The McCollams entered into a contract to purchase Cahill's property on the outskirts of Mobridge, South Dakota. South Dakota law requires sellers of residential real estate to fill out a property conditions form prior to sale. The disclosure form is set forth by statute and contains over 90 questions concerning the lot or title, structural information, system/utilities information, hazardous conditions, and miscellaneous information. One question on the form that Cahill filled out was, "Are there any other problems that have not been disclosed above?" The McCollams contend that Cahill was required to disclose that there had been snakes in the house and around the property and they sued him for rescission based on fraud. They testified that they had found two bull snakes in the house within the first weeks after moving in. They also testified to several other bull snakes found in the garage and around the house during the following months. They and several other witnesses testified to seeing snakes on the property when Cahill lived there. Cahill presented testimony from multiple witnesses that few, if any, snakes were seen on the property while Cahill owned it. After receiving evidence from both parties, the court determined that during the 30 plus years that Cahill owned the property, Cahill only discovered one snake in the house. The court also determined that McCollams only saw two snakes in the house and that some snakes were seen in the yard in 2006. Did Cahill have the duty to disclose the presence of the snakes?
Answer to relevant QuestionsWilliams was 18 years old when she was admitted to Baptist Health Systems for treatment of serious health conditions. The age of majority for contracting in Williams's state was 19. Williams was hospitalized for two days, ...David Denison is a developmentally disabled young man who has been under the legal guardianship of his parents since 1999, when he turned 18. In October 2002, David was living in his own apartment, but his parents strictly ...McCune went to the Myrtle Beach Indoor Shooting Range to participate in a paintball game. Before being allowed to participate, McCune signed and dated a waiver that purported to release the Range from liability for all known ...The Chavezes allege that in May of 1998, they entered into a verbal agreement with Bravo to purchase a home located in Alamo, Texas, for $65,000, comprising a $2,000 down payment and monthly installments of $500. The ...Francis brought suit against Piper and his law firm, alleging Piper committed legal malpractice when he drafted a series of wills for Heine, Francis's brother. Heine, who had never married, had no children; Francis was his ...
Post your question