THE Pacific Futures Trading Company For some time, theoretical and empirical evidence suggested that the Efficient...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
THE Pacific Futures Trading Company For some time, theoretical and empirical evidence suggested that the Efficient Market Hypothesis, the Capital Asset Pricing Model, and other rational financial theories did a good job of predicting and explaining the behavior of investors. However, the 'rationality of financial marifets - and more specifically, investors - has recently been a hot topic in the financial economics literature. Recent research has argued and shown that investors often make mistakes; they behave irrational and exhibit several financially damaging biases, such as loss aversion, herding, overconfidence, and overreaction (Barber and Odean, 2001; DeBondt and Thaler, 1986; Fischoff and Slovic, 1980; Gervais and Odean, 2001; Huberman and Regev, 2001; Kahneman and Tversky, 1979). These irrationalities are frequently attributed to psychological factors such as fear, greed, regret, and other emotional responses to price changes and changes in personal wealth. A growing number of economists, psychologists, and financial-industry professionals have begun to use the terms behavioral economics and 'behavioral finance' to differentiate themselves and their ideas from the standard, rational theories (such as the Efficient Market Hypothesis) in economics and finance. Akrisios Stathopoulos is the President of the Pacific Futures Trading Company (PFTC). Futures trading is a form of investment that involves speculating on the price of a commodity, such as gold, cotton, wheat, or steel, going up or down in the future. Futures are popular among traders, from private individuals to multi-million dollar hedge funds. Founded in 1972, the Pacific Futures Trading Company is a second-generation family-owned business. With Akrisios as President, his brother Epifanio as Vice President of Finance, and his other brother Sirius as Vice President of Human Resources, the Stathopoulos brothers are strongly committed to creating customer satisfaction. Like futures trading, the Pacific Futures Trading Company has grown exponentially over the last decade. Hence, the company spends much time and money on recruitment and training. In futures trading, it is crucial to attracting, screen, and select qualified people for the job and then to train these new employees to become successful traders. Being a successful trader takes patience, determination, discipline, and education. Indeed, learning how to trade is a process that takes time. Despite the efforts that the Pacific Futures Trading Company has put into recruitment and training programs, its traders (even the most experienced ones) occasionally exhibit powerful emotional responses during certain market events, such as increased price volatility or sudden breaks in trends. As a result of these emotional responses, they occasionally make mistakes. Every now and then, these mistakes have a profound financial impact on the company, its clients, and/or the trader. Over the years, Akrisious Stathopoulos has become increasingly interested in the effect of personality characteristics and emotional reactivity on the trading performance of investors. He has recruited Sam Beam, a student from Cambridge to investigate the role of personality and emotions on trading performance. To find solutions for Akrisious' problem, Sam has gathered initial information about factors possibly related to the problem. He has interviewed several Pacific Futures Trading Company traders and gathered books and research articles on behavioral economics and finance. Hence, he has developed a feel for what is going down in behavioral finance. This has allowed him to develop the following problem statement: "What is the effect of personality and emotional reactivity on the financial performance of day traders?" To find solutions for Akrisious' problem, Sam has gathered initial information about factors possibly related to the problem. He has interviewed several Pacific Futures Trading Company traders and gathered books and research articles on behavioral economics and finance. Hence, he has developed a feel for what is going down in behavioral finance. This has allowed him to develop the following problem statement: "What is the effect of personality and emotional reactivity on the financial performance of day traders?" After Sam and Akrisious agreed on the purpose of Sam's research, Sam started examining specific variables as to their contribution on the financial performance of day traders. He developed a theoretical framework that represents his beliefs on how certain variables are related to financial performance and explains why he believes these variables are associated with financial performance. From this theoretical framework, he has developed the following hypotheses to examine whether his theory was valid or not H1: Extreme (positive and negative) emotional responses to market events negatively affect investors' trading performance. H2: Successful traders tend to be emotionally stable introverts open to new experiences. To test these hypotheses, Sam recruited 50 volunteers from a six-week training program for day-traders offered by Rose Bush, a well- known professional futures trader. The day-traders were asked to complete a questionnaire that recorded their psychological profile before. the training program. During the training program, day-traders were asked to fill out