*Using overly expensive IT-driven CRM projects, other companies paved the way for Shell, is one of...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
*Using overly expensive IT-driven CRM projects, other companies paved the way for Shell, is one of the opening remarks made during an interview with Ruud van Munster, Shell s European Loyalty and CRM Manager. The oil company has learned from its failures and has chosen not to implement CRM on a Europe-wide scale, but instead to take a step-by-step approach. A country-by-country basis Shell has elected to expand its CRM programme on a country-by-country basis and is currently (2004) active in nine out of seventeen targeted countries. Munster: We first want to prove that something works on a small scale before we invest in something huge. There are too many CRM failures in the world. There are already too many projects in which the IT focus is too strong. Companies stare at huge CRM systems with abundant possibilities for which they have no sound application. If you do not know how to use them to create customer and company value and just climb aboard the CRM train, you will not succeed. According to van Munster, too many companies have also implemented a call centre without first formulating a proper business case. In our organisation IT follows and we only install a call centre if we are convinced it will improve sales. We spend as little as pos sible on operations. Besides, a European CRM system is not necessary in our organisation since there are only a few customers that fill up their cars across the border and those that do are normally less brand loyal. Shell currently maintains its own Shell (Club) Smart programme in thirteen countries and a coalition programme in four countries: Air Miles in the Netherlands, Happy Days in Belgium, Thrumf in Norway and Smiles in France. The fuel card that can be used to pay for the fuel can also be seen as a loyalty programme and is in use in the Scandinavian countries. Shell has created a three-layered CRM organisation: A loyalty competency centre in Hungary with IT and CRM knowledge. Van Munster: Hungary is known for the quality of its IT people, in addition to being one of the most successful countries for the Shell loyalty programme. A European team of CRM experts; each of the team members has strategic responsibility for a cluster of countries. The local loyalty and CRM groups in the countries, who implement the programmes and have succeeded in creating value. Van Munster: Centralisation has absolutely paid off. It was here that we developed our standard building blocks that we can apply to the countries. A few years ago we needed one year per country to implement a programme; now we do it in three months. If it is up to van Munster, CRM applications will be further simplified and standardised in 2004, mak- ing implementation easier for local CRM teams. Practical efficiency is the goal. Perhaps it will become possible at some point to produce a single European or even global catalogue instead of national versions, and the articles can be sourced at lower cost. Chapter 18 Implementation of CRM systems Case study (continued) Facts Is this approach typical for a follower? No, if we ask van Munster. You have to find out what does and what does not work on a step-by-step basis. You have to remain pragmatic. We sell fuel and cannot innovate CRM theory. At present, Shell has a database of 20 million customers in Europe. This database is filled country by country and is currently operational in seventeen countries. The relation and transaction data are known and it is possible to identify customers and send them correspondence or products. It is possible to look into the database to find out how active they are, how frequently they cash in their loyalty points, determine their fuel purchasing behaviour and evaluate the value that they repre- sent. Van Munster likes facts: Not many consumers will admit that loyalty points influence their choice of a fuel brand, but practice has proven otherwise. I attach more value to infor- mation I get from the database than to the results obtained through traditional market research. There is a difference between what consumers say and what they actually do. Shell actions Crucial within Shell is the accountability for a campaign. Control groups are used, for example, to show the value of a campaign. In France we noticed a significant difference in customer revenue. Campaigns pay off and add approximately 10 percentage points. We had campaigns with a 50 to 60 per cent response rate, which is extremely high. The road warriors in particular, the group that drives a lot and buys plenty of petrol, responds quite well. They love to reach the individual target we communicated to them. The example here is England where key customers received eight to ten e-mails during the summer with the offer of increasing their loyalty points by buying additional litres of fuel. They saw it as a game and took on the challenge. E-mail has become a favourite, although Shell will continue to send physical mailings as well. In three hours time you can invent and create an e-mail campaign; in a regular direct mail process this will take much longer. I do not want to abandon traditional direct mail, as it is part of the multichannel approach and complements the other channels, but the internet is gaining ground. Intranet In England, the entire CRM