, there had been only one syringe of 10 ml. of medication for disease X available in the hospital Dr. John realized that five of these patients were past criminals and had recently finished their jail sentences. They were all suffering from a moderate level of the disease and each one of them needed only 2 ml. of the medication to get cured. However, the sixth patient Rami was a commendable man whose health case was severe and needed the whole 10 ml of the medication in order to be cured. Thus, Dr. John had to either give the full medication to Rami, or to let the five other patients share it. On another note, the hospital threw the syringes that Dr. John used while running the blood tests in the nearest waste basket instead of discarding them in a biohazard container specialized for sharp contaminated objects. Unfortunately, animals eating from the garbage where the syringes were thrown came in contact with the contaminated needles and started spreading the disease all over the city. Questions 1. By applying the Utilitarian approach, what decision would have been taken by Dr. John with respect to the medication? Justify your answer (25 marks). 2. Assume that Dr. John decided to divide the 10 ml. of the medication among the six patients and give each of them an amount of 1.6 mL pretending that they all received the adequate amount needed in order to be cured. Judge the morality of such a decision from a Kantian perspective (25 marks). 3. Who were the victims of the action of disposing the blood test syringes in the nearest waste garbage? How these victims were affected? (25 marks) 4. In your opinion, what corrective action would the hospital take with respect to the damage caused by the syringes? Discuss your answer (25 marks). Course Code BMGT380 Course Name: Business Ethics Assessment: Assignment 2 (Case Study) Submission Deadline: 5/3/2020 Instructions: Read the case study below, then answer the questions that follow At iCare Hospital, Dr. Jole received six patients who looked very ill. After running some blood tests and reading the results, he found out that all of the patients were suffering from disease X Unfortunately, and due to certain situations taking place in the country, there had been only one syringe of 10 ml. of medication for disease X available in the hospital Dr. John realized that five of these patients were past criminals and had recently finished their jail sentences. They were all suffering from a moderate level of the disease and each one of them needed only 2 ml. of the medication to get cured. However, the sixth patient Rami was a commendable man whose health case was severe and needed the whole 10 ml of the medication in order to be cured. Thus, Dr. John had to either give the full medication to Rami, or to let the five other patients share it. On another note, the hospital threw the syringes that Dr. John used while running the blood tests in the nearest waste basket instead of discarding them in a biohazard container specialized for sharp contaminated objects. Unfortunately, animals eating from the garbage where the syringes were thrown came in contact with the contaminated needles and started spreading the disease all over the city. Questions 1. By applying the Utilitarian approach, what decision would have been taken by Dr. John with respect to the medication? Justify your answer (25 marks). 2. Assume that Dr. John decided to divide the 10 ml. of the medication among the six patients and give each of them an amount of 1.6 mL pretending that they all received the adequate amount needed in order to be cured. Judge the morality of such a decision from a Kantian perspective (25 marks). 3. Who were the victims of the action of disposing the blood test syringes in the nearest waste garbage? How these victims were affected? (25 marks) 4. In your opinion, what corrective action would the hospital take with respect to the damage caused by the syringes? Discuss your answer (25 marks).
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Answer 1 As per utilitarian approach the outcome of the decision is decided on the basis of the bene... View the full answer
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these medical sciences questions
-
Read the following case and then answer the questions that follow. Following the assassination of President Abraham Lincoln on April 14, 1865, by John Wilkes Booth and John H. Surratt, one of Booths...
-
Read the following article extract, then answer the questions that follow: What is the difference between management and leadership? It is a question that has been asked more than once and also...
-
Study the following case. Answer the questions that follow with Yes or No. Katsoulas, a U.S. car dealer, had a contract with a Korean automobile manufacturer for the delivery of several cars. When...
-
A managers key task is to balance which four customer service factors against which six logistics cost factors?
-
During the current year, Kyung purchases a boat for $70,000. Because she has only $7,000 of the necessary $14,000 down payment, Kyung makes a $7,000 withdrawal from her IRA. Immediately before the...
-
Purdue Savings and Loan Association purchased a put option on Treasury bond futures with a September delivery date and an exercise price of 91-16. Assume the put option has a premium of 1-32. Assume...
-
The Buffalo Insurance Agency received the following notes during 2010: Requirements 1. Identifying each note by number, compute interest using a 360-day year, and determine the due date and maturity...
-
A vertical electric field of magnitude 2.00 x 104 N/C exists above the Earths surface on a day when a thunderstorm is brewing. A car with a rectangular size of 6.00 m by 3.00 m is traveling along a...
-
The question: 1 Audrey Sanborn has just arranged to purchase a $550,000 vacation home in the Bahamas with a 20 percent down payment. The mortgage has a 6.1 percent stated annual interest rate,...
-
Letang Company has three divisions (R, S, and T), organized as decentralized profit centers. Division R produces the basic chemical Ranbax (in multiples of 1,000 pounds) and transfers it to Divisions...
-
Plant, Property, and Equipment: please provide all required journal entries (account, amounts) for each fiscal year for the following individual piece of equipment: Show your work and assume a...
-
1 dx x solve In(x)
-
Kleen Company acquired patent rights on January 1 0 of Year 1 for $ 9 4 0 , 5 0 0 . The patent has a useful life equal to its legal life of 8 years. On January 7 of Year 4 , Kleen successfully...
-
Analyze the role of social identity theory in shaping intergroup dynamics within a complex organizational structure. What strategies can mitigate conflict arising from group affiliations ?
-
Find uv. (Give your answer correct to 2 decimal places.) 1348.59 ||u|| = 45, ||v|| =40, and the angle between u and v is 5/6.
-
Which carrier would you recommend that Bobs BBQ consider for elimination? Why?
-
For Problem estimate the change in y for the given change in x. y = f(x), f'(12) = 30, x increases from 12 to 12.2
-
Vouching transactions and balances back to supporting documentation would ordinarily provide evidence about which assertions? Which assertions would vouching be least likely to provide evidence about?
-
Why does non-sampling risk exist for all types of tests in all audits? Explain.
-
Emma Maltz has been appointed as audit senior of the accounts receivable area in the audit of Fantastic Cruises, a company operating leisure cruises from ports in eastern Canada. Fantastic Cruises...
-
What do you mean by maxcondentherm and maxcondenbar? How do they differ from each other?
-
What is an azeotrope? How do you categorize an azeotrope? Discuss the minimum boiling azeotrope with the help of phase diagram for a particular system.
-
Explain the azeotrope formation for nitric acid-water system with graphical representation.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App