questionnaires at the end of their training day. These questionnaires were designed to measure the participants' emotional state and trading performance for that day. Sam used the following scales to operationalize the variables in his model: Zung's Self-Rating Anxiety Scale and Self-Rating Depression Scale, a public domain version of McCrae and Costa's NEO IP-R personality inventory instrument, the UWIST Mood Adjective Checklist, and the total profit/loss on paper trades for the day. After the data were gathered, they were statistically analyzed to see whether the generated hypotheses were supported. The results from Sam's study support his first hypothesis. For Sam, these results indicate a clear link between the emotional reactivity of investors and trading performance. These findings suggest that traders may benefit from emotion management and coaching training. By acquiring emotional management skills and techniques, traders may be able to better understand their emotions' impact on their behavior and performance. Also, it may provide them with techniques to better manage their emotions and improve their performance. No evidence was found to support the second hypothesis. This suggests, that Sam explained that traders with different personality types might be able to function equally well after proper training and practice. 1. 2. these hallmarks. 3. 4. Do you think Sam's study's results are generalizable to other organizations? Why (not)? Sam has explained to Akrisious that even though he has tried to meet all the hallmarks of scientific investigation, he has not included all the variables that influence the financial performance of traders. Using vocabulary Akrisious has never heard of (such as omitted variable bias and biased and inconsistent parameter estimates), Sam argues that his study may lack rigor and that his study is probably not 100% scientific. In terms of basic research and applied research, how would you categorize Sam's study? Why? Purposiveness, testability, and objectivity are three hallmarks of scientific research. Use Sam's study as an example to discuss 5a: detail. 5b. 6. What is rigor? Do you think Sam's efforts have been worthwhile despite the apparent lack of rigor? Inductive and deductive research is often carried out in basic and applied research contexts. Describe these forms of research a. b. How does Sam use inductive and deductive research in his study? Explain the steps in hypothetico-deductive research using Sam's study as an example. THE Pacific Futures Trading Company For some time, theoretical and empirical evidence suggested that the Efficient Market Hypothesis, the Capital Asset Pricing Model, and other rational financial theories did a good job of predicting and explaining the behavior of investors. However, the 'rationality of financial marifets - and more specifically, investors - has recently been a hot topic in the financial economics literature. Recent research has argued and shown that investors often make mistakes; they behave irrational and exhibit several financially damaging biases, such as loss aversion, herding, overconfidence, and overreaction (Barber and Odean, 2001; DeBondt and Thaler, 1986; Fischoff and Slovic, 1980; Gervais and Odean, 2001; Huberman and Regev, 2001; Kahneman and Tversky, 1979). These irrationalities are frequently attributed to psychological factors such as fear, greed, regret, and other emotional responses to price changes and changes in personal wealth. A growing number of economists, psychologists, and financial-industry professionals have begun to use the terms behavioral economics and 'behavioral finance' to differentiate themselves and their ideas from the standard, rational theories (such as the Efficient Market Hypothesis) in economics and finance. Akrisios Stathopoulos is the President of the Pacific Futures Trading Company (PFTC). Futures trading is a form of investment that involves speculating on the price of a commodity, such as gold, cotton, wheat, or steel, going up or down in the future. Futures are popular among traders, from private individuals to multi-million dollar hedge funds. Founded in 1972, the Pacific Futures Trading Company is a second-generation family-owned business. With Akrisios as President, his brother Epifanio as Vice President of Finance, and his other brother Sirius as Vice President of Human Resources, the Stathopoulos brothers are strongly committed to creating customer satisfaction. Like futures trading, the Pacific Futures Trading Company has grown exponentially over the last decade. Hence, the company spends much time and money on recruitment and training. In futures trading, it is crucial to attracting, screen, and select qualified people for the job and then to train these new employees to become successful traders. Being a successful trader takes patience, determination, discipline, and education. Indeed, learning how to trade is a process that takes time. Despite the efforts that the Pacific Futures Trading Company has put into recruitment and training programs, its traders (even the most experienced ones) occasionally exhibit powerful emotional responses during certain market events, such as increased price volatility or sudden breaks in trends. As a result of these emotional responses, they occasionally make mistakes. Every now and then, these mistakes have a profound financial impact on the company, its clients, and/or the trader. Over the years, Akrisious Stathopoulos has become increasingly interested in the effect of