operation, including the call centre, is outsourced to Carlson. Shell s competence centre, however, remains in charge and manages the relationship with Carlson. The future of outsourcing depends on several factors. In England, Shell has made good progress with CRM, the wages are high and there is a wide range of service providers. But taking on the challenge in-house also has its advantages as has been proven in Hungary, a country with 2.2 million cars and 2 million Smart customers in Shell s database. Smart customers can cash their points in at McDonald s and this makes the loyalty programme attractive for many. Success depends to a large extent on the efforts and spirit of the local organisation, according to van Munster. Crucial to the organisation of CRM is the communication between the three layers and it is here that the web is useful. Shell has a European portal, an intranet, which functions simultaneously as a knowledge base, a communication vehicle and the beginning of e-mail campaigns. Van Munster: Nearly everything we know about the 20 million customers may be traced on the intranet. Target groups in the seventeen countries and the success of campaigns are described in detail. If Turkey wants to copy a British campaign, they first read everything on the intranet and then get together for a face-to-face meeting to further 393 CRM systems and their implementation Case study (continued) develop the campaign. Each country has access to the available information. But only the local people have permission to access relationship data. This online tool is for us the basis for guiding CRM. You can do as much with it as you want. You can select customers for your campaign, based upon their life-time value or transaction profile and you can approach them whenever you want. Conclusion The CRM targets differ per country and are defined using terms such as retention, reactiva- tion and share of wallet. Van Munster: If we realise a retention rate of 68 per cent in the experimental group for the high value customers and 58 per cent in the control group, you can say that CRM is a success. Questions 1 What are key factors determining the success of Shell s CRM approach? 2 How would you formulate Shell s vision and strategy towards CRM? 3 Reconstruct Shell s CRM road map. 4 Formulate Shell s CRM business case(s). 5 How useful will a standardised global CRM approach be for Shell? Why? Source: Olsthoorn (2004) *Using overly expensive IT-driven CRM projects, other companies paved the way for Shell, is one of the opening remarks made during an interview with Ruud van Munster, Shell s European Loyalty and CRM Manager. The oil company has learned from its failures and has chosen not to implement CRM on a Europe-wide scale, but instead to take a step-by-step approach. A country-by-country basis Shell has elected to expand its CRM programme on a country-by-country basis and is currently (2004) active in nine out of seventeen targeted countries. Munster: We first want to prove that something works on a small scale before we invest in something huge. There are too many CRM failures in the world. There are already too many projects in which the IT focus is too strong. Companies stare at huge CRM systems with abundant possibilities for which they have no sound application. If you do not know how to use them to create customer and company value and just climb aboard the CRM train, you will not succeed. According to van Munster, too many companies have also implemented a call centre without first formulating a proper business case. In our organisation IT follows and we only install a call centre if we are convinced it will improve sales. We spend as little as pos sible on operations. Besides, a European CRM system is not necessary in our organisation since there are only a few customers that fill up their cars across the border and those that do are normally less brand loyal. Shell currently maintains its own Shell (Club) Smart programme in thirteen countries and a coalition programme in four countries: Air Miles in the Netherlands, Happy Days in Belgium, Thrumf in Norway and Smiles in France. The fuel card that can be used to pay for the fuel can also be seen as a loyalty programme and is in use in the Scandinavian countries. Shell has created a three-layered CRM organisation: A loyalty competency centre in Hungary with IT and CRM knowledge. Van Munster: Hungary is known for the quality of its IT people, in addition to being one of the most successful countries for the Shell loyalty programme. A European team of CRM experts; each of the team members has strategic responsibility for a cluster of countries. The local loyalty and CRM groups in the countries, who implement the programmes and have succeeded in creating value. Van Munster: Centralisation has absolutely paid off. It was here that we developed our standard building blocks that we can apply to the countries. A few years ago we needed one year per country to implement a programme; now we do it in three months. If it is up to van Munster, CRM applications will be further simplified and standardised in 2004, mak- ing implementation easier for local CRM teams. Practical efficiency is the goal. Perhaps it will become possible at some point to produce a single European or even global catalogue instead of national versions, and the articles can be sourced at lower cost. Chapter 18 Implementation of CRM systems