U.S. discount retailer Target Corporation learned some very hard lessons when they attempted to launch their...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
U.S. discount retailer Target Corporation learned some very hard lessons when they attempted to launch their brand in Canada, a launch that ultimately became a high-profile and humiliating failure. Target began by acquiring 189 failing Zeller's stores in early 2011. By 2013's end, 124 of those locations had been converted into Target stores and other outlets were being built in communities across the country. Despite enormous excitement and significant media coverage when these stores opened, things rapidly began to go badly. In January 2015 Target announced their complete withdrawal from Canada and the Canadian division filed for bankruptcy. About 17,600 workers lost their jobs. While the reasons for the failure were complex, human behaviour was a big part of it all. Target Corporation had been confident at the outset because Canadian consumers were already familiar with their brand. Target was a popular destination for cross-border shoppers, a common phenomenon in more southern communities. Since they were already attracting Canadian consumers, the corporation made assumptions about their ability to satisfy this new market. But complaints rapidly emerged about poor product selection and a lack of desirable brands. Canadian consumers were also surprised and angered to discover that prices on some items were much higher than in U.S. outlets. The prices reflected duties, tariffs, and transport costs, but of course the consumers did not care about Target Canada's expense structure; they cared about having their expectations violated and about perceived inequities as compared to American consumers. Communications and the management of important change initiatives were also problematic, as evidenced by the many supply chain problems that were reported. Target Canada did launch a brand-new information system to manage inventory in their Canadian operations, but their failure to transition effectively to this new tool led to communication errors throughout the supply chain-and ultimately empty shelves and frustrated consumers. The resentment only worsened when Target Canada announced their withdrawal from Canada. Target offered all employees 16 weeks of severance pay, well exceeding minimum legal requirements, yet they were still heavily criticized. This was in part because the total value of the compensation package for all 17,600 employees was approximately $70 million while the total severance package (including stock options and benefits) received by ex- CEO Gregg Steinhafel the previous May had been $61 million. Canadians, generally less tolerant of huge discrepancies in pay than Americans, were shocked. Online forums were filled with comments trashing the Target brand and reiterating the importance of "buying Canadian." If anything, Target's foray into Canada seemed to have made Canadians less likely to buy from American retailers, the exact opposite of the stated intent. Questions 1. Business decisions are often assessed in purely financial rather than human terms. How might the study of people in general and organizational behaviour in particular have helped Target with some of the challenges they faced when entering the Canadian market? 2. Outline some of the problems associated with using "gut feel" when entering a new country to do business. Is there any evidence that overreliance on "gut feel" might have occurred in this case? How might scientifically validated information help a company enter a new country more successfully? U.S. discount retailer Target Corporation learned some very hard lessons when they attempted to launch their brand in Canada, a launch that ultimately became a high-profile and humiliating failure. Target began by acquiring 189 failing Zeller's stores in early 2011. By 2013's end, 124 of those locations had been converted into Target stores and other outlets were being built in communities across the country. Despite enormous excitement and significant media coverage when these stores opened, things rapidly began to go badly. In January 2015 Target announced their complete withdrawal from Canada and the Canadian division filed for bankruptcy. About 17,600 workers lost their jobs. While the reasons for the failure were complex, human behaviour was a big part of it all. Target Corporation had been confident at the outset because Canadian consumers were already familiar with their brand. Target was a popular destination for cross-border shoppers, a common phenomenon in more southern communities. Since they were already attracting Canadian consumers, the corporation made assumptions about their ability to satisfy this new market. But complaints rapidly emerged about poor product selection and a lack of desirable brands. Canadian consumers were also surprised and angered to discover that prices on some items were much higher than in U.S. outlets. The prices reflected duties, tariffs, and transport costs, but of course the consumers did not care about Target Canada's expense structure; they cared about having their expectations violated and about perceived inequities as compared to American consumers. Communications and the management of important change initiatives were also problematic, as evidenced by the many supply chain problems that were reported. Target Canada did launch a brand-new information system to manage inventory in their Canadian operations, but their failure to transition effectively to this new tool led to communication errors throughout the supply chain-and ultimately empty shelves and frustrated consumers. The resentment only worsened when Target Canada announced their withdrawal from Canada. Target offered all employees 16 weeks of severance pay, well exceeding minimum legal requirements, yet they were still heavily criticized. This was in part because the total value of the compensation package for all 17,600 employees was approximately $70 million while the total severance package (including stock options and benefits) received by ex- CEO Gregg Steinhafel the previous May had been $61 million. Canadians, generally less tolerant of huge discrepancies in pay than Americans, were shocked. Online forums were filled with comments trashing the Target brand and reiterating the importance of "buying Canadian." If anything, Target's foray into Canada seemed to have made Canadians less likely to buy from American retailers, the exact opposite of the stated intent. Questions 1. Business decisions are often assessed in purely financial rather than human terms. How might the study of people in general and organizational behaviour in particular have helped Target with some of the challenges they faced when entering the Canadian market? 2. Outline some of the problems associated with using "gut feel" when entering a new country to do business. Is there any evidence that overreliance on "gut feel" might have occurred in this case? How might scientifically validated information help a company enter a new country more successfully?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 The study of people in general and organizational behavior in particular could have helped Target ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Auditing a risk based approach to conducting a quality audit
ISBN: 978-1133939153
9th edition
Authors: Karla Johnstone, Audrey Gramling, Larry Rittenberg
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
Read the case study and answer the question below with a one page response. What does a SWOT analysis reveal about the overall attractiveness of Under Armours situation? Founded in 1996 by former...