personality characteristics and emotional reactivity on the trading performance of investors. He has recruited Sam Beam, a student from Cambridge to investigate the role of personality and emotions on trading performance. To find solutions for Akrisious' problem, Sam has gathered initial information about factors possibly related to the problem. He has interviewed several Pacific Futures Trading Company traders and gathered books and research articles on behavioral economics and finance. Hence, he has developed a feel for what is going down in behavioral finance. This has allowed him to develop the following problem statement: "What is the effect of personality and emotional reactivity on the financial performance of day traders?" To find solutions for Akrisious' problem, Sam has gathered initial information about factors possibly related to the problem. He has interviewed several Pacific Futures Trading Company traders and gathered books and research articles on behavioral economics and finance. Hence, he has developed a feel for what is going down in behavioral finance. This has allowed him to develop the following problem statement: "What is the effect of personality and emotional reactivity on the financial performance of day traders?" After Sam and Akrisious agreed on the purpose of Sam's research, Sam started examining specific variables as to their contribution on the financial performance of day traders. He developed a theoretical framework that represents his beliefs on how certain variables are related to financial performance and explains why he believes these variables are associated with financial performance. From this theoretical framework, he has developed the following hypotheses to examine whether his theory was valid or not H1: Extreme (positive and negative) emotional responses to market events negatively affect investors' trading performance. H2: Successful traders tend to be emotionally stable introverts open to new experiences. To test these hypotheses, Sam recruited 50 volunteers from a six-week training program for day-traders offered by Rose Bush, a well- known professional futures trader. The day-traders were asked to complete a questionnaire that recorded their psychological profile before. the training program. During the training program, day-traders were asked to fill out questionnaires at the end of their training day. These questionnaires were designed to measure the participants' emotional state and trading performance for that day. Sam used the following scales to operationalize the variables in his model: Zung's Self-Rating Anxiety Scale and Self-Rating Depression Scale, a public domain version of McCrae and Costa's NEO IP-R personality inventory instrument, the UWIST Mood Adjective Checklist, and the total profit/loss on paper trades for the day. After the data were gathered, they were statistically analyzed to see whether the generated hypotheses were supported. The results from Sam's study support his first hypothesis. For Sam, these results indicate a clear link between the emotional reactivity of investors and trading performance. These findings suggest that traders may benefit from emotion management and coaching training. By acquiring emotional management skills and techniques, traders may be able to better understand their emotions' impact on their behavior and performance. Also, it may provide them with techniques to better manage their emotions and improve their performance. No evidence was found to support the second hypothesis. This suggests, that Sam explained that traders with different personality types might be able to function equally well after proper training and practice. 1. 2. these hallmarks. 3. 4. Do you think Sam's study's results are generalizable to other organizations? Why (not)? Sam has explained to Akrisious that even though he has tried to meet all the hallmarks of scientific investigation, he has not included all the variables that influence the financial performance of traders. Using vocabulary Akrisious has never heard of (such as omitted variable bias and biased and inconsistent parameter estimates), Sam argues that his study may lack rigor and that his study is probably not 100% scientific. In terms of basic research and applied research, how would you categorize Sam's study? Why? Purposiveness, testability, and objectivity are three hallmarks of scientific research. Use Sam's study as an example to discuss 5a: detail. 5b. 6. What is rigor? Do you think Sam's efforts have been worthwhile despite the apparent lack of rigor? Inductive and deductive research is often carried out in basic and applied research contexts. Describe these forms of research a. b. How does Sam use inductive and deductive research in his study? Explain the steps in hypothetico-deductive research using Sam's study as an example.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Question Q1 I would consider Sams study applied research Applies research is used to solve a very specific problem in a specific scenario The issue needs some sort of solution or alternative that will ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Introduction to Operations and Supply Chain Management
ISBN: 978-0132747325
3rd edition
Authors: Cecil B. Bozarth, Robert B. Handfield
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
The tiny fragment attack is a form of firewall attack. The intruder uses the IP fragmentation option to create extremely small fragments and force the TCP header information into a separate packet...
