Facts: Retailers use a credit card processing company to process credit transac- tions, and are charged...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Facts: Retailers use a credit card processing company to process credit transac- tions, and are charged a fee for each transaction. Retailers therefore make less net income on credit card sales than on cash sales. Traditionally, businesses had two choices to balance the inequity: to charge a higher price overall and give cash sales a discount or to charge a credit card customer a surcharge for using a card. In New York, the state legislature passed a law, §518. The law stated "No seller in any sales transaction may impose a surcharge on a holder who elects to use a credit card in lieu of payment by cash, check, or similar means." (N.Y. §518). The statute not only banned the ability to impose a surcharge, but also prohibited the use of the term "surcharge." The ban on surcharges and the use of the term "surcharge" caused merchants significant problems in pricing and promotion. They could not explain a discount or price increase adequately without the ability to say anything about the surcharge. A group of retail businesses joined together and sued New York, claiming that $518 violated their First Amendment right to free speech, among other claims. Legal Reasoning: The State of New York took the position that the law was about price control, not speech. The statute prohibited action (imposing a surcharge) rather than prohibiting speech about pricing or products. The retail merchants took the position that the statute was not a pricing regula- tion statute designed to protect consumers but was instead a prohibition on free speech. Court Ruling: The court determined that the statute did not provide consumer protection from unclear pricing and "prohibited speech outright." The New York statute thus did not regulate retail pricing, but instead regulated the communica- tion of that pricing. The court determined that $518 regulated speech and there- fore was an unconstitutional violation of the First Amendment to the Constitution. Questions: 1. Read §518 in paragraph 2 above. Is it clear that the statute regulates speech about pricing? Why or why not? 2. If you were a merchant you could either charge a surcharge to customers who used a credit card or give a discount to cash customers, which would you choose and why? 3. In a competitive retail market, would it have been reasonable to explain a credit card use surcharge to customers without using the concept of "surcharge"? How would you do that? Facts: Retailers use a credit card processing company to process credit transac- tions, and are charged a fee for each transaction. Retailers therefore make less net income on credit card sales than on cash sales. Traditionally, businesses had two choices to balance the inequity: to charge a higher price overall and give cash sales a discount or to charge a credit card customer a surcharge for using a card. In New York, the state legislature passed a law, §518. The law stated "No seller in any sales transaction may impose a surcharge on a holder who elects to use a credit card in lieu of payment by cash, check, or similar means." (N.Y. §518). The statute not only banned the ability to impose a surcharge, but also prohibited the use of the term "surcharge." The ban on surcharges and the use of the term "surcharge" caused merchants significant problems in pricing and promotion. They could not explain a discount or price increase adequately without the ability to say anything about the surcharge. A group of retail businesses joined together and sued New York, claiming that $518 violated their First Amendment right to free speech, among other claims. Legal Reasoning: The State of New York took the position that the law was about price control, not speech. The statute prohibited action (imposing a surcharge) rather than prohibiting speech about pricing or products. The retail merchants took the position that the statute was not a pricing regula- tion statute designed to protect consumers but was instead a prohibition on free speech. Court Ruling: The court determined that the statute did not provide consumer protection from unclear pricing and "prohibited speech outright." The New York statute thus did not regulate retail pricing, but instead regulated the communica- tion of that pricing. The court determined that $518 regulated speech and there- fore was an unconstitutional violation of the First Amendment to the Constitution. Questions: 1. Read §518 in paragraph 2 above. Is it clear that the statute regulates speech about pricing? Why or why not? 2. If you were a merchant you could either charge a surcharge to customers who used a credit card or give a discount to cash customers, which would you choose and why? 3. In a competitive retail market, would it have been reasonable to explain a credit card use surcharge to customers without using the concept of "surcharge"? How would you do that?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 Based on the provided information it is not explicitly clear from the text of 518 whether the statute regulates speech about pricing The statute itself states that No seller in any sales transaction ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Cornerstones of Financial and Managerial Accounting
ISBN: 978-1111879044
2nd edition
Authors: Rich, Jeff Jones, Dan Heitger, Maryanne Mowen, Don Hansen
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these law questions
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
Which of the following divisions of plants does NOT have a well differentiated body? A) Gymnosperms B) Bryophyta C) Thallophyta D) Pteridophyta
-
(a) Find the monic Legendre polynomial of degree 5 using the Gram-Schmidt process. Check your answer by using the Rodrigues formula. (b) Use orthogonality to write t5 as linear combinations of...
-
The diagram shows the curve y = 2x 2 and the points X(2, 0) and P(p, 0) . The point Q lies on the curve and PQ is parallel to the y-axis. i. Express the area, A, of triangle XPQ in terms of p. The...
-
Maribel Baltazar was hired by clothing retail merchandiser Forever 21 in 2007. During the hiring process, Baltazar was given an 11-page document to sign, two pages of which contained an arbitration...
-
Breyer Company purchased packaging equipment on January 3, 2010, for $101,250. The equipment was expected to have a useful life of three years, or 25,000 operating hours, and a residual value of...
-
2. If a person seeks to report fraud related to a World Bank Group financed operation, to what department within the World Bank should that person direct their report? Describe the process of how the...
-
Shown below is an excerpt from the repayment schedule for Ben Birnbaum's mortgage loan. It was originated on May 1. Interest is paid in arrears. Recall that the interest portion of each payment is...
-
Bentley Company's June 30 bank statement and June ledger account for cash are summarized below: Balance, June 1 Deposits during June Checks cleared during June Bank service charges Balance, June 30...
-
1. Tolerance for diversity, extent of centralization, degree of employee participation, and organic city are all part of which characteristic of upper echelon leaders? Explain
-
Last year your construction company built a 2,400 square foot home with a two-car garage for $255,658. Another client wants a similar home built, except they want a three-car garage. It is estimated...
-
Justin sells Balm, a "miracle, cure-all" fish oil, on his website. People can skip browsing other products on the site by dicking the link Buy now. Justin collects information about how many click...
-
A thin double convex lens is to focus the image of an object onto a screen so that the image is life-sized. The lens has equal radii of 83 cm and the refractive index is n = 1.6. (a) What is the...
-
Jade Larson Antiques owes 520.000 on a truck purchased for use in the business. Assume the company makes timely principal payments of 55,000 each year at December 31 plus interest at 8%. Which of the...
-
Assume you are the accountant for Catalina Industries. John Catalina, the owner of the company, is in a hurry to receive the financial statements for the year ended December 31, 20X1, and asks you...
-
The book basis of depreciable assets for Erwin Co. is 900,000 and the tax basis is 700,000 at the end of 2015. The enacted tax rate is 34% for all periods. Determine the amount of deferred taxes to...
-
How does an asset gain or loss develop in pension accounting?
-
In January 2014, installation costs of 6,000 on new equipment were charged to Maintenance and Repairs Expense. Other costs of this equipment of 30,000 were correctly recorded and have been...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App