In November last year, OpenAl released ChatGPT, a free chatbot that produces Al- generated text. ChatGPT...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
In November last year, OpenAl released ChatGPT, a free chatbot that produces Al- generated text. ChatGPT doesn't produce responses of particularly high quality, but its capabilities are nonetheless impressive. There have been reports that ChatGPT can currently pass the exams offered by law, business, and medical schools, and its capabilities are only expected to improve over time. Following its release, a moral panic has set in about the impact ChatGPT will have on cheating in school. What should we make of these concerns about ChatGPT becoming CheatGPT? In competitive contexts such as sports or games, cheating is said to be morally wrong because of the harm done to others in virtue of gaining an unfair advantage over one's competitors. In the context of education, cheating can result in similar unfair advantages but the moral harm that tends to take center stage is the harm done to oneself. Students who cheat are harming themselves by failing to respect academic integrity and the cultivation of their learning. Put another way, the misuse of ChatGPT by students is more like cheating at solitaire than it is like cheating at poker. To be sure, there are ethical concerns surrounding ChatGPT insofar as it offers a new way for students to cheat. But one might wonder why the public reaction has been so frenzied. After all, ChatGPT is not the first, nor will it be the last, method students can use to cheat. It joins the ranks of wandering eyes during in-person exams, copying answers from Chegg. buying essays from paper mills, etc. But instead of being treated as yet another way to cheat, the reaction to ChatGPT seems to be characterized by an unusually high level of fear, panic, and desperation, as if it were threatening the very existence of higher education. Educators have flooded online forums to share their tips and tricks for making assignments ChatGPT-proof, an arms race has taken shape with online tools now being created to detect Al-generated text, and scorched-earth tactics are being implemented like the recent move by a NYC school district to ban access to ChatGPT on the school network. Surprisingly, the panic over ChatGPT doesn't actually seem to be about ChatGPT. It's not all that impressive, nor is it significantly more effective than the "old ways" of cheating. Instead, the panic seems to be fueled by the expectation that students won't be able to resist the temptation to use it and that cheating will become rampant. The release of ChatGPT is forcing educators to confront a much deeper issue that has been taking shape for quite some time; students who are becoming increasingly obsessed with grades, GPAS, and completing a degree, and who are willing to go to great, and sometimes unethical, lengths to achieve these things. This transformation that is taking place is best explained by the gamification of education. Gamification refers to the process of adding game-like elements, such as points, scores, rankings and badges, to make non-game activities more pleasurable. As philosopher C. Thi Nguyen has argued, part of what makes gamification so appealing is that it trades complexity for simplicity. Our values and goals become much clearer once we have quantified metrics for measuring our progress and success. In education, gamification takes the form of metrics like exam scores, course grades, GPA, and the completion of a degree. Without these metrics in place, it would be difficult to know when one has made progress towards, or been successful in, their pursuit of the true values of education. After all, the values associated with a good education are diverse and complex, including personal transformation, the cultivation of skills, exposure to diverse worldviews, becoming a more informed citizen, etc. Gamification offers some relief from this complexity by providing unmistakable metrics for success. The problem with gamification is that, over time, it can transform our values and the very nature of the activity such that we begin to lose sight of what really matters. When students enter college, they may be motivated by a meaningful set of values that can be realized in the context of education. For some students, their grades and GPA are just a useful means to measure their progress towards those goals. But for other students, their values wind up being replaced by these metrics such that "getting an A" or "graduating with a 4.0" becomes the end. For the students who get swept up by gamification, ChatGPT is unlikely to strike them as morally wrong or problematic. If a student no longer values education for its own sake, then there would seem to be nothing to lose by using ChatGPT. They won't see it as cheating themselves out of an education, but merely an easy avenue for a passing grade in a course or completing a college degree. When framed this way, the panic over ChatGPT starts to make a lot more sense. Educators are afraid because they know that, despite their best efforts to adapt their assessments to promote learning outcomes in the face of ChatGPT, these efforts will fall short until they can loosen the grip that gamification has on their students. Many of the current conversations surrounding ChatGPT are focused on making it more difficult for students to cheat. Although this may turn out to be much ado about nothing in light of the recent announcement from OpenAl that they will start charging people to access a premium version of ChatGPT and restricting services provided by the free version. Whether or not ChatGPT remains free and widely accessible, education is still confronted with a crisis. It is not the ability to cheat with ChatGPT that jeopardizes education, but rather the increasing desire to cheat fueled by the gamification of education. Personally, I hope ChatGPT is here to stay, for a little while longer at least. For now, it serves as the impetus to reflect