Case study (continued) Facts Is this approach typical for a follower? No, if we ask van Munster. You have to find out what does and what does not work on a step-by-step basis. You have to remain pragmatic. We sell fuel and cannot innovate CRM theory. At present, Shell has a database of 20 million customers in Europe. This database is filled country by country and is currently operational in seventeen countries. The relation and transaction data are known and it is possible to identify customers and send them correspondence or products. It is possible to look into the database to find out how active they are, how frequently they cash in their loyalty points, determine their fuel purchasing behaviour and evaluate the value that they repre- sent. Van Munster likes facts: Not many consumers will admit that loyalty points influence their choice of a fuel brand, but practice has proven otherwise. I attach more value to infor- mation I get from the database than to the results obtained through traditional market research. There is a difference between what consumers say and what they actually do. Shell actions Crucial within Shell is the accountability for a campaign. Control groups are used, for example, to show the value of a campaign. In France we noticed a significant difference in customer revenue. Campaigns pay off and add approximately 10 percentage points. We had campaigns with a 50 to 60 per cent response rate, which is extremely high. The road warriors in particular, the group that drives a lot and buys plenty of petrol, responds quite well. They love to reach the individual target we communicated to them. The example here is England where key customers received eight to ten e-mails during the summer with the offer of increasing their loyalty points by buying additional litres of fuel. They saw it as a game and took on the challenge. E-mail has become a favourite, although Shell will continue to send physical mailings as well. In three hours time you can invent and create an e-mail campaign; in a regular direct mail process this will take much longer. I do not want to abandon traditional direct mail, as it is part of the multichannel approach and complements the other channels, but the internet is gaining ground. Intranet In England, the entire CRM operation, including the call centre, is outsourced to Carlson. Shell s competence centre, however, remains in charge and manages the relationship with Carlson. The future of outsourcing depends on several factors. In England, Shell has made good progress with CRM, the wages are high and there is a wide range of service providers. But taking on the challenge in-house also has its advantages as has been proven in Hungary, a country with 2.2 million cars and 2 million Smart customers in Shell s database. Smart customers can cash their points in at McDonald s and this makes the loyalty programme attractive for many. Success depends to a large extent on the efforts and spirit of the local organisation, according to van Munster. Crucial to the organisation of CRM is the communication between the three layers and it is here that the web is useful. Shell has a European portal, an intranet, which functions simultaneously as a knowledge base, a communication vehicle and the beginning of e-mail campaigns. Van Munster: Nearly everything we know about the 20 million customers may be traced on the intranet. Target groups in the seventeen countries and the success of campaigns are described in detail. If Turkey wants to copy a British campaign, they first read everything on the intranet and then get together for a face-to-face meeting to further 393 CRM systems and their implementation Case study (continued) develop the campaign. Each country has access to the available information. But only the local people have permission to access relationship data. This online tool is for us the basis for guiding CRM. You can do as much with it as you want. You can select customers for your campaign, based upon their life-time value or transaction profile and you can approach them whenever you want. Conclusion The CRM targets differ per country and are defined using terms such as retention, reactiva- tion and share of wallet. Van Munster: If we realise a retention rate of 68 per cent in the experimental group for the high value customers and 58 per cent in the control group, you can say that CRM is a success. Questions 1 What are key factors determining the success of Shell s CRM approach? 2 How would you formulate Shell s vision and strategy towards CRM? 3 Reconstruct Shell s CRM road map. 4 Formulate Shell s CRM business case(s). 5 How useful will a standardised global CRM approach be for Shell? Why? Source: Olsthoorn (2004)
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Answers to the case 1 The key factors determining the success of Shells CRM approach are the following Implementation in small scale to use the applicability of the CRM rather than spending huge amoun... View the full answer
Related Book For
Modern Database Management
ISBN: 978-0133544619
12th edition
Authors: Jeff Hoffer, Ramesh Venkataraman, Heikki Topi
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these organizational behavior questions
-
If there are too many leaves on some stems in a stem-and-leaf display, we might double the number of stems. The leaves 0-4 could hang on one stem and 5-9 on the repeated stem. For the observations we...
