Suppose that Amtrak is choosing whether or not to build a new high-speed railroad on the...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Suppose that Amtrak is choosing whether or not to build a new high-speed railroad on the East Coast. Building the railroad will involve an initial up-front sunk cost k. To keep the accounting simple assume that the railway, if built, will run for exactly one year, and that it will generate (new) revenues of $130,000,000. Operating the railroad for that year would cost $10,000,000 in fuel, plus some labor costs. The labor costs depend on the wage. The railroad would need to employ 1000 workers all of whom would be unionized. The current going wage for union rail labor on the East Coast is $50,000. That is, without the new railroad, these workers would earn $50,000. (a) Assuming that the labor can be hired at this going wage, for what values of k should Amtrak build the new railroad? (Assume that Amtrak aims to maximize profits without discounting). (b) Suppose that, if the railroad is built, after it is built the rail union can make a 'take it or leave it' wage demand w to Amtrak to apply just for labor on the new line. The railroad's only choice is to accept to pay the wage demand, w, or close the new line down. What demand will the union make? Given this, if you were Amtrak, for what values of k would you build the new line? Why is your answer different from that in part (a)? (c) Now suppose that the wage demand made after the railroad is built is not a 'take it or leave it' demand but rather part of negotiation. Suppose that, fearing strikes in the transport sector, the government has instituted compulsory arbitration in wage disputes. The arbitrator always follows a two-step approach. First, she disqualifies any wage offers lower than the current going wage (that is, such that employees would rather walk away than accept the offer), and also any wage demand that would cause the employer to shut down (that is, such that the employee would rather walk away than accept the demand). Provided the offers and demands survive this test, she then splits the difference. What wage demands and wage offers will be presented to the arbitrator after the railroad is built. Given this, if you were Amtrak, for what values of k would you build the new line? Why is your answer different from that in parts (a) and (b)? (d) Issues like this are the 'hold-up' problems we discussed in class. One way to avoid the problem here (under-investment) is to give all the ex post bargaining power to the would-be ex ante investor. (Here this is the employer but in other settings it might be an employee who must decide how much to invest in skills that are specific to a given firm.) Briefly list some other ways we see people try to get around hold-up problems. Suppose that Amtrak is choosing whether or not to build a new high-speed railroad on the East Coast. Building the railroad will involve an initial up-front sunk cost k. To keep the accounting simple assume that the railway, if built, will run for exactly one year, and that it will generate (new) revenues of $130,000,000. Operating the railroad for that year would cost $10,000,000 in fuel, plus some labor costs. The labor costs depend on the wage. The railroad would need to employ 1000 workers all of whom would be unionized. The current going wage for union rail labor on the East Coast is $50,000. That is, without the new railroad, these workers would earn $50,000. (a) Assuming that the labor can be hired at this going wage, for what values of k should Amtrak build the new railroad? (Assume that Amtrak aims to maximize profits without discounting). (b) Suppose that, if the railroad is built, after it is built the rail union can make a 'take it or leave it' wage demand w to Amtrak to apply just for labor on the new line. The railroad's only choice is to accept to pay the wage demand, w, or close the new line down. What demand will the union make? Given this, if you were Amtrak, for what values of k would you build the new line? Why is your answer different from that in part (a)? (c) Now suppose that the wage demand made after the railroad is built is not a 'take it or leave it' demand but rather part of negotiation. Suppose that, fearing strikes in the transport sector, the government has instituted compulsory arbitration in wage disputes. The arbitrator always follows a two-step approach. First, she disqualifies any wage offers lower than the current going wage (that is, such that employees would rather walk away than accept the offer), and also any wage demand that would cause the employer to shut down (that is, such that the employee would rather walk away than accept the demand). Provided the offers and demands survive this test, she then splits the difference. What wage demands and wage offers will be presented to the arbitrator after the railroad is built. Given this, if you were Amtrak, for what values of k would you build the new line? Why is your answer different from that in parts (a) and (b)? (d) Issues like this are the 'hold-up' problems we discussed in class. One way to avoid the problem here (under-investment) is to give all the ex post bargaining power to the would-be ex ante investor. (Here this is the employer but in other settings it might be an employee who must decide how much to invest in skills that are specific to a given firm.) Briefly list some other ways we see people try to get around hold-up problems.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
a Very briefly define what is meant by sunk cost and what is meant by the sunk cost fallacy Go look it up if you do not know Ans When undertaking a project we say costs are sunk when some of the actio... View the full answer
Related Book For
Corporate Finance
ISBN: 978-0077861759
10th edition
Authors: Stephen Ross, Randolph Westerfield, Jeffrey Jaffe
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
A man wants to determine whether or not to invest $1000 in a friend's speculative venture. He will do so if he thinks he can get his money back in one year. He believes the probabilities of the...