on what the purpose of education is and how to achieve alignment between these values and the ones that students come to be motivated by. Looking ahead, the conversation should focus on how to diminish the emphasis placed on grades and GPAs in order to help students reconnect with the true values of education. The case study stated that the public reaction to ChatGPT has been so frenzied to the extent of panic. The author said, "This transformation that is taking place is best explained by the gamification of education." a) Define gamification in education and provide reason for its importance. (2 Marks) b) Discuss from the perspective of students, educators, and future employers, why the panic in ChatGPT and gamification in education "starts to make a lot more sense." Provide your answers for each stakeholder with the relevant example. (15 Marks) (Total: 17 Marks) In November last year, OpenAl released ChatGPT, a free chatbot that produces Al- generated text. ChatGPT doesn't produce responses of particularly high quality, but its capabilities are nonetheless impressive. There have been reports that ChatGPT can currently pass the exams offered by law, business, and medical schools, and its capabilities are only expected to improve over time. Following its release, a moral panic has set in about the impact ChatGPT will have on cheating in school. What should we make of these concerns about ChatGPT becoming CheatGPT? In competitive contexts such as sports or games, cheating is said to be morally wrong because of the harm done to others in virtue of gaining an unfair advantage over one's competitors. In the context of education, cheating can result in similar unfair advantages but the moral harm that tends to take center stage is the harm done to oneself. Students who cheat are harming themselves by failing to respect academic integrity and the cultivation of their learning. Put another way, the misuse of ChatGPT by students is more like cheating at solitaire than it is like cheating at poker. To be sure, there are ethical concerns surrounding ChatGPT insofar as it offers a new way for students to cheat. But one might wonder why the public reaction has been so frenzied. After all, ChatGPT is not the first, nor will it be the last, method students can use to cheat. It joins the ranks of wandering eyes during in-person exams, copying answers from Chegg. buying essays from paper mills, etc. But instead of being treated as yet another way to cheat, the reaction to ChatGPT seems to be characterized by an unusually high level of fear, panic, and desperation, as if it were threatening the very existence of higher education. Educators have flooded online forums to share their tips and tricks for making assignments ChatGPT-proof, an arms race has taken shape with online tools now being created to detect Al-generated text, and scorched-earth tactics are being implemented like the recent move by a NYC school district to ban access to ChatGPT on the school network. Surprisingly, the panic over ChatGPT doesn't actually seem to be about ChatGPT. It's not all that impressive, nor is it significantly more effective than the "old ways" of cheating. Instead, the panic seems to be fueled by the expectation that students won't be able to resist the temptation to use it and that cheating will become rampant. The release of ChatGPT is forcing educators to confront a much deeper issue that has been taking shape for quite some time; students who are becoming increasingly obsessed with grades, GPAS, and completing a degree, and who are willing to go to great, and sometimes unethical, lengths to achieve these things. This transformation that is taking place is best explained by the gamification of education. Gamification refers to the process of adding game-like elements, such as points, scores, rankings and badges, to make non-game activities more pleasurable. As philosopher C. Thi Nguyen has argued, part of what makes gamification so appealing is that it trades complexity for simplicity. Our values and goals become much clearer once we have quantified metrics for measuring our progress and success. In education, gamification takes the form of metrics like exam scores, course grades, GPA, and the completion of a degree. Without these metrics in place, it would be difficult to know when one has made progress towards, or been successful in, their pursuit of the true values of education. After all, the values associated with a good education are diverse and complex, including personal transformation, the cultivation of skills, exposure to diverse worldviews, becoming a more informed citizen, etc. Gamification offers some relief from this complexity by providing unmistakable metrics for success. The problem with gamification is that, over time, it can transform our values and the very nature of the activity such that we begin to lose sight of what really matters. When students enter college, they may be motivated by a meaningful set of values that can be realized in the context of education. For some students, their grades and GPA are just a useful means to measure their progress towards those goals. But for other students, their values wind up being replaced by these metrics such that "getting an A" or "graduating with a 4.0" becomes the end. For the students who get swept up by gamification, ChatGPT is unlikely to strike them as morally wrong or problematic. If a student no longer values education for its own sake, then there would seem to be nothing to lose by using ChatGPT. They won't see it as cheating themselves out of an education, but merely an easy avenue for a passing grade in a course or completing a college degree. When framed this way, the panic over ChatGPT starts to make a lot more sense. Educators are afraid because they know that, despite their best efforts to adapt their assessments to promote learning outcomes in the face of ChatGPT, these efforts will fall short until they can loosen the grip that gamification has on their students. Many of the current