Read the complete case study: Overlands management is considering the proposal from FHP. There are variety of
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Read the complete case study: Overland’s management is considering the proposal from FHP. There are variety of issues involving strategy, cost, risk and capacity. Use the following questions to guide your analysis. Considering the FHP proposal, prepare a recommendation to management. Use the questions 3 and 4 in the Decision section at the end of the case study to organize your recommendation. Responses to each question should be substantive with supporting information and calculations.
Transcribed Image Text:
IMA EDUCATIONAL Case Case Journal Study Over-land Trucking and Freight: Relevant Costs for Decision Making* Thomas L. Albright Naval Postgraduate School ima Paul Juras Babson College The Association of Accountants and Financial Professionals in Business ISSN 1940-204X Russ Elrod Arab Cartage and Express Co. ABSTRACT Over-land Trucking and Freight has a long-established and mutually beneficial business relationship with a major international automotive parts company, FHP Technologies. Management at FHP has approached Over-land with a request to provide additional routes that are important to the efficiency of its supply chain. Over-land s management wishes to nurture the business relationship with FHP but is concerned about the available capacity to service the new routes, potential risks, and profitability associated with FHP s request. INTRODUCTION Alan James founded Over-land Trucking and Freight in 1968 and has grown the business into a sizeable operation with 90 trucks and 180 trailers. His largest customer, FHP Technologies, has submitted a proposal to him to add delivery routes that would improve the efficiency of FHP s supply chain. Alan was not certain that Over-land could handle the additional routes since the company currently was operating at (or near) full capacity. replace older equipment (usually in blocks of five trucks). Alan knew the slim profit margins associated with trucking, coupled with a downturn in the economy, could spell disaster if saddled with too much debt. See Exhibits 1 and 2 for the company s most recent statement of income from operations and the balance sheet, respectively. Roger Simmons, Over-land s operations manager for the past 16 years, had been reviewing the FHP proposal and approached Alan. Alan, we need to discuss this offer from FHP. I think it is a great opportunity for our company, and we need to find a way to make it work. Within 10 minutes Alan and Roger were in a closed-door meeting discussing the pros and cons of FHP s offer. Roger began by stating the obvious: Alan, this is a huge opportunity for us to grow the business. Not to mention, as FHP becomes more dependent on our services, we will be in a stronger position to negotiate future rate increases. I know you are opposed to debt, and I understand the risks of carrying more debt, but there is more than one way to grow our fleet. If you would consider using independent contract drivers, we could grow the fleet enough to accept FHP s offer without incurring more debt. Alan cringed at the thought of using independent contract drivers. Although independent contractors owned their own trucks, Alan viewed them as difficult to deal with and not worth the headache. Roger, I hear you, but this new route will not last a week if we cannot give FHP great service. Independent contractors call the shots, not us. They own the rig and will sit at home if they want to. I would rather deal with our own company s rigs and drivers. The rewards just do not justify the risks of damaging our relationship with FHP. FHP offered a total of $2.15 per mile (including fuel service charge and miscellaneous fees) for the new route. But Alan knew that to accept the offer he would have to add more trucks and perhaps incur additional debt. The question was whether the rates offered by FHP were high enough to offset the associated risks of growing the fleet. Although the business had been grown organically through the years by reinvesting profits, it incurred debt from time to time to *The views expressed in this document are those of the author and do not reflect the offical policy or position of the U.S. Department of Defence or the U.S. government. IMA EDUCATIONAL Case Case Journal Study Over-land Trucking and Freight: Relevant Costs for Decision Making* Thomas L. Albright Naval Postgraduate School ima Paul Juras Babson College The Association of Accountants and Financial Professionals in Business ISSN 1940-204X Russ Elrod Arab Cartage and Express Co. ABSTRACT Over-land Trucking and Freight has a long-established and mutually beneficial business relationship with a major international automotive parts company, FHP Technologies. Management at FHP has approached Over-land with a request to provide additional routes that are important to the efficiency of its supply chain. Over-land s management wishes to nurture the business relationship with FHP but is concerned about the available capacity to service the new routes, potential risks, and profitability associated with FHP s request. INTRODUCTION Alan James founded Over-land Trucking and Freight in 1968 and has grown the business into a sizeable operation with 90 trucks and 180 trailers. His largest customer, FHP Technologies, has submitted a proposal to him to add delivery routes that would improve the efficiency of FHP s supply chain. Alan was not certain that Over-land could handle the additional routes since the company currently was operating at (or near) full capacity. replace older equipment (usually in blocks of five trucks). Alan knew the slim profit margins associated with trucking, coupled with a downturn in the economy, could spell disaster if saddled with too much debt. See Exhibits 1 and 2 for the company s most recent statement of income from operations and the balance sheet, respectively. Roger Simmons, Over-land s operations manager for the past 16 years, had been reviewing the FHP proposal and approached Alan. Alan, we need to discuss this offer from FHP. I think it is a great opportunity for our company, and we need to find a way to make it work. Within 10 minutes Alan and Roger were in a closed-door meeting discussing the pros and cons of FHP s offer. Roger began by stating the obvious: Alan, this is a huge opportunity for us to grow the business. Not to mention, as FHP becomes more dependent on our services, we will be in a stronger position to negotiate future rate increases. I know you are opposed to debt, and I understand the risks of carrying more debt, but there is more than one way to grow our fleet. If you would consider using independent contract drivers, we could grow the fleet enough to accept FHP s offer without incurring more debt. Alan cringed at the thought of using independent contract drivers. Although independent contractors owned their own trucks, Alan viewed them as difficult to deal with and not worth the headache. Roger, I hear you, but this new route will not last a week if we cannot give FHP great service. Independent contractors call the shots, not us. They own the rig and will sit at home if they want to. I would rather deal with our own company s rigs and drivers. The rewards just do not justify the risks of damaging our relationship with FHP. FHP offered a total of $2.15 per mile (including fuel service charge and miscellaneous fees) for the new route. But Alan knew that to accept the offer he would have to add more trucks and perhaps incur additional debt. The question was whether the rates offered by FHP were high enough to offset the associated risks of growing the fleet. Although the business had been grown organically through the years by reinvesting profits, it incurred debt from time to time to *The views expressed in this document are those of the author and do not reflect the offical policy or position of the U.S. Department of Defence or the U.S. government.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Strategic ImplicationsRisks Expand Business Operations or Not Every business faces strategic risks p... View the full answer
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these general management questions
-
Cakes Companys management is considering a proposal to install a third production department in its factory building. With the companys existing production setup, direct materials are processed...
-
Read and complete case study 10-10, "Eat at My Restaurant" in your text. Address the following elements, which are also "required" elements at the end of the case study: Comment on the difference...
-
What is the value of a Treasury Bill that has 91days to maturity, if the face value is Ghc 1,500,000 and the current interest rate is 10%. Assume 365days in a year. b. What is the value of a Treasury...
-
Ms. Acosta received a job as a teacher with a starting salary of $3 According to her contract, she will receive a 1.5% increase in her salary every year. How much will Ms. Acosta earn in 7 years.
-
Criss-Cross Manufacturers will issue commercial paper for a short-term cash inflow. The paper is for 91 days, has a face value of $50,000, and is anticipated to sell at 96% of par value. Criss-Cross...
-
In 2015, employees of Pecos River County earned $5 million in vacation pay. They were paid for $4.2 million but deferred taking the balance of their earned vacations until subsequent years. Also,...
-
Explain what you understand by the terms' decentralization' and 'divisionalization', clearly indicating the difference between them. What are the major accounting problems that have to be over come...
-
Use the following information for The Windshield Pro, a retail merchandiser of auto windshields, to compute the cost of goods sold: Web Site Maintenance.......$ 7,000 Delivery Expense......... 800...
-
5. Identify any asymptotes. How do they apply to the real-world situation?
-
1. Are you persuaded by the states evidence that it had an individual of a different national origin who was treated similarly to Herawi? If Ward (or other managers) treated everyone equally poorly,...
-
Which one of the following settings can be different on the two connected router interfaces to form OSPF neighbor relationship? Area ID Authentication Type Network ID Priority
-
Write a html that uses a form with textboxes, that has as input a number of feet, a button that says 'calculate' and when clicked computes and displays the equivalent number of inches as output. 25...
-
A firm has excess capacity, and has received an order for 50,000 units at $25 each over and above its normal production activity of 600,000 units. To meet this order, new equipment at a cost of...
-
Explain the impacts on Cryptocurrencies, given that new regulations, such' s taxes, will soon be imposed.
-
Fix following code by the following the requirements below. Use the setup code as your source. The objective is to program a two stack and queue method.? import java.util.LinkedList; import...
-
Explain why healthcare organizations need to develop a realistic cash budget upon completion of their operating and capital budget processes.
-
On December 1, 2022 Oriole Company nad the following account balances. Debits Credits Cash $19,400 Accumulated Depreciation-Equipment $3,470 Notes Receivable 2,160 Accounts Payable 6,320 Accounts...
-
A number of years ago the United Food and Commercial Workers Union organized 800 workers of the 1035 employees at one of the Wilson Brothers food operations in Toronto, Ontario. The employees include...
-
In Caroline Company, total material costs are \($48,000\), and total conversion costs are \($60,000\). Equivalent units of production are materials 10,000 and conversion costs 12,000. Compute the...
-
Sota Company has the following production data for April: units transferred out 40,000, and ending work in process 5,000 units that are 100% complete for materials and 40% complete for conversion...
-
Motta Company has the following production data for April: units started and completed 40,000, and ending work in process 5,000 units that are 100% complete for materials and 40% complete for...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App