You want to compare Caterpillars operations for fiscal 2007 to those of an international competitor, CNH Global,
Question:
You want to compare Caterpillars operations for fiscal 2007 to those of an international competitor, CNH Global, headquartered in the Netherlands. (CNH Global financial statements follow the Caterpillar financial statements at the end of the case.) In particular you want to compare a number of inventory-related metrics. However, the two companies do not use the same inventory costing methods: Caterpillar uses LIFO for a large portion of its inventory whereas CNH Global uses FIFO to cost all of its inventory. International financial reporting standards (IFRS) do not permit companies to use the LIFO method. To compare the two companies, you first must restate Caterpillars relevant balance sheet and income statement numbers from LIFO to FIFO. To do this, we assume that Caterpillar had instead always used the FIFO method of inventory costing. Use the table below to aggregate the data you need to covert LIFO to FIFO for Caterpillar. For these calculations, assume that the marginal tax rate for Caterpillar is 35%
Caterpillar, Inc. | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 |
Sales | 41,962 | 38,869 | 34,006 |
LIFO Cost of gods sold (COGS) | 32,626 | 29,549 | 26,558 |
LIFO Net Income | 3,541 | 3,537 | 2,854 |
LIFO Inventory from balance sheet | 7,204 | 6,351 | 5,224 |
LIFO Reserve from financial statement notes | 2,617? | 2,403? | 2,345? |
Total Assets from the balance sheet | 56,132 | 51,449 | 47,553 |
Calculations to convert LIFO to FIFO | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 |
FIFO Inventory = LIFO Inventory + LIFO Reserve | |||
FIFO Assets = LIFO Assets + LIFO Reserve | |||
Increase in LIFO Reserve during the year | |||
FIFO COGS = LIFO COGS Increase in LIFO Reserve | |||
After-tax effect of LIFO = (1- Marginal tax rate) * Increase in LIFO Reserve | |||
FIFO Net Income = LIFO Net income + After-tax effect of LIFO method |
Complete the table below using information from the financial statements and from the table you completed above. Comment on the results comparing CNH Global with Caterpillars As Reported and As if FIFO income statement and balance sheet information.
Year End December 31, 2007 | Caterpillar | CNH Global | |
As Reported | As if FIFO | As Reported | |
Common-size Cost of goods sold1 | |||
Net Income | |||
Growth in Net Income | |||
Common-size Net Income | |||
Total assets | |||
Inventory | |||
Common-size Inventory2 |
ISE International Business Competing In The Global Marketplace
ISBN: 9781260575866
13th International Edition
Authors: Charles Hill