Mr I. M. A. Star is the sole equity holder and manager of Stellar Company (SC)....
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Mr I. M. A. Star is the sole equity holder and manager of Stellar Company (SC). Today (t = 0) SC has assets in place that will generate a final cash flow of either £100 million or £0 in one year's time (at t = 1) with equal probability. There are no other cash flows from existing assets. Mr Star has very recently won the lottery and has a lot of money in the bank (tens of millions) and is thus planning to close down SC in a year's time after these cash flows are obtained. There are no other cash flows, no taxes of any kind, and the discount rate for all cash flows is 0. SC has pre-existing debt on its balance sheet (a discount bond) which matures at t = 1 with a face value of £12 million. Assume that at t = 0 it is not possible to renegotiate SC's debt in any way and any new debt issued must be junior to existing debt. At t = 0, SC has access to a new riskless project (Project 1) that costs £10 million to implement today and pays £15 million at t = 1. Clearly, having won the lottery, Mr Star has the personal resources to invest in this project if it is in his personal interest to do so. (a) (6 marks) Would Mr Star choose to contribute £10 million of his own resources to finance Project 1? Would his willingness to contribute have been different if (counterfactually) SC had no debt on its balance sheet? Show your work and explain your reasoning. (b) (5 marks) Suppose that SC instead had access to a different riskless project: Project 2. Project 2 also costs £10 million to implement at t = 0 but pays a higher amount of £18 million at t = 1. Given the debt on SC's balance sheet, would Mr Star be willing to finance Project 2 from his own resources? Show your work and interpret your finding in the context of part (a). (c) (6 marks) Suppose, counterfactually, that SC owed £18 million to its creditors at t = 1 (instead of £12 million). Would Mr Star's willingness to finance Project 1 or Project 2 differ from parts (a) and (b)? Show your work and interpret your findings. (d) (8 marks) While times are now rosy for Mr Star, they were not always so. Indeed, SC's current debt of £12 million was taken on a year ago (at t = -1) when SC was in dire straits and needed to raise as much liquidity as it could by borrowing. At t = -1, Mr Star and SC's potential creditors all knew that SC would have t = 1 cash flows (as described above) in two years. They also knew that SC would have access at t = 0 to either Project 1 or Project 2 (each as described above), but did not know which project would become available: At t = -1, everybody believed that at t = 0 SC would have access to Project 1 with probability p and to Project 2 with probability 1 - p. SC had two options for borrowing at t = -1: To sell a two-year discount bond with a face value of £12 million or to sell a two-year discount bond with a face value of £18 million. Under the guidance of Mr Star, SC chose to take on debt with a face value of only £12 million, despite its dire need for cash. Following his lottery win, Mr Star recently gave an interview to his university alumni magazine. Interestingly, when asked during this interview why he chose the lower level of debt at t = -1 (amongst the two choices available to him), Mr Star said mysteriously: "Upon reflection, I realized that issuing higher face value debt would raise less money." Can you shed light upon Mr Star's puzzling comment? What does Mr Star's choice say about the relative probabilities assigned by Mr Star and SC's creditors at t = -1 about the prospects of SC having access Project 1 vs Project 2 at t = 0? What general lessons can be learned from this specific example? Discuss. Mr I. M. A. Star is the sole equity holder and manager of Stellar Company (SC). Today (t = 0) SC has assets in place that will generate a final cash flow of either £100 million or £0 in one year's time (at t = 1) with equal probability. There are no other cash flows from existing assets. Mr Star has very recently won the lottery and has a lot of money in the bank (tens of millions) and is thus planning to close down SC in a year's time after these cash flows are obtained. There are no other cash flows, no taxes of any kind, and the discount rate for all cash flows is 0. SC has pre-existing debt on its balance sheet (a discount bond) which matures at t = 1 with a face value of £12 million. Assume that at t = 0 it is not possible to renegotiate SC's debt in any way and any new debt issued must be junior to existing debt. At t = 0, SC has access to a new riskless project (Project 1) that costs £10 million to implement today and pays £15 million at t = 1. Clearly, having won the lottery, Mr Star has the personal resources to invest in this project if it is in his personal interest to do so. (a) (6 marks) Would Mr Star choose to contribute £10 million of his own resources to finance Project 1? Would his willingness to contribute have been different if (counterfactually) SC had no debt on its balance sheet? Show your work and explain your reasoning. (b) (5 marks) Suppose that SC instead had access to a different riskless project: Project 2. Project 2 also costs £10 million to implement at t = 0 but pays a higher amount of £18 million at t = 1. Given the debt on SC's balance sheet, would Mr Star be willing to finance Project 2 from his own resources? Show your work and interpret your finding in the context of part (a). (c) (6 marks) Suppose, counterfactually, that SC owed £18 million to its creditors at t = 1 (instead of £12 million). Would Mr Star's willingness to finance Project 1 or Project 2 differ from parts (a) and (b)? Show your work and interpret your findings. (d) (8 marks) While times are now rosy for Mr Star, they were not always so. Indeed, SC's current debt of £12 million was taken on a year ago (at t = -1) when SC was in dire straits and needed to