Raiders Oil Company had been a problem for its auditor, Stabler, CPA, for several years. The...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Raiders Oil Company had been a problem for its auditor, Stabler, CPA, for several years. The company's stock was traded in the over-the-counter market, and management was concerned with keeping net income as high as possible to support the stock price. Each year, the controller would refuse to record any of Stabler's proposed entries if he could establish that they were not material. Accordingly, each year's net income was generally overstated by 5 to 10 percent, which Stabler accepted on the basis that it was not material. Of particular concern to Stabler was a $10 million investment in an oil venture in South America. However, he had been unsuccessful to date in proving to the controller's satisfaction that a loss should be recorded on this investment. During the current year's audit, Stabler discovered a report indicating that the South American oil venture was worthless and had been for two years. When he discussed this report with the controller, the controller suggested that the investment be written off in equal amounts over the next five years to prevent a significant effect in any year and to prevent embarrassment or liability to Stabler from disclosing that past financial statements were misstated. The controller stated that recognition of the loss in the current year would mean bankruptcy for Raiders Oil Company and certain liability for Stabler. RED: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) Assume that the company's stock is being offered for the first time and the provisions of the Securities Act of 1933 apply. If the investment was written off in five installments and the company subsequently went bankrupt in one year, what case would investors who lost money have against the auditor? Explain your answer. Assume the same facts as in (1) above. How might the auditor prove that the investor losses were caused by other factors? Assume the same facts as in (1) above. In your opinion, would the auditor have a due diligence defense against the charge of ordinary negligence? Give reasons for your answers. Assume instead that the stock has been on the market for several years and that the provisions of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 apply. If the investment was written off in five installments and the company went bankrupt in two years, what conditions would have to exist for investors who lost money to prove scienter? Taking the case situation as stated, give reasons why the auditor should accept the controller's solution. What liability does he face if he does accept it? Give reasons why the auditor should not accept the controller's solution. What liability does he face if he does not accept it? What should the auditor do? Give reasons for your answer. Raiders Oil Company had been a problem for its auditor, Stabler, CPA, for several years. The company's stock was traded in the over-the-counter market, and management was concerned with keeping net income as high as possible to support the stock price. Each year, the controller would refuse to record any of Stabler's proposed entries if he could establish that they were not material. Accordingly, each year's net income was generally overstated by 5 to 10 percent, which Stabler accepted on the basis that it was not material. Of particular concern to Stabler was a $10 million investment in an oil venture in South America. However, he had been unsuccessful to date in proving to the controller's satisfaction that a loss should be recorded on this investment. During the current year's audit, Stabler discovered a report indicating that the South American oil venture was worthless and had been for two years. When he discussed this report with the controller, the controller suggested that the investment be written off in equal amounts over the next five years to prevent a significant effect in any year and to prevent embarrassment or liability to Stabler from disclosing that past financial statements were misstated. The controller stated that recognition of the loss in the current year would mean bankruptcy for Raiders Oil Company and certain liability for Stabler. RED: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) Assume that the company's stock is being offered for the first time and the provisions of the Securities Act of 1933 apply. If the investment was written off in five installments and the company subsequently went bankrupt in one year, what case would investors who lost money have against the auditor? Explain your answer. Assume the same facts as in (1) above. How might the auditor prove that the investor losses were caused by other factors? Assume the same facts as in (1) above. In your opinion, would the auditor have a due diligence defense against the charge of ordinary negligence? Give reasons for your answers. Assume instead that the stock has been on the market for several years and that the provisions of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 apply. If the investment was written off in five installments and the company went bankrupt in two years, what conditions would have to exist for investors who lost money to prove scienter? Taking the case situation as stated, give reasons why the auditor should accept the controller's solution. What liability does he face if he does accept it? Give reasons why the auditor should not accept the controller's solution. What liability does he face if he does not accept it? What should the auditor do? Give reasons for your answer.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 The investors would likely have a case against the auditor for not discovering the misst... View the full answer
Related Book For
Financial Reporting Financial Statement Analysis and Valuation a strategic perspective
ISBN: 978-1337614689
9th edition
Authors: James M. Wahlen, Stephen P. Baginski, Mark Bradshaw
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Required Raiders Oil Company had been a problem for its auditor, Stabler, CPA, for several years. The company's stock was traded in the over-the-counter market, and management was concerned with...
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
If the rate of a plane in still air is x mph and the rate of a steady wind is 20 mph, what is the rate of the plane in each case? (a) The plane is flying into the wind (that is, into a headwind,...
-
1. Suppose the required rate of return on stock is 11% and the growth rate is 5%. If the current price of stock is $20, then what is the value of D1 (next period's dividend)? 2. Suppose the required...
-
Rewrite Fig. 7.2 so that the size of the array is specified by the first command-line argument. If no command-line argument is supplied, use 10 as the default size of the array.
-
On March 31, Daisy Tennis Equipment had a $165,000 debit balance in Accounts Receivable. During April, Daisy Tennis Equipment had the following transactions: Sales of $490,000, all on credit. ...
-
Pam Corporation acquired all the outstanding stock of Sun Corporation on April 1, 2016, for $15,000,000, when Sun's stockholders' equity consisted of $5,000,000 capital stock and $2,000,000 retained...
-
OQ1 Various Interest Rate Measures Q1a. (Example 3-1) A Walmart bond you purchased two years ago for $890 is now selling for $925. The bond paid $100 per year in coupon interest on the last day of...
-
' broken_600.png' a) Write a program to draw a picture in Python using the ImageDraw class and then frame the picture according to the following criteria: Y our program "LIOQlinitials.py" must...
-
The definition, " ' Chiropractor ' means a person who is a medical quack with no legitimate scientific background," is an example of: Theoretical definition Definition by subclass Persuasive...
-
Consider 3 neighbors (Ben, Jill and Lisa) deciding whether or not to have a streetlight inthe neighborhood. The light costs $600. They agree in advance that if the light is provided they would share...
-
Reflect on your own experiences with employee selection. What tests or steps were used? Do you think that they were reliable and valid? Describe one thing that you would have changed in the selection...
-
Major appliances in North American homes are designed to use 240 V power sources. A typical Whirlpool Washing machine draws 12.0 Amps of current. Assuming the washing machine is used continuously for...
-
3. A bird with a body length of 10 cm is flying at 10 m/s through air (viscosity of 18.27 x 106 Pas, density of 1.225 kg/m). a. What is the bird's Reynolds Number (Re)? b. Will there be vortices...
-
Let U = {3, 15, 2, 12, 16, 17, 21, 18} A = {3, 21, 18} C = {15, 2, 12, 16, 17} Find A U C'.
-
303 stainless steel, with a Brinell hardness of 270, is turned with a carbide tool with = 8o. The undeformed chip thickness is 0.3 mm, and the cutting speed is 0.5 m/s, the chip is continuous; a 1-m...
-
Design an experiment to demonstrate that RNA transcripts are synthesized in the nucleus of eukaryotes and are subsequently transported to the cytoplasm.
-
Three years of combined data for two firms appear below (in millions). One of these firms is eBay, an online retailer with a three-year growth in sales of 337.3 percent, and the other is TJX...
-
Suppose you are analyzing a firm that is successfully executing a strategy that differentiates its products from those of its competitors. Because of this strategy, you project that next year the...
-
TJX, Inc., an apparel retailer, reported net income (amounts in thousands) of $609,699 for Year 4. The weighted average of common shares outstanding during Year 4 was 488,809 shares. TJX, Inc.,...
-
The Excel formula to compute net income's percentage of sales in Exhibit 7-5, is a. \(=B 4 * B 2\) b. \(=B 4 / B 2\) c. \(=\mathrm{B} 2-\mathrm{B} 3\) d. \(=\mathrm{B} 4+\mathrm{B} 3\) EXHIBIT 7-5 A...
-
Match each component of a computerized accounting system with its meaning. Meaning Component Electronic linkages that allow different computers A. Server to share the same information Electronic...
-
Complete the crossword puzzle that follows. 2 3 4 5 6 Down: 1. Managers need over operations in order to authorize transactions and safeguard assets 3. Programs that drive a computer 4. Electronic...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App