Godongwana: Basic income grant decisions will not be made because of political pressure By Sarah Smit...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Godongwana: Basic income grant decisions will not be made because of political pressure By Sarah Smit If some iteration of a basic income grant is eventually rolled out, it will not be because the treasury has buckled under political pressures, Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana said on Wednesday. He was speaking at a media briefing ahead of his budget speech about how a basic income grant might be financed. "The budget for an election is this one-2024 is too late to deal with elections," he said. "Now if you are saying that we will have pressure to raise taxes next year for this election... I don't think so." Last October, when he delivered his medium-term budget speech, Godongwana announced the extension of the R350 social relief of distress (SRD) grant to the end of March 2024. At the time, the government was considering options for a more permanent replacement for the grant, although there had been no decision of how it would be financed. According to the treasury's 2023 budget tabled on Wednesday, the department of social development has been allocated R35.7 billion to fund the extended SRD grant. The South African Social Security Agency will get R400 million to administer it. "Government is considering alternative options to provide appropriate social protection for the working age population that can replace or complement the current grant," the document notes. The social relief of distress grant, which reaches about 7.8 million people, was introduced in May 2020 as a Covid-19 pandemic lifeline to the most vulnerable in society. It has been extended several times since. Earlier this month, President Cyril Ramaphosa said the R350 grant would continue, but was vague about how long it would be extended for. He also announced that work was underway to develop a mechanism for targeted basic income support for the most vulnerable, within our fiscal constraints". The treasury's medium-term budget policy statement noted that the introduction of a new grant in the fiscal framework is a permanent spending increase and that, to be sustainable, it needs to be financed with permanent increases in revenue, spending reprioritisation, or a combination of the two". Keeping the R350 grant in place for another year cost the state R44 billion. "Assuming the current grant value and take- up rate remain constant and it is extended indefinitely, the cost of the grant could grow at an average of 8.8% per year to reach R64.9 billion in 2030-31. Without a permanent source of funding, this would threaten the sustainability of the public finances," the October medium-term budget policy statement noted. The government and civil society have been in disagreement about what form the replacement grant should take. In an August 2022 presentation, the treasury floated the idea of partially replacing the R350 grant with a jobseekers grant or household grant for some. The idea seemingly adapted a 2021 proposal made by the World Bank to replace the grant with one targeted at active jobseekers. A July 2022 paper drafted by the presidency also proposed possible alternatives to the R350 grant, including a jobseekers grant. The South African Federation of Trade Unions responded to the government's proposals by noting that they would significantly limit access to the grant. "The presidency and national treasury's prejudice against the BIG [basic income grant) on the basis that it is unaffordable is based on a neoliberal fiscal framework. That our govemment acts in line with the dictates outlined by global financial institutions such as the World Bank, serves to demonstrate in whose interests the ANC government ruling is," the federation added. Meanwhile, organisations such as the Institute for Economic Justice (IEJ) have disputed the government's unaffordability argument. According to the IEJ - which has proposed a number of financing options, including a wealth tax-a portion of the amount the government spends on a basic income grant would inevitably be clawed back through value-added tax. Spending on the grant would flow back into government revenue in other ways through increased local economic activity, the IEJ has argued. (Source: https://mg.co.za/business/2023-02-22-godongwana-basic-income-grant-decisions-wont-be-made-because-of- political-pressure/, Date accessed 20 February 2023) QUESTION The decision, to or not to provide a permanent basic income grant, has important ethical considerations attached. In this regard, provide an analysis of the various ethical considerations based on the three main ethical models. If the decision to grant the permanent income grant resided with you, what would be your choice and why? Keeping in mind the FOUR (4) types of conflicts can be employed to effectively coordinate intergroup performance. critically discuss any FIVE (5) strategies Under the Occupational Health Safety Act, 85 of 1993, employers must ensure a safe working environment that does not risk the health of employees or others that may be directly affected by their activities. Some employers feel that the act, in the absence of a specific legislation that empowers them to apply mandatory vaccination requirements, opens a loophole for mandates. In light of the statement above, deliberate on the use of Occupational Health Safety Act, 85 of 1993 to impose mandatory vaccination. What is your stance on mandatory vaccination? Godongwana: Basic income grant decisions will not be made because of political pressure By Sarah Smit If some iteration of a basic income grant is eventually rolled out, it will not be because the treasury has buckled under political pressures, Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana said on Wednesday. He was speaking at a media briefing ahead of his budget speech about how a basic income grant might be financed. "The budget for an election is this one-2024 is too late to deal with elections," he said. "Now if you are saying that we will have pressure to raise taxes next year for this election... I don't think so." Last October, when he delivered his medium-term budget speech, Godongwana announced the extension of the R350 social relief of distress (SRD) grant to the end of March 2024. At the time, the government was considering options for a more permanent replacement for the grant, although there had been no decision of how it would be financed. According to the treasury's 2023 budget tabled on Wednesday, the department of social development has been allocated R35.7 billion to fund the extended SRD grant. The South African Social Security Agency will get R400 million to administer it. "Government is considering alternative options to provide appropriate social protection for the working age population that can replace or complement the current grant," the document notes. The social relief of distress grant, which reaches about 7.8 million people, was introduced in May 2020 as a Covid-19 pandemic lifeline to the most vulnerable in society. It has been extended several times since. Earlier this month, President Cyril Ramaphosa said the R350 grant would continue, but was vague about how long it would be extended for. He also announced that work was underway to develop a mechanism for targeted basic income support for the most vulnerable, within our fiscal constraints". The treasury's medium-term budget policy statement noted that the introduction of a new grant in the fiscal framework is a permanent spending increase and that, to be sustainable, it needs to be financed with permanent increases in revenue, spending reprioritisation, or a combination of the two". Keeping the R350 grant in place for another year cost the state R44 billion. "Assuming the current grant value and take- up rate remain constant and it is extended indefinitely, the cost of the grant could grow at an average of 8.8% per year to reach R64.9 billion in 2030-31. Without a permanent source of funding, this would threaten the sustainability of the public finances," the October medium-term budget policy statement noted. The government and civil society have been in disagreement about what form the replacement grant should take. In an August 2022 presentation, the treasury floated the idea of partially replacing the R350 grant with a jobseekers grant or household grant for some. The idea seemingly adapted a 2021 proposal made by the World Bank to replace the grant with one targeted at active jobseekers. A July 2022 paper drafted by the presidency also proposed possible alternatives to the R350 grant, including a jobseekers grant. The South African Federation of Trade Unions responded to the government's proposals by noting that they would significantly limit access to the grant. "The presidency and national treasury's prejudice against the BIG [basic income grant) on the basis that it is unaffordable is based on a neoliberal fiscal framework. That our govemment acts in line with the dictates outlined by global financial institutions such as the World Bank, serves to demonstrate in whose interests the ANC government ruling is," the federation added. Meanwhile, organisations such as the Institute for Economic Justice (IEJ) have disputed the government's unaffordability argument. According to the IEJ - which has proposed a number of financing options, including a wealth tax-a portion of the amount the government spends on a basic income grant would inevitably be clawed back through value-added tax. Spending on the grant would flow back into government revenue in other ways through increased local economic activity, the IEJ has argued. (Source: https://mg.co.za/business/2023-02-22-godongwana-basic-income-grant-decisions-wont-be-made-because-of- political-pressure/, Date accessed 20 February 2023) QUESTION The decision, to or not to provide a permanent basic income grant, has important ethical considerations attached. In this regard, provide an analysis of the various ethical considerations based on the three main ethical models. If the decision to grant the permanent income grant resided with you, what would be your choice and why? Keeping in mind the FOUR (4) types of conflicts can be employed to effectively coordinate intergroup performance. critically discuss any FIVE (5) strategies Under the Occupational Health Safety Act, 85 of 1993, employers must ensure a safe working environment that does not risk the health of employees or others that may be directly affected by their activities. Some employers feel that the act, in the absence of a specific legislation that empowers them to apply mandatory vaccination requirements, opens a loophole for mandates. In light of the statement above, deliberate on the use of Occupational Health Safety Act, 85 of 1993 to impose mandatory vaccination. What is your stance on mandatory vaccination?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Analysis of Ethical Considerations for a Permanent Basic Income Grant There are various ethical considerations associated with the decision to provide or not provide a permanent basic income grant We ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Smith and Roberson Business Law
ISBN: 978-0538473637
15th Edition
Authors: Richard A. Mann, Barry S. Roberts
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these general management questions
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
1. How strong are the competitive forces confronting J. Crew in the market for specialty retail? Do a [Michael Porter] five-forces analysis to support your answer. (see chapter 3 in the textfor...