conversations surrounding ChatGPT are focused on making it more difficult for students to cheat. Although this may turn out to be much ado about nothing in light of the recent announcement from OpenAl that they will start charging people to access a premium version of ChatGPT and restricting services provided by the free version. Whether or not ChatGPT remains free and widely accessible, education is still confronted with a crisis. It is not the ability to cheat with ChatGPT that jeopardizes education, but rather the increasing desire to cheat fueled by the gamification of education. Personally, I hope ChatGPT is here to stay, for a little while longer at least. For now, it serves as the impetus to reflect on what the purpose of education is and how to achieve alignment between these values and the ones that students come to be motivated by. Looking ahead, the conversation should focus on how to diminish the emphasis placed on grades and GPAs in order to help students reconnect with the true values of education. The case study stated that the public reaction to ChatGPT has been so frenzied to the extent of panic. The author said, "This transformation that is taking place is best explained by the gamification of education." a) Define gamification in education and provide reason for its importance. (2 Marks) b) Discuss from the perspective of students, educators, and future employers, why the panic in ChatGPT and gamification in education "starts to make a lot more sense." Provide your answers for each stakeholder with the relevant example. (15 Marks) (Total: 17 Marks)
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
a Gamification in education refers to the practice of incorporating elements commonly found in games such as points scores badges competition and rankings into educational activities to enhance engage... View the full answer
Related Book For
Contemporary business 2012 update
ISBN: 978-1118010303
14th edition
Authors: Louis E. Boone, ? David L. Kurtz
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these general management questions
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Googles ease of use and superior search results have propelled the search engine to its num- ber one status, ousting the early dominance of competitors such as WebCrawler and Infos- eek. Even later...
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
DTG agreed to merge with the SPQ. The total equity purchase price of $45,000 is going to be 50% financed issuing DTGs common shares and 50% financed with cash raised by DTG issuing long-term debt....
-
Why is the flexible-budget variance the same amount as the spending variance for fixed manufacturing overhead?
-
Suppose that the relation R on the finite set A is represented by the matrix MR. Show that the matrix that represents the symmetric closure of R is MR MtR.
-
Thomas and James, who were operating separate competing businesses, decided on 1 July 2025 to form a partnership by contributing cash, assets and liabilities of their respective businesses. At that...
-
On January 1, 2015, Universe of Fun issues $900,000, 8% bonds that mature in 10 years. The market interest rate for bonds of similar risk and maturity is 9%, and the bonds issue for $841,464....
-
4. 5. In which of following conditions a real gas would behave ideally? (a) Low pressure and low temperature ha (b) At value of temperature equal to its Boyle's temperature (c) Between its critical...
-
Following is partial information for the income statement of Timber Company under three different inventory costing methods, assuming the use of a periodic inventory system: Required: 1. Compute cost...
-
The class excel model includes cost of goods sold but not sold, general, and administrative (SG&A) expenses. Suppose that the firm has $200 of these expenses each year, irrespective of level of...
-
Answer the following questions for the network in Figure 1 assuming the valley-free export-all routing policy. AS 39 AS 36 AS 33 AS 69 AS 66 AS 666 AS 99 AS 96 1 AS 93 1.2.10/23 1.2.8/21 Figure 1:...
-
Rewe Company's income statement contained the following condensed information. Rewe Company Income Statement For the Year Ended December 31, 2022 Service revenue $970,000 Operating expenses,...
-
Based on your plot in Task #2 of the notebook, which two predictors appear to have the strongest relationship with each other? Maternal.Age and Maternal.Height Gestational.Days and Maternal.Height...
-
The success of any project is dependent on a diverse range of skills, abilities and competencies of the project manager which should both inspire the project team to succeed and win the confidence of...
-
1. How are extreme weather-caused catastrophes impacting the decisions of insurance companies? 2. What actions are insurance companies taking to address the increased frequency and intensity of...
-
Use the table above. If the perfectly competitive firm can sell its output for $1 per unit, what is the profit-maximizing level of output? 230 units 240 units O 170 units 90 units
-
What kind of financial pressures can an LBO cause?
-
1. In addition to cash payments, what other incentives do you think might motivate The Coca-Cola Company employees to participate in its wellness programs? 2. The Coca-Cola Company has developed a...
-
1. Explain how customer service fulfills a significant portion of Zappos production function. 2. What kind of firm might Zappos use for benchmarking? Why? If you like shoes, youve heard of Zappos....
-
1. How does Disney fulfill its responsibility to the general public? 2. Which organization benefits more from the Give a Day, Get a Disney Day program Disney or HandsOn? Explain your answer. Pink...
-
Why is it difficult to convict organized crime leaders?
-
How would an audit not catch missing cash amounts of this magnitude?
-
While Al Capone was clearly the leader of his organization and benefited extensively, what enticed others to participate in his illegal activities?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App