-
Which statements when inserted independently will throw an exception at runtime? (Choose two.) var x = new LinkedList (); x.offer (18); // INSERT CODE HERE A. B. x. peek (); x.peek(); x. poll ();...
-
In using the bolt cutter shown, a worker applies two 75-lb forces to the handles. Determine the magnitude of the forces exerted by the cutter on the bolt. 75 05 in. I in. I in. 20 im 4 in. 75 Ib I in.
-
An employee earned \($50,000\) during the year. FICA tax for social security is 6.2% and FICA tax for Medicare is 1.45%. The employees share of FICA taxes is a. Zero, since the employees pay exceeds...
-
What is a stock market?
-
The Roanoke, Virginia, distributor of Rainwater Beer delivers beer by truck to stores in six other Virginia cities, as shown in the following network: The mileage between cities is shown along each...
-
Suppose the expected return on the market is 1 2 . 5 6 percent and the return on short - term treasury bills is 2 . 6 6 percent. What is the expected return on a stock with a beta of 1 . 8 7 ? ( Do...
-
Blossom Corporation is preparing the comparative financial statements to be included in the annual report to stockholders. Blossom employs a fiscal year ending May 31. Income from operations before...
-
The accompanying data set contains two variables: x1 and x2. Observation x1 x2 1 0.46 4 2 0.41 1 3 0.96 4 4 0.48 2 5 0.79 3 6 0.70 2 7 0.14 3 8 3 9 0.49 3 10 0.84 2 11 0.90 3 12 0.04 1 13 0.19 3 14...
-
Substitute the given values: Annual Coupon Interest Payment = 8% of $1,000 Current Price of Bond = $964 Calculate the current yield using the formula
-
Find the equation of the circle with radius 5 and centre (1,1)
-
Assuming that all sales were on account, calculate the following risk ratios for 2024. (Use 365 days a year. Round yo to 1 decimal place.) Risk Ratios 1. Receivables turnover ratio times 2. Average...
-
Canadian star tennis player Bianca Andreescu defeated Serena Williams in the 2019 US Open tournament. During the match Bianca served an ace right up the middle of the court. The ball left her racket...
-
CBS will pay its first dividend of $8 in 8 years. The growth rate is expected to be 4%. Ks are 17%. What price should CBS sell for today
-
The relationship between leadership styles and organizational culture significantly influences the effectiveness of management within enterprises. Discuss the theoretical underpinnings of various...
-
Fill in each blank so that the resulting statement is true. A solution to a system of linear equations in two variables is an ordered pair that__________ .
-
Refer to the Auditing in Practice feature, Weak Internal Control Design and Links to Substantive Audit Procedures. Explain how the auditors preliminary assessment of control risk affects planned...
-
TRUE-FALSE QUESTIONS 1. An organization typically has many debt transactions during the year, with each individual transaction being immaterial. 2. Typically, the most relevant assertion related to...
-
What are the relevant accounts when auditing debt obligations, and what is the auditor's primary objective?
-
American firms increasingly adopt stock compensation plans to compensate mid- to high-level managers. Companies are motivated to use stock options as a large portion of the compensation mix because...
-
Snappel Inc. is considering the purchase of new equipment for a purchase price of \(\$ 105,000\). The equipment has an estimated useful life of 5 years and an estimated cash salvage value of \(\$...
-
Keenlen Inc. is considering the purchase of new manufacturing equipment requiring an initial \(\$ 580,000\) investment and having an expected eight-year useful life. At the end of its life, the...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App