# Question: The ending of the game between the Indianapolis Colts and

The ending of the game between the Indianapolis Colts and the New England Patriots (NFL teams) in Fall 2009 was quite controversial. With about two minutes left in the game, the Patriots were ahead 34 to 28 and had the ball on their own 28-yard line with fourth down and two yards to go. Their coach, Bill Belichick, decided to go for the first down rather than punt, contrary to conventional wisdom. They didn’t make the first down, so that possession went to the Colts, who then scored a touchdown to win by a point. Belichick was harshly criticized by most of the media, but was his unorthodox decision really a bad one?

a. Use a decision tree to analyze the problem. You can make some simplifying decisions:

(1) The game would essentially be over if the Patriots made a first down, and

(2) At most one score would occur after a punt or a failed first down attempt.

b. Show that the Patriots should go for the first down if p > 1 - q/r. Here, p is the probability the

Patriots make the first down, q is the probability the Colts score a touchdown after a punt, and r is the probability the Colts scores a touchdown after the Patriots fail to make a first down. What are your best guesses for these three probabilities? Based on them, was Belichick’s decision a good one?

a. Use a decision tree to analyze the problem. You can make some simplifying decisions:

(1) The game would essentially be over if the Patriots made a first down, and

(2) At most one score would occur after a punt or a failed first down attempt.

b. Show that the Patriots should go for the first down if p > 1 - q/r. Here, p is the probability the

Patriots make the first down, q is the probability the Colts score a touchdown after a punt, and r is the probability the Colts scores a touchdown after the Patriots fail to make a first down. What are your best guesses for these three probabilities? Based on them, was Belichick’s decision a good one?

## Answer to relevant Questions

Suppose you believe that the price of a particular stock goes up each day with probability p and goes down with probability 1 - p. You also believe the daily price changes are independent of one another. However, you are not ...This problem illustrates an interesting variation of simple random sampling.a. Open a blank spreadsheet and use the RAND() function to create a column of 1000 random numbers. Don’t freeze them. This is actually a simple ...Create a simulation similar to the one in the Wheel of Fortune Similation.xlsx file. However, suppose that the outcome of each spin is no longer uniformly distributed between $0 and $1000. Instead, it is the number of 7s you ...The file P08_05.xlsx contains salary data on all NFL players in each of the years 2002 to 2009. Because this file contains all players for each of these years, you can calculate the population mean for each year if ...The same data as in the previous problem are stored in a different format in the last two sheets of the P08_15.xlsx file.a. Use StatTools to find a 95% confidence interval for the proportion who favor Crest from the data in ...Post your question