-
In Figure S is a small loudspeaker driven by an audio oscillator with a frequency that is varied from 1000 Hz to 2000 Hz, and D is a cylindrical pipe with two open ends and a length of 45.7 cm. The...
-
Many companies are building customer databases through loyalty programs. One example is the Optimum program of Shoppers Drug Mart Corporation. Customers collect Optimum points when they spend money...
-
In 2006, Walmart was operating more than 6,500 stores with 1.8 million employees around the world. In the early 1990s, Walmart Stores Inc. expanded into Canada, with the purchase of 122 stores from...
-
The dean of a business school wishes to form an executive committee of 5 from among the 40 tenured faculty members at the school. The selection is to be random, and at the school there are 8 tenured...
-
Use implicit differentiation of the equations in Exercises to determine the slope of the graph at the given point. 4y 3 - x 2 = -5; x = 3, y = 1
-
A \(250-\mathrm{m}\)-long ship has a wetted area of \(8000 \mathrm{~m}^{2}\). A \(\frac{1}{100}\)-scale model is tested in a towing tank with the prototype fluid, and the results are: Calculate the...
-
Water Sport Inc. manufactures a small personal water tube used for children learning to swim. Management is now preparing detailed budgets for the third quarter, July through September, and has...
-
If the two lines intersect, then k= x-1 y-67=2+2 3 2 x=Y+1 -z+k 2
-
Ruth Dennis, CEO of Prescott Industries, is concerned about the recent volatility in the company's operating income. She believes that since the number of units sold has been fairly stable over the...
-
A red blood cell has a mass of about 0.000000000027 g. Convert this mass to an appropriate SI prefix and unit, so the number portion does not need a decimal place (i.e. an integer number). Your...
-
Consider a Swiss Confederation zero-coupon bond with a par value of CHF100, a remaining time to maturity of 12 years and a price of CHF89. In three years time, the bond is expected to have a price of...
-
Crimes against decency and/or morality include incest, indecent exposure, voyeurism, bigamy, polygamy, and, in some jurisdictions, profanity. Incest refers to sexual intercourse with certain...
-
Prostitution is defined as performing or agreeing to perform a sexual act for hire. It is criminalized in all states, except Nevada, where a limited number of rural counties license legal brothels. ...
-
Suppose Mylandia announces that it expects significant cash flow growth over the next three years, and now plans to increase its recent CAD2.40 dividend by 10 percent in each of the next three years....
-
Describe the strategies in the game that Coca-Cola and PepsiCo play. With some assumed payoffs, create a payoff matrix for the game and find the equilibrium outcome. Whats your soft drink of choice?...
-
Job 877 Job 878 Job 879 Job 880 Direct materials $14,430 $6,080 $3,490 $1,730 Direct labor 15,000 8,000 1,900 2,400 Overhead is applied to production at the rate of 75% of direct labor cost. Job 877...
-
Determine two different Hamilton circuits in each of the following graphs. A B F G
-
Describe the changing roles of a data administrator and database administrator in environment.
-
Discuss the purposes for which data mining can be used.
-
What is the difference between COUNT, COUNT DISTINCT, and COUNT(*) in SQL? When will these three commands generate the same and different results?
-
At December 31, 2025, the fair value of non-trading securities is 41,300 and the cost is 39,800. At January 1, 2025, there was a credit balance of 900 in the Fair Value Adjustment Non-Trading...
-
On January 1, 2025, Lennon Enterprises acquires 100% of Ono Ltd. for 220,000 in cash. The condensed statements of financial position of the two companies immediately following the acquisition are as...
-
Which of the following will not be reported in the statement of cash flows? a. The net change in plant assets during the year. b. Cash payments for plant assets during the year. c. Cash receipts from...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App