The barriers to entry into the retail banking industry have traditionally been very high, but there...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
The barriers to entry into the retail banking industry have traditionally been very high, but there are signs they could possibly be tumbling. The high barriers to entry in financial services include two economic categories. First are the structural barriers due to basic industry conditions, and in this industry they include economies of scale, network effects and regulation. The last is significant; to protect the safety and stability of the financial system there are high regulatory walls. Second, incumbents may deliberately promote strategic barriers to keep or drive competitors out, like setting prices artificially low or spending heavily on product and brand advertising. The latter has some importance in banking, but the former does not. However, structural regulation barriers could be considered strategic in this industry as incumbents tend to exploit and lobby for them to their own advantage to keep competitors out. In the UK, these barriers have resulted in the "Big Five' domination: HSBC, Barclays, Royal Bank of Scotland, Lloyds and Santander. Other markets are very similar with a 'Big Five' in Canada, "Big Threes' in Spain and the Netherlands and a "Big Four' in Sweden. It seemed as if regulators would lower barriers to increase competition. However, in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis regulations have increased. The dilemma for regulators is that they have two partly conflicting objectives. First, to secure the stability of the financial system they need to increase capital requirements regulation for banks. The second aim is to deliver more efficiency and more services for customers through increased competition. To act on this second objective, regulators have started to encourage more entrants and assist them to find cracks in the barriers without totally breaking them. For example, Britain's Payment Systems Regulator has proposed that banks should cut their ownership stakes in the core payment systems as Managing Director Hannah Nixon confirms: *There needs to be a fundamental change in the industry to encourage new entrants to compete on service, price and innovation in an open and transparent way." The UK's financial regulators have even launched a start-up unit to help new players to enter as Andrew Bailey, former CEO of the Prudential Regulation Authority explained: *The New Bank Start-Up Unit builds on the work we have already done to reduce the barriers to entry for prospective banks, which has led to twelve new banks now authorised since April 2013." It remains to be seen if competition will increase, but adding to the regulators' aspirations is a new breed of potent rivals that may prove more powerful. Helped by new IT technologies, software and mobile banking there are over a hundred so-called "fintech' (finance and technology) start-ups as confirmed in a Deloitte report: *New, agile and hitherto unregulated players are emerging and are disintermediating the traditional incumbents. Even if incumbents also try to jump on this fintech bandwagon they may not be able to dominate it. In contrast to the flourishing fintech start-ups, they are not only behind the entry barriers, but bound by them as the report continued: *Regulation is making it harder to innovate and grow, whilst legacy strategy, infrastructure and thinking, are preventing the existing players from responding aggressively from this threat." Questions 1. Evaluate the strengths of the banking industry's entry barriers according to Porter's criteria. 2. How would you evaluate the ethical behaviour of banks trying to keep competition out? The barriers to entry into the retail banking industry have traditionally been very high, but there are signs they could possibly be tumbling. The high barriers to entry in financial services include two economic categories. First are the structural barriers due to basic industry conditions, and in this industry they include economies of scale, network effects and regulation. The last is significant; to protect the safety and stability of the financial system there are high regulatory walls. Second, incumbents may deliberately promote strategic barriers to keep or drive competitors out, like setting prices artificially low or spending heavily on product and brand advertising. The latter has some importance in banking, but the former does not. However, structural regulation barriers could be considered strategic in this industry as incumbents tend to exploit and lobby for them to their own advantage to keep competitors out. In the UK, these barriers have resulted in the "Big Five' domination: HSBC, Barclays, Royal Bank of Scotland, Lloyds and Santander. Other markets are very similar with a 'Big Five' in Canada, "Big Threes' in Spain and the Netherlands and a "Big Four' in Sweden. It seemed as if regulators would lower barriers to increase competition. However, in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis regulations have increased. The dilemma for regulators is that they have two partly conflicting objectives. First, to secure the stability of the financial system they need to increase capital requirements regulation for banks. The second aim is to deliver more efficiency and more services for customers through increased competition. To act on this second objective, regulators have started to encourage more entrants and assist them to find cracks in the barriers without totally breaking them. For example, Britain's Payment Systems Regulator has proposed that banks should cut their ownership stakes in the core payment systems as Managing Director Hannah Nixon confirms: *There needs to be a fundamental change in the industry to encourage new entrants to compete on service, price and innovation in an open and transparent way." The UK's financial regulators have even launched a start-up unit to help new players to enter as Andrew Bailey, former CEO of the Prudential Regulation Authority explained: *The New Bank Start-Up Unit builds on the work we have already done to reduce the barriers to entry for prospective banks, which has led to twelve new banks now authorised since April 2013." It remains to be seen if competition will increase, but adding to the regulators' aspirations is a new breed of potent rivals that may prove more powerful. Helped by new IT technologies, software and mobile banking there are over a hundred so-called "fintech' (finance and technology) start-ups as confirmed in a Deloitte report: *New, agile and hitherto unregulated players are emerging and are disintermediating the traditional incumbents. Even if incumbents also try to jump on this fintech bandwagon they may not be able to dominate it. In contrast to the flourishing fintech start-ups, they are not only behind the entry barriers, but bound by them as the report continued: *Regulation is making it harder to innovate and grow, whilst legacy strategy, infrastructure and thinking, are preventing the existing players from responding aggressively from this threat." Questions 1. Evaluate the strengths of the banking industry's entry barriers according to Porter's criteria. 