-
Read the following case study and answer the questions that follow. EDCON Edcon is a 90-year-old retailer in South Africa that came within an inch of collapse in 2018 like its rival Stuttafords. It...
-
Review how once an IDPS detects an anomalous network situation, it has several options, depending on the policy and objectives of the organization that has configured it as well as the capabilities...
-
What is the structure of the a-keto acid formed by transamination of each of the following amino acids? (a) Threonine (b) Phenylalanine (c) Asparagine
-
Discuss the morphological differences between animal and plant development. How are they different at the cellular level? How are they similar at the genetic level?
-
Figure P29.4 shows a square conducting loop centered on the \(x\) axis, with its sides parallel to the \(y\) and \(z\) axes. The loop moves with constant velocity in the negative \(x\) direction...
-
San Jose Sunglasses sell for about $157 per pair. Suppose that the company incurs the following average costs per pair: San Jose has enough idle capacity to accept a one-time-only special order from...
-
Step 2: Smooth Sailing 1. Edit the sshd_config file. [Your bash commands here]
-
What is each shareholder's realized gain or loss? b. What is each shareholder's recognized gain or loss? c. What is each shareholder's basis in their stock? When does their holding period begin? d....
-
A regular hexagonal loop of wire having sides a carrying current / is bent into a book-end shaped loop (two perpendicular planes) of two equal parts. The resultant magnetic field at the centre will...
-
There are probably still a lot of people around who think that the famous British engineering company Rolls-Royce is a car maker, but that has not been true for many years. Rolls-Royce cars today are...
-
Fred Stern and Company applied to the Ultramares Loan Corporation for a credit advance in support of its import business. As was its custom, Ultramares asked Stern for a d e tailed financial...
-
Explain whether modern stadium development projects would best fit the definition of a public use or a public purpose/benefit when a government entity attempts to use eminent domain to take property...
-
Write the stiffness matrix corresponding to the degrees of freedom 1,2, and 3 of the continuous beam shown in Figure P16.2. A SEI Ks= 12- 1 B 2 spring 3 -I+2 L D El= constant
-
Explain the role of a company website in shaping a customers experience of a business brand.
-
Ben has recently inherited a painting by Monet. Excited about his good fortune he hires Bob Villa to remodel his home. The bill from Bob Villa is $30,000. Ben pays Bob with a promissory note for...
-
Open Text Corporation provides a suite of business information software products. Exhibit 10-9 contains Note 10 from the companys 2013 annual report detailing long-term debt. Required: a. Open Text...
-
Explain (a) the elements of a secured transaction, (b) the difference between a mortgage and a deed of trust, and (c) the difference between an assumption of a mortgage and buying subject to a...
-
Discuss the priorities among the various parties who may have competing interests in collateral and the rights and remedies of the parties to a security agreement after default by the debtor.
-
Civil Code 1719, subdivision (a) provides in part that any person who draws a check that is dishonored due to insufficient funds shall be liable to the payee for the amount owing upon the check and...
-
Bhopal is a city in central India with a population, in 1984 , of 800,000 . Because it was, at that time, home to the largest mosque in India, Bhopal was a major railway junction. Its main industries...
-
In the early 1980 s, Colombian drug barons, large landowners, industrialists, and bankers, with the cooperation of the Colombian government, began to create private paramilitary units to combat the...
-
PricewaterhouseCoopers (or PwC, as it is known), one of the United States' "Big 4" accounting firms, has had a tax practice in Russia since the time that country changed from Communist rule. One of...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App