what is the statement of problem? what is Frye standard and Daubert standard? what is frye case?
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
what is the statement of problem?
what is Frye standard and Daubert standard?
what is frye case? what is daubert case?
Transcribed Image Text:
Posted on June 03, 2019 by Richard Fechter The Florida Supreme Court issued a per curiam opinion on May 23, 2019, reversing its decision seven months earlier in Delisle v. Crane, (Case No. SC16-2182) concerning Florida Statute Section 90.702 and the admissibility of expert witness testimony in the state. The court made a complete about face, rejecting the less rigorous Frye standard established in Delisle in favor of the strict Daubert standard for expert used by federal courts. According to Justice Poston, the federal court system has followed the Daubert standard for 23 years, which has also been adopted by 36 states, and the "grave constitutional concerns" that led to the rejection of Daubert in the Delisle decision were unfounded. By reversing course and reverting back to the Daubert standard, Florida courts will likely need to address more frequent challenges to expert testimony offered by forensic accountants and valuation analysts. This is not only because Daubert applies to expert opinions relating to new scientific principles (as does Frye), but it also applies to many areas of expert testimony that are not always thought of as being scientific in nature, including testimony involving the calculation of economic damages, business valuation and forensic accounting. Moreover, where Frye (unlike Daubert) allows experts to provide testimony that relies solely on their experience and training, Daubert requires that expert opinions be tested and assessed for reliability, rely on methods that have been subject to peer review and are generally accepted in the scientific community. As a result, testifying experts are now under one evidential standard for admissibility in both Florida courts and in Federal courts in the US (Daubert), which the Supreme Court ruled "will promote fairness and predictability in the legal system as well as help lessen forum shopping." Posted on June 03, 2019 by Richard Fechter The Florida Supreme Court issued a per curiam opinion on May 23, 2019, reversing its decision seven months earlier in Delisle v. Crane, (Case No. SC16-2182) concerning Florida Statute Section 90.702 and the admissibility of expert witness testimony in the state. The court made a complete about face, rejecting the less rigorous Frye standard established in Delisle in favor of the strict Daubert standard for expert used by federal courts. According to Justice Poston, the federal court system has followed the Daubert standard for 23 years, which has also been adopted by 36 states, and the "grave constitutional concerns" that led to the rejection of Daubert in the Delisle decision were unfounded. By reversing course and reverting back to the Daubert standard, Florida courts will likely need to address more frequent challenges to expert testimony offered by forensic accountants and valuation analysts. This is not only because Daubert applies to expert opinions relating to new scientific principles (as does Frye), but it also applies to many areas of expert testimony that are not always thought of as being scientific in nature, including testimony involving the calculation of economic damages, business valuation and forensic accounting. Moreover, where Frye (unlike Daubert) allows experts to provide testimony that relies solely on their experience and training, Daubert requires that expert opinions be tested and assessed for reliability, rely on methods that have been subject to peer review and are generally accepted in the scientific community. As a result, testifying experts are now under one evidential standard for admissibility in both Florida courts and in Federal courts in the US (Daubert), which the Supreme Court ruled "will promote fairness and predictability in the legal system as well as help lessen forum shopping."
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Statement of Problem It is a section of the research proposal by which a brief description of the major concern of the study problem is presented It i... View the full answer
Related Book For
Accounting
ISBN: 978-1337899451
27th edition
Authors: Carl S. Warren, James M. Reeve, Jonathan Duchac
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
What standards or tests has the Supreme Court used to evaluate governmental attempts to regulate abortion?
-
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in May 2005 that people can buy wine directly from out-of-state vineyards. The Court held that state laws requiring people to buy directly from wine retailers within the...
-
On 1 July 2015, Richard Ltd acquired all the issued shares of Elizabeth Ltd. The following information relates to the inter entity transactions that have occurred between Richard and Elizabeth to...
-
Which power plant has high load factor?
-
Lunar eclipses are always eclipses of a full Moon. That is, the Moon is always seen full just before and after Earth's shadow passes over it. Why is this? Why can we never have a lunar eclipse when...
-
You are earning money by painting a shed. You plan to paint two sides of the shed today. Each of the two sides has the dimensions shown at the right. You can paint 200 square feet per hour, and you...
-
Cooling tower in a steam power plant is a device for (a) condensing steam into water (b) cooling the exhaust gases coming out the boiler (c) reducing the temperature of superheated steam (d) reducing...
-
Beer sales at the Shapiro One-Stop Store are analyzed using temperature and number of people (age 21 or over) on the street as independent variables. A random sample of 20 days is selected, and the...
-
Pharma Company produces various medicines in capsule form. At the beginning of the month of February, it had 9 , 0 0 0 units that were 5 0 % complete. ese were assigned costs of $ 7 0 , 0 0 0 ....
-
Devon Bishop, age 45, is single. He lives at 1507 Rose Lane, Albuquerque, NM 87131. His Social Security number is 111-11-1117. Devon does not want $3 to go to the Presidential Election Campaign Fund....
-
Which type of strategy is being used if a company offers a product at a lower cost than its competitors? Multiple choice question. differentiation strategy focused differentiation strategy...
-
For transaction three, does the amount in the payroll register report match the balance in the payroll account before the bank transfer?
-
Why might venture capitalists choose to invest in a start-up's convertible preferred stock instead of in: a) debt; b) non-convertible preferred stock; or c) common stock (equity)? Explain your...
-
The window shown here would be used in QuickBooks Online to perform maintenance on what type of record?
-
What transaction-related objective is described by ensuring that recorded purchase transactions represent inventories acquired during the period?
-
You have replaced the former audit partner Brett of the auditing firm Moira & Stella (M&S). You find the following independent engagement is potentially in breach of the independence requirements of...
-
What must all enrollees in TRICARE for Life do? Multiple Choice be eligible for Medicare Part A only be eligible for Medicare Part B only have Part A premiums deducted from their Social Security...
-
During the year land was revalued and the surplus reported as Revaluation surplus; and an asset costing 80,000, written down to 38,000, was sold for 40,000. Identify the cost of any non-current...
-
Based on the following data, determine the cost of merchandise sold for November: Increase in estimated returns inventory ................................ $ 14,500 Merchandise inventory, November 1...
-
On June 1, 2019, Herbal Co. received $18,900 for the rent of land for 12 months. Journalize the adjusting entry (include an explanation) required for unearned rent on December 31, 2019.
-
Assume that the entry closing total revenues of $3,190,000 and total expenses of $2,350,000 has been made for the year. At the end of the fiscal year, Teresa Schafer, Capital has a credit balance of...
-
International Distribution Company Pvt. Ltd. manufactures an assortment of high-performance engines for small boats. The average selling price for various units is \($575\). The associated variable...
-
A group of retired engineering professors from Singapore Polytechnic has decided to form a small manufacturing firm that will produce a full line of automation equipment. The investors have proposed...
-
Christian Dior S.A. is a successful family business with its famous fashion and perfume brands. Its latest effort in growing the business involves opening a series of international outlets to...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App