-
The kickback is a form of fraud often associated with purchasing. Most organizations expect their purchasing agents to select the vendor that provides the best provide at the lowest price. To...
-
Rock 'n' roll is a form of music that evolved in the United States and quickly spread to the rest of the world. The interest in rock music, like any other genre, has gone through ups and downs over...
-
Match the following ratios with the appropriate formula. Ratio or Rate Formula a. Income from operations Interest expense Acid-test Total liabilities Stockholders' equity Current b. Net income-...
-
Consider Jakes processes in the opening vignette of this chapter. a. Create a BPMN for the Burger Assembly process. b. Write a procedure for how the in-store employee inputs a customer order on the...
-
Determine the output voltage for the circuit of Fig. 11.52. 330 k2 470 33 12 mV 47 k 47 18 mV FIG. 11.52 Problem 8
-
What is meant by replanning? b d b a d a C
-
The standard cost of Product B manufactured by Mateo Company includes three units of direct materials at $5.00 per unit. During June, 28,000 units of direct materials are purchased at a cost of $4.70...
-
Logan has a loan that he has to pay $80,000 at the end of the year for 10 years. If Logan wants to pay this loan in monthly terms instead of annual terms and money is worth 15% compounded annually......
-
In March 2013 the management team of Londonderry Air (LA) met to discuss a proposal to purchase five shorthaul aircraft at a total cost of $25 million. There was general enthusiasm for the...
-
Which fracture type is dominant at the trough of a syncline? Why?
-
The electricity supply of a certain U.S. state needs to be increased. The state is very cloudy and rainy from October to April. There are several large rivers, and there are almost no areas with high...
-
The cyclization reaction shown below involves two sequential condensation reactions, and can be catalyzed by either a strong acid or a strong base. a. Draw the neutral intermediate that would form...
-
The following diagram represents the risk/return position of four portfolios of shares. Portfolio D is the market portfolio (the portfolio made up of all risky assets in the market in the same...
-
Feel free to ask me some questions if you would like to refresh your basic chemistry knowledge. a) Where can I find the total number of electrons for a specific element? b) What are valence...
-
Consider solidification of manganese. The melting temperature of Mn is 1250 C, the solid-liquid interfacial energy is 0.216 Jm- and the latent heat of fusion can be approximated with Richard's rule....
-
A polynomial f(x) and two of its zeros are given. f(x) = 5x^5+14x^4+82x^3+48x^2-183x+34 -1-4i and 1/5 are zeros. Find all zeros
-
If the joint cost function for two products is C(x, y) = xy2 + 1 dollars (a) Find the marginal cost (function) with respect to x. (b) Find the marginal cost with respect to y.
-
Omega Design is moving into an old Victorian building with a very unusual oor layout: The numbers of daily interdepartmental trips are as follows: Use the minimal distance traveled logic to develop a...
-
Consider the SimQuick simulation model for Luc's Car Wash, shown in Figure 6S.6. Suppose Luc decides to put in place a second crew. Redraw Figure 6S.6 to reect this change. What changes to the model...
-
Tyler Apiaries sells bees and beekeeping supplies. Bees (including a queen) are shipped in special packages according to weight. The target weight of a package is 1.4 kg. Historically, Tyler's...
-
What are the two categories of pattern generality? Explain.
-
Analogy approach makes people end up building templates rather than building patterns. Explain.
-
Explain the concept behind constructing analysis pattern by using stability approach.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App