2. How would you evaluate the ethical behaviour of banks trying to keep competition out? The barriers to entry into the retail banking industry have traditionally been very high, but there are signs they could possibly be tumbling. The high barriers to entry in financial services include two economic categories. First are the structural barriers due to basic industry conditions, and in this industry they include economies of scale, network effects and regulation. The last is significant; to protect the safety and stability of the financial system there are high regulatory walls. Second, incumbents may deliberately promote strategic barriers to keep or drive competitors out, like setting prices artificially low or spending heavily on product and brand advertising. The latter has some importance in banking, but the former does not. However, structural regulation barriers could be considered strategic in this industry as incumbents tend to exploit and lobby for them to their own advantage to keep competitors out. In the UK, these barriers have resulted in the "Big Five' domination: HSBC, Barclays, Royal Bank of Scotland, Lloyds and Santander. Other markets are very similar with a 'Big Five' in Canada, "Big Threes' in Spain and the Netherlands and a "Big Four' in Sweden. It seemed as if regulators would lower barriers to increase competition. However, in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis regulations have increased. The dilemma for regulators is that they have two partly conflicting objectives. First, to secure the stability of the financial system they need to increase capital requirements regulation for banks. The second aim is to deliver more efficiency and more services for customers through increased competition. To act on this second objective, regulators have started to encourage more entrants and assist them to find cracks in the barriers without totally breaking them. For example, Britain's Payment Systems Regulator has proposed that banks should cut their ownership stakes in the core payment systems as Managing Director Hannah Nixon confirms: *There needs to be a fundamental change in the industry to encourage new entrants to compete on service, price and innovation in an open and transparent way." The UK's financial regulators have even launched a start-up unit to help new players to enter as Andrew Bailey, former CEO of the Prudential Regulation Authority explained: *The New Bank Start-Up Unit builds on the work we have already done to reduce the barriers to entry for prospective banks, which has led to twelve new banks now authorised since April 2013." It remains to be seen if competition will increase, but adding to the regulators' aspirations is a new breed of potent rivals that may prove more powerful. Helped by new IT technologies, software and mobile banking there are over a hundred so-called "fintech' (finance and technology) start-ups as confirmed in a Deloitte report: *New, agile and hitherto unregulated players are emerging and are disintermediating the traditional incumbents. Even if incumbents also try to jump on this fintech bandwagon they may not be able to dominate it. In contrast to the flourishing fintech start-ups, they are not only behind the entry barriers, but bound by them as the report continued: *Regulation is making it harder to innovate and grow, whilst legacy strategy, infrastructure and thinking, are preventing the existing players from responding aggressively from this threat." Questions 1. Evaluate the strengths of the banking industry's entry barriers according to Porter's criteria. 2. How would you evaluate the ethical behaviour of banks trying to keep competition out? The barriers to entry into the retail banking industry have traditionally been very high, but there are signs they could possibly be tumbling. The high barriers to entry in financial services include two economic categories. First are the structural barriers due to basic industry conditions, and in this industry they include economies of scale, network effects and regulation. The last is significant; to protect the safety and stability of the financial system there are high regulatory walls. Second, incumbents may deliberately promote strategic barriers to keep or drive competitors out, like setting prices artificially low or spending heavily on product and brand advertising. The latter has some importance in banking, but the former does not. However, structural regulation barriers could be considered strategic in this industry as incumbents tend to exploit and lobby for them to their own advantage to keep competitors out. In the UK, these barriers have resulted in the "Big Five' domination: HSBC, Barclays, Royal Bank of Scotland, Lloyds and Santander. Other markets are very similar with a 'Big Five' in Canada, "Big Threes' in Spain and the Netherlands and a "Big Four' in Sweden. It seemed as if regulators would lower barriers to increase competition. However, in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis regulations have increased. The dilemma for regulators is that they have two partly conflicting objectives. First, to secure the stability of the financial system they need to increase capital requirements regulation for banks. The second aim is to deliver more efficiency and more services for customers through increased competition. To act on this second objective, regulators have started to encourage more entrants and assist them to find cracks in the barriers without totally breaking them. For example, Britain's Payment Systems Regulator has proposed that banks should cut their ownership stakes in the core payment systems as Managing Director Hannah Nixon confirms: *There needs to be a fundamental change in the industry to encourage new entrants to compete on service, price and innovation in an open and transparent way." The UK's financial regulators have even launched a start-up unit to help new players to enter as Andrew Bailey, former CEO of the Prudential Regulation Authority explained: *The New Bank Start-Up Unit builds on the work we have already done to reduce the barriers to entry for prospective banks, which has led to twelve new banks now authorised since April 2013." It remains to be seen if competition will increase, but adding to the regulators' aspirations is a new breed of potent rivals that may prove more powerful. Helped by new IT technologies, software and mobile banking there are over a hundred so-called "fintech' (finance and technology) start-ups as confirmed in a Deloitte report: *New, agile and hitherto unregulated players are emerging and are disintermediating the traditional incumbents. Even if incumbents also try to jump on this fintech bandwagon they may not be able to dominate it. In contrast to the flourishing fintech start-ups, they are not only behind the entry barriers, but bound by them as the report continued: *Regulation is making it harder to innovate and grow, whilst legacy strategy, infrastructure and thinking, are preventing the existing players from responding aggressively from this threat." Questions 1. Evaluate the strengths of the banking industry's entry barriers according to Porter's criteria. 2. How would you evaluate the ethical behaviour of banks trying to keep competition out?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 Evaluation of Entry Barriers According to Porters Criteria Threat of New Entrants The banking indu... View the full answer
Related Book For
Management Accounting Information for Decision-Making and Strategy Execution
ISBN: 978-0137024971
6th Edition
Authors: Anthony A. Atkinson, Robert S. Kaplan, Ella Mae Matsumura, S. Mark Young
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these banking questions
-
Riverbed Limited uses a perpetual inventory system. The inventory records show the following data for its first month of operations: Date Explanation Units Unit Cost/Price Total Cost Balance in Units...
