John Calc Gossling is one of Canada's foremost real estate investment analysts. He works for the firm of Bouchard Wiener
John "Calc" Gossling is one of Canada's foremost real estate investment analysts. He works for the firm of Bouchard Wiener Securities Inc. (BWS). His job is to do research and make recommendations on the stock of publicly traded companies, independent of any interest his employer may have in the companies. The research gets published and is used by investors in making their investment decisions. He is noted for his superb number-crunching ability, scathing comments, and accurate analysis. In late 1989, he correctly predicted the end of the real estate bubble, which occurred about two years later. His writing style is in marked contrast to the traditional dry prose of most investment analysts.
Major Developments Corporation (Major) is a publicly traded company operating primarily in the real estate sector. Major has a March 31 year end and in 2013 reported revenues of $704 million and after-tax income of $118 million.
The company buys and sells commercial real estate properties and manufactures commercial elevator components, its original business before it got into real estate. Major survived the recession of the 1990s, and during that time purchased a number of commercial "jewels" at bargain prices. In 2012, Major ventured overseas, acquiring properties in three Asian countries.
Major's share price climbed steadily from 2008 until July 11, 2013. On that date, BWS released a stunning research report by Gossling on Major (see the extracts in Exhibit C6-2(a)). The report caused uproar, as it claimed that many of Major's accounting policies in fiscal 2013 were misleading and therefore not in accordance with Canadian generally accepted accounting principles. It further claimed that the company was overvalued and had poor prospects because of its real estate portfolio mix.
The stock had been trading in the $15-16 range but immediately dropped to around $9. BWS profited from the decline in the stock price because it held a significant short position in Major's stock. Within four days, lawyers working for Major launched a legal action against BWS, claiming damages plus a full retraction of all statements made and published in a national newspaper.
BWS's legal counsel is now examining various courses of action. To help prepare for the case, counsel has hired Rohailla & Mortar, Chartered Accountants, to provide a report on the validity of the positions of each of the parties on the disagreements over accounting policies as well as any other relevant advice. You, CA, work for Rohailla & Mortar.
You have obtained a copy of Major's 2013 annual report (see extracts in Exhibit C6-2(b)). Major's lawyers have provided the information in Exhibit C6-2(c).
Prepare a draft report to legal counsel for the partner to review.
EXTRACTS FROM JOHN GOSSLING€™S RESEARCH REPORT
.I have done a detailed review of Major's 2013 annual report. I approached management of the company with a detailed list of further questions, but management didn't respond in the four days I gave them.
.It is my contention that in 2013, Major clearly violated International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), as set out by the International Accounting Standards Board, on a number of issues. I am saying that the accounting is wrong, not just aggressive.
.Major's accounting for its real estate loans really takes the cake for non-compliance. The company consolidates the assets and results of two corporations to whom it has granted loans when it does not own any shares in either of the companies.
.I don't like the accounting in Major's non-real estate business. There is no question it is misleading. Starting in 2013, the company specifically states in the financial statement notes that revenue (and profit I might add) is recognized on product that is still sitting in the company's warehouse!
.How can Rely Holdings, a company that lost $750,000, in which Major had acquired an additional 25% interest for $5 million, be valued at over $29 million? The valuation of Rely Holdings makes no sense.
.How can a company capitalize costs incurred for properties that were never acquired? Clearly these costs cannot be considered assets, and it is misleading to do so.
.It is absurd that Major continues to recognize the revenue from properties in certain economically unstable Asian countries. It is unlikely that the money will be collected. Major should write off these buildings immediately instead of recognizing revenue from them.
.Major has not followed IFRS in its accounting for the dividend in kind declared during the year. Thirteen days after the dividend was declared, the only tenant in the only property owned by NC Tower Inc. went bankrupt (reference The Financial Journal, February 26, 2013, p. 13), so the value attributed cannot be accepted. Furthermore, the dividend has still not been paid, as the regulators are still looking into it.
Recommendation on Major Developments Corp.
