What is the effectiveness of the performance appraisal is often a topic of debate. Read the Forbes
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
What is the effectiveness of the performance appraisal is often a topic of debate. Read the Forbes article, Eliminating Performance Appraisals Links to an external site. Based on the content of the article,
argue reasons why performance appraisals should not be eliminated.
Transcribed Image Text:
FORBES > LEADERSHIP Eliminating Performance Appraisals Edward E. Lawler III Former Contributor I am all about sustainable organizational effectiveness. Mar 25, 2014, 02:46pm EDT Should organizations stop doing performance appraisals? The argument in favor of eliminating them is that they frequently do more damage than good. Among the damage that they are said to do, the least troublesome is wasting time, and the most troublesome is the alienation of employees and creating conflicts between them and their supervisors. There is no doubt that in many organizations performance appraisals are poorly done, and that they create a multitude of problems. However, it is important to point out that they exist because of the need to motivate, direct, and improve the performance of individuals and organizations. Those who advocate eliminating performance appraisals don't disagree with these needs, but they point out that managers can and do this anyway, and that therefore performance appraisals are a redundant bureaucratic troublesome activity. It is hard to argue with the point that "good managers" do what a good performance appraisal is supposed to do. The fact that they can and do it supports the argument that appraisals can be eliminated, or at least, radically simplified. The "problem" is that many managers do not manage in ways that make performance appraisals unnecessary. Despite this, some companies have declared that they are performance appraisal-free organizations. FORBES > LEADERSHIP Eliminating Performance Appraisals Edward E. Lawler III Former Contributor I am all about sustainable organizational effectiveness. Mar 25, 2014, 02:46pm EDT Should organizations stop doing performance appraisals? The argument in favor of eliminating them is that they frequently do more damage than good. Among the damage that they are said to do, the least troublesome is wasting time, and the most troublesome is the alienation of employees and creating conflicts between them and their supervisors. There is no doubt that in many organizations performance appraisals are poorly done, and that they create a multitude of problems. However, it is important to point out that they exist because of the need to motivate, direct, and improve the performance of individuals and organizations. Those who advocate eliminating performance appraisals don't disagree with these needs, but they point out that managers can and do this anyway, and that therefore performance appraisals are a redundant bureaucratic troublesome activity. It is hard to argue with the point that "good managers" do what a good performance appraisal is supposed to do. The fact that they can and do it supports the argument that appraisals can be eliminated, or at least, radically simplified. The "problem" is that many managers do not manage in ways that make performance appraisals unnecessary. Despite this, some companies have declared that they are performance appraisal-free organizations.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
While the article discusses the potential drawbacks of performance appraisals it also highlights several reasons why they should not be eliminated ent... View the full answer
Related Book For
Fundamentals Of Human Resource Management
ISBN: 9781119032748
12th Edition
Authors: David A DeCenzo, Stephen P Robbins, Susan L Verhulst
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these organizational behavior questions
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
importance of workalike balance for women as a leader in healthcare. 1. The purpose of the research; 2. Research question/s; 3. Findings and relevant data; 4. Any recommendations and; 5. The...
-
A Moving to another question will save this response. Question 9 1 L The absent of the logic action Release in the Resource Module means: The operator will rework the entity a. b. C. The operator...
-
Multiple-Concept Example 5 reviews many of the concepts that play roles in this problem. An extreme skier starting from rest, coasts down a mountain slope that makes an angle of 25.08 with the...
-
Recall our discussion of the Swiss franc's currency floor in the box. Also, recall the last chapter's discussion of the liquidity trap. Because Switzerland has been in a liquidity trap all the time...
-
To control fixed asset additions, a company should establish control procedures that require: a. Capitalizing of the cost of fixed asset additions that exceeds a specified dollar amount. b....
-
Condensed balance sheet and income statement data for Clarence Corporation appear below. Additional information:1. The market price of Clarence?s common stock was $4.00, $5.00, and $8.00 for 2011,...
-
Sofia is playing a game with her friend, Kara, where she throws M&M candies toward Kara. Kara then adjusts the height of her mouth up/down in order to catch the M&M in her mouth, but their horizontal...
-
Because computers are cheaper and more abundantly available now than a decade ago, doesnt this mean the supply curve for computers is downward sloping?
-
A firms stock has expected return of 10.25% a beta of 1.25 and its in equilibrium. If it ye risk free rate is 2.09% what is the market risk premium
-
What is the intrinsic value of a stock which last paid a dividend of $2.55 and is expected to grow at 18% over the next 2 years after which it will settle down at a stable rate of 7% per annum? The...
-
What are some alternative ways to obtain a market risk premium for use in a CAPM cost equity calculation? Discuss both the possibility of obtaining estimates from out organizations and also ways...
-
Phillips has funded a retirement investment with $250,000 earning a return of 6.75 percent annually. What is that he can receive in perpetuity? (Round to the nearest dollar.)
-
What constitutes the central piece of guidance that a financial advisor can offer you? how can you party hard when you are in your 20s how can you save for your retirement how can you stop working...
-
At December 31, 2016, Skye Inc. had 500,000 common shares outstanding (no preferred shares issued). On July 1, 2017, an additional 50,000 common shares were issued. Skye also had unexercised call...
-
Reread the discussion leading to the result given in (7). Does the matrix sI - A always have an inverse? Discuss.
-
Mentioning OSHA to employers can result in a variety of reactions, many of which arent very favorable. Organizations often feel that the regulations are costly to follow, require them to implement...
-
Identify ways to make performance evaluations more effective. Select one that you believe is most effective and explain why.
-
Explain which of the advances in management seem most and least important in the evolution of HRM.
-
The reciprocating mass, crank radius, and connecting-rod length of each of the cylinders in a two-cylinder in-line engine are given by \(m, r\), and \(l\), respectively. The crank angles of the two...
-
The force transmitted by an internal combustion engine of mass \(500 \mathrm{~kg}\), when placed directly on a rigid floor, is given by \[F_{t}(t)=(18,000 \cos 300 t+3600 \cos 600 t) \mathrm{N}\]...
-
A shaft, having a stiffness of \(3.75 \mathrm{MN} / \mathrm{m}\), rotates at \(3600 \mathrm{rpm}\). A rotor, having a mass of \(60 \mathrm{~kg}\) and an eccentricity of 2000 microns, is mounted on...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App