-
An athletic team wants to build a new sports arena in the middle of the downtown area. The team has bought enough land for the stadium, but needs more land to build an adjacent parking lot. The team...
-
Suppose your company needs $20 million to build a new assembly line. Your target debtequity ratio is .75. The flotation cost for new equity is 7 percent, but the flotation cost for debt is only 3...
-
Calculate the heat required to raise 50 kg of solid sodium carbonate (Na2CO3) from 10C to 50C at 1atm using (a) The true heat capacity of Na2CO3, which is 1.14 kJ / (kg C). (b) A heat capacity...
-
Kalton and Anderson (1986) consider disproportional stratified random sampling for estimating the mean of a characteristic yi in a rare population. Let ri = 1 if person i is in the rare population...
-
Briefly discuss how a systems analyst can manage each of the six cost elements of maintenance described.
-
A plant asset purchased by Krest Inc. for \(\$ 100,000\) late in 2018 is to be depreciated as follows. In 2020 , taxable income was \(\$ 450,000\) and the tax rate is \(25 \%\). Future enacted tax...
-
Boulanger Savings and Loan is proud of its long tra-dition in Winter Park, Florida. Begun by Michelle Boulanger 22 years after World War II, the S& L has bucked the trend of financial and liquidity...
-
What is the most likely value of the firm and why? Comment on the goodwill & intangibles; significance? Comment on the treasury stock and effect; significance? Net worth method: 52,883-(45175+2390...
-
Assume the standard deviation of the return on every stock is 40%, and the correlation coefficient between any two stocks is 0.2. The market is perfect and short-selling is not restricted. As for...
-
On January 1, 2024, Rick's Pawn Shop leased a truck from Corey Motors for a six-year period with an option to extend the lease for three years. Rick's had no significant economic incentive as of the...
-
Valdez Company is considering eliminating its kitchen division, which reported an operating loss of $54,000 for the past year as shown below. Segment Income (Loss) Sales Variable costs Contribution...
-
Please describe the workflow below, step by step, and explain what it means. Purchasing Process Is it an Independent Contractor? YES IC's Agreement fod out or on File Cash Purchase Process HI...
-
In its income statement for the year ended December 31, 2022, Shamrock Inc. reported the following condensed data. Operating expenses $812,000 Interest revenue $ 36,960 Cost of goods sold 1,406,720...
-
Peter is a dual citizen of US and Canada residing in Canada. He is single. In 2 0 1 9 he received $ 2 0 K US Social Security and $ 4 0 K distribution from registered retirement plan in Canada. What...
-
Hamilton Boats issued 306,000 shares of its no-par common stock to Sudoku Motors in exchange for 1,800 four-stroke outboard motors that normally sell in quantity for $3,400 each. By what amount...
-
Marie encounters the following when planning the audit of Cars 'R Us Ltd. (CRU), a large auto dealership. Marie is a senior auditor working at Kingsley & Wallace, CPA's. Kingsley & Wallace hav...
-
Troy is a qualified radiologist who operates a successful radiology practice from purpose- built rooms attached to his house. Troy works in the practice three days a week, and the other two days he...
-
A put option that expires in six months with an exercise price of $65 sells for $4.89. The stock is currently priced at $61, and the risk-free rate is 3.6 percent per year, compounded continuously....
-
Suppose the Japanese yen exchange rate is 85 = $1, and the British pound exchange rate is 1 = $1.53. a. What is the cross-rate in terms of yen per pound? b. Suppose the cross-rate is 131.4 = 1. Is...
-
Indicate whether you think the following claims regarding takeovers are true or false. In each case, provide a brief explanation for your answer. a. By merging competitors, takeovers have created...
-
List three examples of money-related opportunity costs you have faced in the last two months. Write a sentence explaining what decision you made for each one and why.
-
To become a member of an Internet DVD library, Maritza has to put down a deposit of \($100,\) using her credit card. When and if Maritza chooses to discontinue her membership, the library will refund...
-
If your personal financial statements indicate that you have a deficit, what might you do to change your financial situation?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App