Jack and Jill had been going out together for a while when Jill decided to end the relationship.  The main reason for Jill's decision was that she knew that Jack had a violent streak and had seen him involved in fights, most of which he had instigated.  Jill was very troubled by this aspect of Jack's personality. 

 

When Jill told Jack about her decision, he became agitated and pleaded with her not to break things off.  However, nothing violent happened between them and when Jack eventually calmed down, he seemed to accept Jill's decision. 

 

Over the following months Jack went off the rails.  Jill heard from friends that Jack had been arrested several times for fighting.  There was no contact between Jill and Jack during this time. 

 

Then, one summer evening, when Jill was sitting in her front garden, she received a call on her mobile phone.  At first the caller remained silent but after a few seconds she heard Jack laughing hysterically before he said "Here's Johnny - I'm just around the corner and I'm coming to see you." 

 

Jill ran into her house and locked the door.  She then saw Jack, who had entered the house by the rear, standing in her kitchen.  Jill was terrified as Jack advanced towards her with one arm behind his back, seemingly concealing something.  Jill ran into her sitting room, followed by Jack, who closed and locked the door behind himself before backing Jill into a corner.  Then inches away from Jill he pulled out a sawn-off shotgun which he had been holding behind his back and brandished it wildly in the air before placing it to his own head.  Jack then threatened to shoot himself if Jill did not agree to take him back.  In the agony of the moment Jill said "Okay, okay, just give me the gun."  Jack handed over the weapon which turned out not to be loaded. 

 

After this, Jill collapsed in shock on her settee.  Jack sat down next to her and gently took her by the hand and kissed her once on the cheek.  He then started to cry and apologize, trying to explain himself.  When Jill recovered her composure she told Jack to leave, which he did straight away.  Jill then left her house and went directly to stay with some friends. 

 

Advise Jill as to any potential civil claims she may have.  Note that no credit will be given for discussion of criminal liability. 

Answer rating: 100% (QA)

Jill may have potential civil claims based on Jacks actions While criminal liability is not consider... View the full answer