Use your knowledge of argument forms and the counterexample method to determine which, if any, of...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Use your knowledge of argument forms and the counterexample method to determine which, if any, of the following statements are true. Check all that apply. If two arguments are not substitution instances of the same argument form, then one argument cannot be a counterexample to the other. Since validity or invalidity is a matter of degree, being a counterexample is also a matter of degree. To be a successful counterexample, an argument must have a true conclusion. If you have made many unsuccessful attempts to come up with a counterexample to a given argument form, then the argument form in question is valid. An argument's form is determined by replacing the content words with letters, while leaving the form words alone. A successful counterexample may have true premises and a true conclusion. "If," "then," and "not" are typical form words for hypothetical syllogisms. A substitution instance is produced by uniformly substituting terms or statements for the letters in an argument form. Some argument forms are neither valid nor invalid. A successful counterexample will use statements with indisputable truth values and terms with precise definitions. If an argument is a substitution instance of a valid argument form and an invalid argument form, then the argument is invalid. In the form for a categorical syllogism, the letters represent statements. Any argument that can be produced by uniformly substituting terms or statements in place of the letters in an argument form is a substitution instance. An argument form is the same thing as a substitution instance. In an argument form for a categorical syllogism, the letters will stand for terms or noun phrases. Use your knowledge of argument forms and the counterexample method to determine which, if any, of the following statements are true. Check all that apply. If two arguments are not substitution instances of the same argument form, then one argument cannot be a counterexample to the other. Since validity or invalidity is a matter of degree, being a counterexample is also a matter of degree. To be a successful counterexample, an argument must have a true conclusion. If you have made many unsuccessful attempts to come up with a counterexample to a given argument form, then the argument form in question is valid. An argument's form is determined by replacing the content words with letters, while leaving the form words alone. A successful counterexample may have true premises and a true conclusion. "If," "then," and "not" are typical form words for hypothetical syllogisms. A substitution instance is produced by uniformly substituting terms or statements for the letters in an argument form. Some argument forms are neither valid nor invalid. A successful counterexample will use statements with indisputable truth values and terms with precise definitions. If an argument is a substitution instance of a valid argument form and an invalid argument form, then the argument is invalid. In the form for a categorical syllogism, the letters represent statements. Any argument that can be produced by uniformly substituting terms or statements in place of the letters in an argument form is a substitution instance. An argument form is the same thing as a substitution instance. In an argument form for a categorical syllogism, the letters will stand for terms or noun phrases.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
The detailed answer for the above question is provided below Lets analyze each statement one by one If two arguments are not substitution instances of the same argument form then one argument cannot b... View the full answer
Related Book For
Governmental and Nonprofit Accounting
ISBN: 978-0132751261
10th edition
Authors: Robert Freeman, Craig Shoulders, Gregory Allison, Robert Smi
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these business communication questions
-
2. The new CEO of Radco Manufacturing has asked for a variety of information about the operations of the firm from last year. The CEO is given the following information, but with some data missing:...
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Googles ease of use and superior search results have propelled the search engine to its num- ber one status, ousting the early dominance of competitors such as WebCrawler and Infos- eek. Even later...
-
Lowell Inc. projects unit sales for a new project with a life of FOUR YEARS as follows: year 1 = Unit sales 10,000 Year 2 = Unit sales 12,000 Year 3 = Unit sales 14,000 Year 4 = Unit sales 16,000...
-
Describe the different forms of two-and three-column cash books with which you are familiar.
-
What does owners equity mean for the owner?
-
For a sample of size 18, the following values were obtained: b0 = 2.27, b1 = 1.46, se = 5.72, (x x)2 = 360.26, and x = 1.95. a. Construct a 99% confidence interval for the mean response when x = 2....
-
Longworth Manufacturing has two producing departments, machining and assembly, and two service departments, personnel and custodial. The companys budget for April 20X1 is as follows: Longworth...
-
Question 3 (30 marks) (a)Define interest rate risk on bond prices. (2 marks) (b)Anson is studying the interest rate risk of two bonds that he is holding. Bond A is with longer term to maturity than...
-
For the differential equation " +2y +1y-zin(8z) Part 1: Solve the homogeneous equation The differential operator for the homogeneous equation is List the complementary functions Part 2: Find the...
-
What two decisions do advertisers make in developing a media strategy? What are the four basic media scheduling alternatives? Provide an example of each type of media scheduling.
-
Provide examples of how technology has increased the ticket prices of professional sporting events. Support your examples from a cost perspective.
-
What questions or issues might an organization raise when choosing among sponsorship opportunities?
-
In your opinion, why are sports sponsorships so successful in reaching a specific target market?
-
Find at least one example of sponsorship for each of the following athletic platforms: individual athlete, team, and league.
-
Which of the following statements best describes the meaning of a glycoside? Select one: O It is the hemiacetal of a sugar. O It is the mirror image of a sugar. O It is the acetal of a sugar. O It is...
-
What does non-recourse financing mean?
-
Neither the capital assets acquired through a Capital Projects Fund nor the long-term debt issued to finance capital projects is normally accounted for in the CPF. Why? Where are such capital assets...
-
Revenues Subsidiary Ledger accounts classified by major revenue source category and Expenditures Subsidiary Ledger accounts classified by function. Could more detailed subsidiary ledger accounts be...
-
Why are nonrevenue financing sources and nonexpenditure uses of financial resources distinguished from governmental fund revenues and expenditures?
-
Which of the following questions would an auditor ask while auditing accounts receivable to add value to an audit? a. Are accounts receivable pledged? b. Are customers satisfied with your billing...
-
What are some inquiries an auditor can make when examining the long-term debt account to add value to the audit?
-
Beta, Inc., is an affiliate of an audit client and is audited by another firm of auditors. Which of the following is most likely to be used by the auditor to obtain assurance that all guarantees of...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App