The Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) waives the federal government's sovereign immunity concerning claims arising out of torts committed by federal employees. This waiver of sovereign immunity allows tort claims based on wrongful actions by federal employees, except when an exception to the waiver applies (in which event a tort claim cannot be brought or pursued against the government). One of the exceptions to the sovereign immunity waiver is set forth in FTCA §2680(b). This exception is for "loss, miscarriage, or negligent transmission of letters or postal matter." Barbara Dolan was injured when she tripped and fell over packages and letters that a U.S. Postal Service (USPS) mail carrier left on the porch of her home. Dolan sued the USPS under the FTCA on the theory that the USPS mail carrier had been negligent- in other words, had failed to use reasonable care-in leaving the items of mail on the porch. The USPS argued that the case should be dismissed because it fell within §2680(b)'s reference to claims arising out of "negligent transmission of letters or postal matter." Agreeing with this argument, the district court dismissed the case. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed. Dolan appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, arguing that the lower courts had erroneously interpreted §2680(b). Were the lower courts correct in their interpretation of § 2680(b)? Was Dolan's claim barred by the "negligent transmission of letters or postal matter" language?
Answer to relevant QuestionsMany states and localities used to have so-called Sunday Closing laws-statutes or ordinances forbidding certain business from being conducted on Sunday.A few may still have such laws. Often, these laws have not been obeyed ...Alabama resident Lynda Butler sued Beer Across America, an Illinois firm, for having sold her minor son 12 bottles of beer. The son ordered the beer from the defendant's website while his parents were on vacation. Butler ...Nevada is alone among the states in making prostitution legal. Under Nevada law, brothels may be operated in certain counties in the state. In other counties in the state, they are unlawful. Where brothels may lawfully be ...While it was preparing a comprehensive land use plan in the area, the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency (TRPA) imposed two moratoria on development of property in the Lake Tahoe Basin. The moratoria together lasted 32 months. A ...You are hired as a corporate accountant for Ryco Industries, Inc., a public company with shares traded on the New York Stock Exchange. The company has enjoyed consistently higher earnings each quarter, meeting or exceeding ...
Post your question