Was There a Fair Hearing? Baker v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration)79 A woman was...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Was There a Fair Hearing? Baker v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration)79 A woman was ordered deported. She applied, on humanitarian and compassionate grounds, for an exemption from the rule that an application for permanent residency had to be made from outside of Canada. Her application was supported by letters about the availability of medical care in her home country and the effect of her depar- ture on her Canadian-born children. An immigration officer refused her application by letter, without providing reasons for his decision. The Supreme Court indicated that the duty of procedural fairness is flexible and vari- able. The extent of the duty depends on several factors, including the nature of the deci- sion (the more an administrative tribunal is designed like a court, the higher the duty of fairness), the relevant legislation (greater procedural fairness is required if there is no appeal process, the decision is determinative/final, and there are no further requests that can be made of the tribunal), the importance of the decision to the individual affected (the higher the stakes, the higher the requirement of fairness), and the procedure fol- lowed in making it (legitimate expectations of the party[ies] regarding the level of proce- dural fairness that ought to be part of the decision-making process). Here the claimant had to have an opportunity to present evidence and to have it fully and fairly considered. An oral hearing was not required; the chance to provide written documentation was suf- ficient. Written notes prepared by a junior officer that were provided to the claimant's lawyer were a sufficient explanation of the decision. The claimant was successful, how- ever, because these notes gave rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias. The decision appeared to be based on the fact that the claimant was a single mother with several children and had been diagnosed with a psychiatric illness. This was inappropriate; deci- sions of this nature should instead be made impartially, based on the evidence. The Court ordered that another hearing be held in front of a different immigration officer. DISCUSSION QUESTIONS Are the standards imposed on administrative tribunals too onerous? Should the courts ever have the power to interfere with the operation of statutory tribunals in the execu- tion of their function? Should such tribunals remain unfettered from the restrictions of rules and procedures found in the court process? What do you think? Was There a Fair Hearing? Baker v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration)79 A woman was ordered deported. She applied, on humanitarian and compassionate grounds, for an exemption from the rule that an application for permanent residency had to be made from outside of Canada. Her application was supported by letters about the availability of medical care in her home country and the effect of her depar- ture on her Canadian-born children. An immigration officer refused her application by letter, without providing reasons for his decision. The Supreme Court indicated that the duty of procedural fairness is flexible and vari- able. The extent of the duty depends on several factors, including the nature of the deci- sion (the more an administrative tribunal is designed like a court, the higher the duty of fairness), the relevant legislation (greater procedural fairness is required if there is no appeal process, the decision is determinative/final, and there are no further requests that can be made of the tribunal), the importance of the decision to the individual affected (the higher the stakes, the higher the requirement of fairness), and the procedure fol- lowed in making it (legitimate expectations of the party[ies] regarding the level of proce- dural fairness that ought to be part of the decision-making process). Here the claimant had to have an opportunity to present evidence and to have it fully and fairly considered. An oral hearing was not required; the chance to provide written documentation was suf- ficient. Written notes prepared by a junior officer that were provided to the claimant's lawyer were a sufficient explanation of the decision. The claimant was successful, how- ever, because these notes gave rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias. The decision appeared to be based on the fact that the claimant was a single mother with several children and had been diagnosed with a psychiatric illness. This was inappropriate; deci- sions of this nature should instead be made impartially, based on the evidence. The Court ordered that another hearing be held in front of a different immigration officer. DISCUSSION QUESTIONS Are the standards imposed on administrative tribunals too onerous? Should the courts ever have the power to interfere with the operation of statutory tribunals in the execu- tion of their function? Should such tribunals remain unfettered from the restrictions of rules and procedures found in the court process? What do you think?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
No the standards imposed on adminstrative tribunals are not too onerous as it is only bound by princ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Dynamic Business Law The Essentials
ISBN: 978-0078023842
3rd edition
Authors: Nancy K. Kubasek, M. Neil Browne, Daniel J. Herron, Lucien Dhooge Sue
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these economics questions
-
The U.S. Bureau of Citizenship and Immigration Services collects and reports information about naturalized persons in Statistical Yearbook. Following is an age distribution for persons naturalized...