Price earnings multiplier based on last fiscal year: 12.7
Overall rating on the stock: underperform
EXTRACTS FROM MAJOR DEVELOPMENTS CORPORATION€™S 2013 ANNUAL REPORT
Note 1: Accounting policies
The company incurs significant costs in investigating new properties for purchase. Costs incurred in investigating any and all properties, whether or not these properties are ultimately purchased by the company, are capitalized as part of the cost of properties actually acquired. These costs are amortized over the useful lives of the properties acquired.
Economic problems in certain Asian countries where the company owns properties have made collection of rental revenues from these properties difficult at this time. The company expects that, once the difficulties in these countries have been resolved, amounts owed will be collected in full. It is the company's policy to accrue the revenue from these properties.
Revenue on product sales is recognized when goods are shipped to the customer. In the case of "bill and hold" sales, revenue is recognized when the goods are placed in the company's designated storage area.
The consolidated financial statements include the accounts of Major and its majority owned subsidiaries and, commencing prospectively in fiscal 2013, the accounts of companies in which Major has no common share ownership but to which it has advanced loans that are currently in default. The equity method is used for investments in which there is significant influence, considered to be voting ownership of 20% to 50%.
In 2013, Major purchased an additional 25% interest in Rely Holdings Inc. for $5 million. Major now owns 48% of Rely Holdings Inc. Major accounts for its investment on an equity basis. In 2013 Major recorded a loss of $750,000 from Rely Holdings Inc.
Note 24: Dividend in kind
On February 10, 2013, the Board of Directors of Major declared a $0.20 dividend in kind on each common share, consisting of five common shares of NC Tower Inc. The NC Tower Inc. shares had an appraised value of $0.04 each and a carrying value of $0.018 per share. The stock exchange on which Major is listed has raised certain objections to the transaction, and the matter is currently being investigated. Management expects approval for the transaction to be granted in the near future. During the year, Major reported a gain on disposal of $11 million and a charge to retained earnings of $20 million to account for the declaration of the dividend.
EXTRACTS FROM INFORMATION PROVIDED BY MAJOR€™S LAWYERS
1. Major's auditor has always provided an unqualified report on the audited financial statements of Major, including the 2013 financial statements. The unqualified opinions prove conclusively that the statements were in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards.
2. Major has a legal opinion that the two loans are in default (Item A), and a third-party accounting opinion (Item B) that this default permits consolidation of those companies.
".In my opinion, loan 323 to Skyscraper Inc., and loan 324 to Wenon Corporation are in default as of February 1, 2012, under the aforesaid terms of default of the respective loan agreements, dated the 12th day of August, 2010. The lender has the right under law and contract to repossess said aforementioned properties, for the purposes of realization on the loans, subject to restrictions of right under clause 43.(b)." Matthew Krebs, Q.C.
"Based on the facts set out in the attached document, we concur that it is acceptable under International Financial Reporting Standards for Major to consolidate Skyscraper Inc., and Wenon Corporation." Jesse & Mitchell, Chartered Accountants.
3. "Bill and hold" refers to a practice whereby a customer purchases goods but the seller retains physical possession until the customer requests shipment. Delivery is delayed at the purchaser's request, but the purchaser accepts both title to the goods and the related billing.
Financial statements are the standardized formats to present the financial information related to a business or an organization for its users. Financial statements contain the historical information as well as current period’s financial... Corporation
A Corporation is a legal form of business that is separate from its owner. In other words, a corporation is a business or organization formed by a group of people, and its right and liabilities separate from those of the individuals involved. It may... Dividend
A dividend is a distribution of a portion of company’s earnings, decided and managed by the company’s board of directors, and paid to the shareholders. Dividends are given on the shares. It is a token reward paid to the shareholders for their... Portfolio
A portfolio is a grouping of financial assets such as stocks, bonds, commodities, currencies and cash equivalents, as well as their fund counterparts, including mutual, exchange-traded and closed funds. A portfolio can also consist of non-publicly...
This problem has been solved!
Step by Step Answer: