Suppose that you discover a colleague has run a randomized trial in a particularly poor area...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Suppose that you discover a colleague has run a randomized trial in a particularly poor area of rural Nairobi. In this setting, all farmers initially reported having no access to credit (i.e., their measure of Credit was equal to 0), but your colleague then randomly provided concessional loan to half of the farmers through a local bank so that they now had access to credit. After implementing this intervention, your colleague estimates the same regression as a). However, the regression coefficient b that your colleague estimates is very different from your estimate of the coefficient b. (10 points) Summarize the argument presented in Lecture 4 regarding how randomization solves the selection bias problem. Then, given the differing b estimates, explain which estimate is more likely to reflect the causal impact of access to credit on fertilizer application rate. Does the fact that farmers randomly assigned to the concessional loan treatment subsequently report spending more time on their other jobs affect your response? Why or why not? (10 points) Provide two explanations for why the b estimates from the two studies (in Kenya and Nairobi) would not be expected to be identical even if each reflected the causal impact of access to credit on fertilizer use in the given study setting. (5 points) So far, we have focused exclusively on the size/magnitude of the b estimate, but we have not discussed its statistical significance. Explain how (if at all) the policy implications of your estimate of the causal impact of credit (b) should differ depending on whether the coefficient is statistically distinguishable from zero (i.e., whether we can reject the null hypothesis that the coefficient is equal to 0 with 95% confidence). Suppose that you discover a colleague has run a randomized trial in a particularly poor area of rural Nairobi. In this setting, all farmers initially reported having no access to credit (i.e., their measure of Credit was equal to 0), but your colleague then randomly provided concessional loan to half of the farmers through a local bank so that they now had access to credit. After implementing this intervention, your colleague estimates the same regression as a). However, the regression coefficient b that your colleague estimates is very different from your estimate of the coefficient b. (10 points) Summarize the argument presented in Lecture 4 regarding how randomization solves the selection bias problem. Then, given the differing b estimates, explain which estimate is more likely to reflect the causal impact of access to credit on fertilizer application rate. Does the fact that farmers randomly assigned to the concessional loan treatment subsequently report spending more time on their other jobs affect your response? Why or why not? (10 points) Provide two explanations for why the b estimates from the two studies (in Kenya and Nairobi) would not be expected to be identical even if each reflected the causal impact of access to credit on fertilizer use in the given study setting. (5 points) So far, we have focused exclusively on the size/magnitude of the b estimate, but we have not discussed its statistical significance. Explain how (if at all) the policy implications of your estimate of the causal impact of credit (b) should differ depending on whether the coefficient is statistically distinguishable from zero (i.e., whether we can reject the null hypothesis that the coefficient is equal to 0 with 95% confidence).
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Answer d Randomization solves the selection bias problem by randomly assigning individuals to the treatment or control group thereby ensuring that the ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Microeconomics An Intuitive Approach with Calculus
ISBN: 978-0538453257
1st edition
Authors: Thomas Nechyba
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
The modern day cafeteria is very different from that introduced over 150 years ago. Describe the all the innovations that are often found in todays cafeteria style service.
-
Nonobviousness, Novelty, and Usefulness (a) Imagine that you discover a long-ignored cure for headaches in an old U.S. medical journal from the 1800s, and you apply for a patent. Explain why a patent...
-
(a) Imagine that you discover a long-ignored cure for headaches in an old U.S. medical journal from the 1800s, and you apply for a patent. Explain why a patent examiner would likely reject your...
-
Which of the following pairs of steps in the programming process is in the correct order? a. Code the program, plan the logic b. Test the program, translate it into machine language c. Put the...
-
Three slits, each separated from its neighbor by 0.06 mm, are illuminated by a coherent light source of wavelength 550 nm. The slits are extremely narrow. A screen is located 2.5 m from the slits....
-
In Problems 13 26, find the zeros of each quadratic function by factoring. What are the x-intercepts of the graph of the function? g (x) = 2x 2 5x 3
-
The basic concept behind a learning organization is: A. The popularity to change. B. The people change. C. The adaptation to change. D. The resources of change.
-
Andre Preneur supervises two consulting jobs in the consulting firm of Dewey, Cheatham, and Howe, which does studies on environmental cleanup. One of the consulting jobs is for the Canadian...
-
8-Accounts receivable has a debit balance of $2200, and the allowance for uncollectible accounts has a credit balance of $600. A $70 account receivable is written off. What is the amount of net...
-
Greg Gordon manages the 10,000-square-foot multilevel laser tag arena at LazerLite. This arena combines cutting-edge computer technology with action-oriented team play; in a futuristic environment...
-
Annie ODonnell, an architect, acquired a house in Tarragindi under a contract dated 1 January 2014 for $520,000. She also paid $15,000 in legal fees and stamp duty upon settlement of the property on...
-
On January 1, Year 1, Poultry Processing Company purchased a freezer and related installation equipment for $68,700. The equipment had a three-year estimated life with a $3,300 salvage value....
-
e) If cotx=x lies in second quadrant, find values of other trigonometric functions. 12' f) If a matrix has 8 elements, what are the possible orders it can have.
-
A company requires funds to expand, and decides to issue a rights offering. You have gathered the following information: Number of shares outstanding 11,000,000 Market price per share $28.00 New...
-
A well isulated styrofoam bucket contains 140g of ice at 0 degrees celcius .If 22gms of steam at 100 degrees celcius is injected into the bucket, what is the final equlibrium temperature of the...
-
What is Cognitive Psychology? (2023). The Interaction Design Foundation . https://www.interaction-design.org/literature/topics/cognitive-psychology present two main points from the program or...
-
Which method of speech delivery is carefully prepared to sound as though it is being delivered spontaneously?
-
How is use of the word consistent helpful in fraud reports?
-
Suppose two players are asked to split $100 in a way that is agreeable to both. A: The structure for the game is as follows: Player 1moves firstand he is asked to simply state some number between...
-
Tax Revenues and the Laffer curve: In this exercise, we will consider how the tax rate on wages relates to the amount of tax revenue collected. A. As introduced in Section B, the Laffer curve depicts...
-
Governments often impose costs on businesses in direct relation to how much labor they hire. They may, for instance, require that businesses provide certain benefits like health insurance or...
-
The quantity supplied is positively related to the price because firms supplying goods and services want to increase their _________.
-
An individual supply curve is a graphical representation that shows the _________ relationship between the price and the quantity supplied.
-
An increase in demand is represented by a(n) _________ shift in the demand curve; a decrease in demand is represented by a(n) _________ shift in the demand curve.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App