raise as much liquidity as it could by borrowing. At t = -1, Mr Star and SC's potential creditors all knew that SC would have t = 1 cash flows (as described above) in two years. They also knew that SC would have access at t = 0 to either Project 1 or Project 2 (each as described above), but did not know which project would become available: At t = -1, everybody believed that at t = 0 SC would have access to Project 1 with probability p and to Project 2 with probability 1 - p. SC had two options for borrowing at t = -1: To sell a two-year discount bond with a face value of £12 million or to sell a two-year discount bond with a face value of £18 million. Under the guidance of Mr Star, SC chose to take on debt with a face value of only £12 million, despite its dire need for cash. Following his lottery win, Mr Star recently gave an interview to his university alumni magazine. Interestingly, when asked during this interview why he chose the lower level of debt at t = -1 (amongst the two choices available to him), Mr Star said mysteriously: "Upon reflection, I realized that issuing higher face value debt would raise less money." Can you shed light upon Mr Star's puzzling comment? What does Mr Star's choice say about the relative probabilities assigned by Mr Star and SC's creditors at t = -1 about the prospects of SC having access Project 1 vs Project 2 at t = 0? What general lessons can be learned from this specific example? Discuss.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
a To determine whether Mr Star would choose to contribute 10 million of his own resources to finance Project 1 we need to compare the present value of ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Financial Accounting and Reporting a Global Perspective
ISBN: 978-1408076866
4th edition
Authors: Michel Lebas, Herve Stolowy, Yuan Ding
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these finance questions
-
Ques 1: What is the major complaint by firms concerning the Sarbanes-Oxley act of 2012? A. the legislative maximum allowable compensation for a CEO. B. the legal requirement to disclose project...
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
Multiple Choice: Select the best answer and place it on the line next to the question number. ____ 1. Bond X and Bond Y are both issued by the same company. Each of the bonds has a maturity value of...
-
On 31 March 1980, Philip acquired a 48-year copyright at a cost of 85,000. The copyright was valued at 92,000 on 31 March 1982. On 31 March 2021, Philip sold the copyright for 47,000. Compute the...
-
Discount Drugs (one of the three largest drug makers) just reported that its 2018 third quarter profits are essentially the same as the 2017 third quarter profits. In addition to this announcement,...
-
The ending inventory for Oak Co. was incorrectly adjusted, which caused it to be understated by $18,500 for 2013. Required Was each of the following amounts overstated, understated, or not affected...
-
Bond Features Define the following terms related to bonds payable. Debenture bonds Secured bonds Convertible bonds Callable bonds Face value of the bonds Face rate of interest Issue price
-
NGW, a consumer gas provider, estimates a rather cold winter. As a result it decides to enter into a futures contract on the NYMEX for natural gas on November 2, 2011. The trading unit is 10,000...
-
5-- Calculate the average rate of change of the given Function over the given interval. Round your answer to 3 decimal places. fcx) = 4x2 3,- [5, 1] |:| 6. - SCALCEV12.7.U19. The cost (in dollare] of...
-
On 31 December 20X3, the capital structure of Victor Varieties Ltd. was as follows: $4,500,000 face value of 12% debentures, due 1 April 20X10, convertible into eight common shares per $1,000....
-
Set forth below is a partially completed balance sheet for Episco, Inc., as of December 31, 2016, along with comparative data for the year ended December 31, 2015. From the statement of cash flows...
-
An alkaline battery with an emf of e = 1 . 5 2 5 V has an internal resistance r = 0 . 4 2 5 ohms. a multimeter is used to measure a voltage across R = 1 . 0 0 Kilo - ohms load resistor connected...
-
A firm does not plan to change its current dividend payout ratio from 50 percent. Currently, the firm is operating at full capacity and has the following: sales of $19,700, net income of $3,571,...
-
Question 3 You won the lottery! However, in order to receive your first prize, you need to choose among the following pay-out options. The APR is 20%, compounded semi-annually. Option A: You will...
-
If you invest $5,000 into an account with 7% continuously compounding interest, how much will be in the account in 12 years?
-
1. What is Forensic Biology? 2. How can a Forensic Scientist apply scientific method to their work?
-
At the beginning of the year, a company had accounts receivable of $700,000 and an allowance for doubtful accounts with a credit balance of $60,000. During the current year, sales on account were...
-
Funds are separate fiscal and accounting entities, each with its own self-balancing set of accounts. The newly established Society for Ethical Teachings maintains two funds-a general fund for...
-
Multiple Choice Questions Select the right answer (only one possible answers unless otherwise stated). 1 The statement of financial position/balance sheet emphasizes the dynamics of the cash flowing...
-
aWhat sources of information on a business economic situation, other than financial statements, are available to the general public?
-
Multiple Choice Questions 1. Which of the following statements is not correct? (a) A ratio reflects a business model relationship between two or more variables. (b) When using comparative ratio...
-
How does authority become power?
-
What are the downsides of using coercive power? What are its benefits?
-
How does having extensive social networks help garner power?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App