-
The U.S. Bureau of Citizenship and Immigration Services collects and reports information about naturalized persons in Statistical Yearbook. The following table gives a joint probability distribution...
-
The U.S. Bureau of Citizenship and Immigration Services collects and reports information about naturalized persons in Statistical Yearbook. Suppose that a naturalized person is selected at random....
-
Alpha Mann Ltd makes and sells computer carry bags. Bill Blake, the company accountant, is responsible for preparing the company's annual budget. In compiling the budget data for next year, Blake has...
-
How should appreciation of a firms home currency generally affect its cash inflows? How should depreciation of a firms home currency generally affect its cash outflows?
-
Suppose that the sampling experiment described in Example 8.1 had used samples of size 10 rather than size 5. If 50 samples of size 10 were selected, the x value for each sample computed, and a...
-
\(\frac{10}{\sqrt{6}+7}\) Rationalize the denominator of the fraction, and then simplify the fraction.
-
Navajo Companys financial statements show the following. The company recently discovered that in making physical counts of inventory, it had made the following errors: Inventory on December 31, 2012,...
-
You are the purchasing agent for a cereal company. You anticipate that your firm will need 100,000 bushels of wheat in August. The futures contracts on wheat is based on 5,000 bushels and are...
-
John Parsons (123-45-6781) and George Smith (123-45-6782) are 70% and 30% owners, respectively, of Premium, Inc. (11-1111111), a candy company located at 1005 16th Street, Cut and Shoot, TX 77303....
-
A company has two pieces of Inventory, A and B. Inventory A cost the company P40 per unit and can now be sold for P60 per unit after incurring P15 in selling expenses per unit. It has a replacement...
-
Discuss the various incentives and mechanisms of earnings management in firms. Your discussion should provide a comprehensive definition of earnings management. How may earnings management behaviour...
-
Discuss specifically the corporate governance Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats (SWOT) of ORACLE CORPORATION. Explain in detail! how some of the observations you have made relate to...
-
Company X is an online pharmacy. Recently, colleagues used a computer program to analyze the purchasing behavior of customers sorted by ZIP code and found that customers in some ZIP codes are, on...
-
You are the audit manager for the audit of Master Mines Limited. It is a listed company in Hong Kong, specializing in sulphur exploitation in various parts of the world (with five different...
-
(c) This question is about Hill cipher. The plaintex "ME" 12 The key K' is (3). 1 3 K- is 24 7) - ( 25 2). 1 i. Show what the ciphertext C will be. You need to show your calculations. ii. Show the...
-
Maria is a refugee from Columbia who has feelings of sadness, loneliness, and guilt about her living arrangement she is a widow who know lives in a common law relationship who is not the father of...
-
The Strahler Stream Order System ranks streams based on the number of tributaries that have merged. It is a top-down system where rivers of the first order are the headwaters (aka outermost...
-
In 2008, a lawyer for Mutual Life Insurance e-mailed Dr. Miles regarding the settlement of a lawsuit that he had filed against the insurance company. The e-mail that the attorney sent contained...
-
Plaintiff prose Wilfredo A. Golez (Golez) filed a motion to compel the work attendance records of two former coworkers who are not parties to the instant litigation. Golez states that he requires the...
-
An investor brought suit against an architect after the investor lost $600,000 in a failed project. To develop the project, a real estate empire in Chicago, an LLC, the Burnham Station, was created...
-
A companys balance sheet appears as follows: Required: (a) If 10,000 of the ordinary shares were purchased at par, there being no new issue of shares for the purpose, show the journal entries to...
-
Some years ago M plc had issued 375,000 of 10 per cent debentures 2006/2010 at par. The terms of the issue allow the company the right to repurchase these debentures for cancellation at or below par,...
-
Debentures of 30,000 are issued on 1 January 2003. Redemption is to take place, on equal terms, four years later. The company decides to put aside an equal amount to be invested at 5 per cent which...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App