1) Did a contract exist between Dunston and Szafranski? If there was a contract, what type was...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
1) Did a contract exist between Dunston and Szafranski? If there was a contract, what type was it and why?
2) Did the May 2010 "break up text" have any effect on the signed fertility clinic consent form, why or why not?
3) Discuss the elements of contract law that apply to this case, with detailed explanations of each, and present an argument based on the law of contracts, regarding who should win this case.
Transcribed Image Text:
The above story is the series of events in a real life case. Dr. Karla Dunston is the woman who as a result of her cancer treatment cannot have a child other than with the frozen embryos. The father is Jacob Szafranski, a nurse, paramedic & firefighter. The judge ruled that the verbal contract the couple had made when Szafranski agreed to father embryos with Dunston was binding and that the woman's wish to procreate (to have children) outweigh the man's desire not to procreate. What's unique about this case from previous ones is that the couple here were never married (is that an important fact, why or why not?). In 2010, the couple went to a Chicago fertility clinic and signed a consent form that stated that no embryo could be used without permission of both parties unless there is another contract or divorce decree. An attorney drafted a co-parenting agreement for the couple that stated Szafranski would undertake any obligations no matter what happened in their relationship and that Dunston would have all control over the embryos. That contract was never signed. In April 2010, both individuals made their donations. In May 2010, Szafranski initiated the break up. In August 2011, he filed suit to prevent Dunston from using the embryos saying that he had changed his mind. Dunston countersued for sole custody of the embryos and won. Szafranski appealed the case. The above story is the series of events in a real life case. Dr. Karla Dunston is the woman who as a result of her cancer treatment cannot have a child other than with the frozen embryos. The father is Jacob Szafranski, a nurse, paramedic & firefighter. The judge ruled that the verbal contract the couple had made when Szafranski agreed to father embryos with Dunston was binding and that the woman's wish to procreate (to have children) outweigh the man's desire not to procreate. What's unique about this case from previous ones is that the couple here were never married (is that an important fact, why or why not?). In 2010, the couple went to a Chicago fertility clinic and signed a consent form that stated that no embryo could be used without permission of both parties unless there is another contract or divorce decree. An attorney drafted a co-parenting agreement for the couple that stated Szafranski would undertake any obligations no matter what happened in their relationship and that Dunston would have all control over the embryos. That contract was never signed. In April 2010, both individuals made their donations. In May 2010, Szafranski initiated the break up. In August 2011, he filed suit to prevent Dunston from using the embryos saying that he had changed his mind. Dunston countersued for sole custody of the embryos and won. Szafranski appealed the case.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Answer 1 There was a contract between Dunston and Szafranski The type of contract is an oral contrac... View the full answer
Related Book For
Mathematical Statistics with Applications in R
ISBN: 978-0124171138
2nd edition
Authors: Chris P. Tsokos, K.M. Ramachandran
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
In Exercises 1-2, explore the effect of an elementary row operation on the determinant of a matrix. In each case, state the row operation and describe how it affects the determinant. 1. 2. [: ]: a d...
-
The paper The Effect of an Endothelin-Receptor Antagonist, Bosentan, on Blood Pressure in Patients with Essential Hypertension [The New England Journal of Medicine (1998)] discussed the contribution...
-
An experiment was conducted to observe the effect of an increase in temperature on the potency of an antibiotic. Three one ounce portions of the antibiotic were stored for equal lengths of time at...
-
1. Rick and Barbara are married with two children. Four yearsago, Barbara bought a $75,000 life insurance policy on her motherslife and named her children as policy beneficiaries. Barbara didnot name...
-
P(x > 71.6) The random variable x is normally distributed with mean = 74 and standard deviation = 8. Find the indicated probability.
-
Explain, using equations where appropriate, why a pump located even with the bottom of a pressurized tank containing a vapor-liquid mixture of a pure component will likely not ever cavitate...
-
The following transactions for Best Deal Tire, Co., occurred during May: Requirements 1. Journalize the transactions on the books of Best Deal Tire, Co. 2. What was Best Deal Tires gross profit for...
-
The data listed below are taken from a balance sheet of Trident Corporation. Some amounts, indicated by question marks, have been intentionally omitted. Required: 1. Determine the missing amounts. 2....
-
An epicyclic gear train consists of a sun wheel S, a stationary annular wheel E and three identical planetwheels P carried on a star-shaped carrier C, as shown in Fig.15.14. The size of different...
-
Wayland Custom Woodworking is a firm that manufactures custom cabinets and woodwork for business and residential customers. Students will have the opportunity to establish payroll records and to...
-
You receive an invoice for 2 5 0 0 0 $ with the terms 3 / 1 5 , n / 6 0 with a late fee of 6 % on any unpaid balance. You pay 1 0 0 0 0 $ by the discount date and another 1 0 0 0 0 $ by the net date....
-
How many legal host addresses are possible for the network 192.168.215.224/28?
-
You are the newly hired Director of Human Resources for a city. Describe your approach to the City Manager in your first week of work ?
-
Presented below are data on three promissory notes. Determine the missing amounts. (Use 360 days for calculation.) Date of Note Terms Maturity Date Principal Annual Interest Rate 60 April 1 May 31...
-
For IESDS, it doesn't matter what order you eliminate strategies in: the same set of strategies will survive in the end (or the same unique strategy profile survives, in the case where the game is...
-
Explain about the strategy " Second Helping Strategy" and then do some work to find reliable support at least 2 for using the strategy in the Math Area. Plan your talking points on your own (why?...
-
How do you value a business using free cash flows and earnings? Which factors contribute to variation in price-earnings multiples? Why did the stock market crash in 1929? What caused the Great...
-
Solve the relation Exz:Solve therelation ne %3D
-
Suppose a coin is tossed 100 times in order to estimate p = p (Head). It is observed that head appeared 60 times. Find a 95% confidence interval for p.
-
From an urn containing 15 white, 7 black, and 8 yellow balls a sample of 3 balls is drawn at random. Find the probability that (a) All three balls are yellow. (b) All three balls are of the same...
-
In Exercise 6.1.3: (a) Assume that the rejection region is {Y 8}. Calculate a and b if p = 0.6. Compare the results with the corresponding values obtained in Exercise 6.1.3. (This gives the effect...
-
A shell with a mass of \(20 \mathrm{~kg}\) is fired from point \(O\), with a velocity \(u=\) \(300 \mathrm{~m} / \mathrm{s}\) in the vertical \(x-z\) plane at the inclination shown. When it reaches...
-
The 32.2-lb carriage \(A\) moves horizontally in its guide with a speed of \(4 \mathrm{ft} / \mathrm{sec}\) and carries two assemblies of balls and light rods which rotate about a shaft at \(O\) in...
-
The smooth vane shown diverts the open stream of fluid of crosssectional area \(A\), mass density \(ho\), and velocity \(v\). (a) Determine the force components \(R\) and \(F\) required to hold the...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App