-
2. The schematic below represents a distillation column. Based on the information given, write down all the components of the control system and also draw the logic flow control diagram...
-
1. How strong are the competitive forces confronting J. Crew in the market for specialty retail? Do a [Michael Porter] five-forces analysis to support your answer. (see chapter 3 in the textfor...
-
What has been the trend in sales over the years presented? July 29, July 30, 2023 2022 (Unaudited) (Unaudited) Net sales $ 5,164,072 100.0% $ 4,643,014 100.0% Cost of sales 3,115,603 60.3% 2,773,824...
-
Who benefits from subsidies to U.S. sugar producers? Who loses?
-
a. Draw a UML class diagram that describes the Beach Dudes sales and collection process. b. Using Microsoft Access, implement a relational database from your UML class diagram. Identify at least...
-
The following data were taken from the financial statements of The Amphlett Corporation, which is all equity financed. Required 1. Calculate the following ratios for 2016 and 2017: a. Return on...
-
Using the moving average method of perpetual inventory costing and the information presented in E2-6, compute the cost of materials used and the cost of the July 31 inventory. (Round unit prices to...
-
The price of shares of ABC stock was $ 6 0 on January 1 , 2 0 1 8 $ 7 0 on January 1 , 2 0 1 9 ; and $ 6 0 on January 1 , 2 0 2 0 . Paul bought one share of ABC on January 1 , 2 0 1 8 , four more on...
-
For the network of Fig. 7.90, determine: a. VG. b. IDQ and VGSQ c. VD and VS d. V o 20 V 2.2 k 910 k DSS GS. 0 110 k 1.1 k
-
2. Let W, X, Y, and Z be random variables such that: (i) Cov(W, W) = Cov(X, X) = Cov(Y,Y)= Cov(Z, Z) = 0.0802 - (ii) All other covariances are each equal to -0.0123. Calculate: Var(W+X+Y+Z). Round...
-
Examine advanced synchronization mechanisms in RTOS, such as priority inheritance and real-time mutexes. How do these mechanisms contribute to maintaining real-time performance ?
-
Reflecting on your past experience with an employer...Did this employer have a formal compensation method? If yes, was it effective? If no, what could the employer have done differently? Your initial...
-
K A 150-pound person uses 6.3 calories per minute when walking at a speed of 4 mph. How long must a person walk at this speed to use at least 210 calories? A person must walk for at least (Round up...
-
How does memory management in RTOS differ from that in general-purpose operating systems? Discuss techniques for real-time memory allocation and their impact on system performance
-
Given the following array: import java.util.*; String[] fruits = {"Apple", "Mango", "Pear", "Banana", "Cherry"}; a. Write a for loop to loop through the array and print out each fruit on a separate...
-
1. What will the following piece of Java code do? In one to two short sentences, describe how this Java code [does | does not] change the state of the database. public static void insert Employee...
-
Smiths Family Fashions implemented a balanced scorecard performance measurement system several years ago. Smiths is a locally owned clothing retailer with fashions for men, women, teens, and...
-
1. What is the difference between flexible and capacity-related resources? 2. A student develops a spending plan for a school semester. Is this budgeting? Why?
-
Under what condition will the cost savings due to kaizen costing not be applied to production?
-
Bennington Home Products sells home products. It buys products for resale from suppliers all over the world. The products are organized into groups. A few examples of these groups are floor care...
-
Eden Development Company has two competing investments. Proposal A and Proposal B. Proposals A and B have an initial investment of $175,000. The net cash flows estimated for the two investments are...
-
Pyramid Construction Company is planning an investment of \($174,000\) for a bulldozer. The bulldozer is expected to operate for 1,400 hours per year for five years. Customers will be charged \($80\)...
-
Financial statement data is utilized by a variety of user-groups to include a companys board of directors, bondholders, corporate employees and executives, customers, investment advisors, labor...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App