The Spanish Navy Pays Nearly $3 Billion for a Submarine That Will Sink Like a Stone...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
The Spanish Navy Pays Nearly $3 Billion for a Submarine That Will Sink Like a Stone In 2003, shipbuilders at Navantia, Spain's state- owner shipyard, welcomed a contract from their navy to construct four state-of-the-art submarines. The S-80 class was going to be an engineering mar- vel, filled with the latest and most cutting-edge technology, including a diesel-electric propulsion system that would be 20% lighter than other ships, while delivering 50% more power. As the list of up- grades and new technical gadgetry grew, the deliv- ery date for the Isaac Peral-the lead ship in the S-80 class-continued to ship further behind schedule. Nevertheless, it wasn't the continuous upgrading and addition of new equipment that finally slammed the brakes on the project; it was the startling warning from Navantia's engineers that the Isaac Peral was not seaworthy. The submarine, named in honor of the Spanish man credited by some as the inventor of the underwater vessel, was 75-100 tons overweight, an excess that could make it difficult or impossible for the submarine to surface after submerging. As a re- sult, the Spanish navy was faced with the challenge of fixing a submarine that ran the risk of disaster whenever it decided to submerge! Navantia admitted the existence of "devia- tions related to the balance of weight" in the vessel and estimated it would take up to two years more to correct the problem, pushing the new delivery date to late 2018. The firm's engineers are trying to determine their best options at this point. It appears that two choices are most likely: Find a way to trim the design of the overall ship, which would be very difficult at this stage in construction, or lengthen the hull of the already 233-foot submarine to com- pensate for the extra weight. The problem with this option is that designers have estimated that for every meter the hull is lengthened, it will end up costing nearly 10 million additional euros (about $14 million dollars). Unfortunately for the Spaniards, indepen- dent agencies report that they have already sunk the equivalent of $680 million into the Isaac Peral, and a total of $3 billion into the entire quartet of S-80 class submarines. reactor is also underperforming. A Strategic Studies Group spokesperson said that the AlIP system has been designed to enable the submarine to operate underway for 28 days but is currently able to man- age only one week. The Group's memo suggests, "The buoyancy problem alone could cost up to half a billion euros to cover redesign and extra construc- tion, without considering the propulsion problem." The submarine setback couldn't have come at a worse time for Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy, who was already caught up in a corruption scan- dal and saw his approval rating hit a record low in 2013. Because of the poor shape of Spain's economy, Rajoy's austerity cuts trimmed the Spanish military budget by 30 percent in 2012, leaving much less room for added ballast. With reports that the S-80 program will be delayed an estimated two years and another general election looming in 2015, Rajoy likely will not see the submarines through to suc- cessful launch. How did such an expensive project get funded at a time when the Spanish military's entire special weap- ons program received a 98% cut? Sheer pride seems to have been a factor: Spain hoped the S-80 class would be a new homegrown breakthrough achieved with- out foreign help. Now that Navantia has entered into a $15 million contract with the Electric Boat Division of America's General Dynamics to help with the rede- sign, that dream seems dead in the water.17 Questions 1. Google "Spain's S-80 class submarine" and read some of the articles posted. In your opinion, how does technical risk cause problems with major defense projects? 2. Why do you think it is common for defense con- tractors to add new features and modifications to current programs? In other words, why do defense agencies contract for one project, only to see it often evolve into something new by the time it is launched? 3. If you were an advisor brought in by the Spanish government, what advice would you offer them in managing their defense projects? The buoyancy problem is not the only difficulty facing the program; an analyst said that that sub- marine's air-independent propulsion (AIP) system The Spanish Navy Pays Nearly $3 Billion for a Submarine That Will Sink Like a Stone In 2003, shipbuilders at Navantia, Spain's state- owner shipyard, welcomed a contract from their navy to construct four state-of-the-art submarines. The S-80 class was going to be an engineering mar- vel, filled with the latest and most cutting-edge technology, including a diesel-electric propulsion system that would be 20% lighter than other ships, while delivering 50% more power. As the list of up- grades and new technical gadgetry grew, the deliv- ery date for the Isaac Peral-the lead ship in the S-80 class-continued to ship further behind schedule. Nevertheless, it wasn't the continuous upgrading and addition of new equipment that finally slammed the brakes on the project; it was the startling warning from Navantia's engineers that the Isaac Peral was not seaworthy. The submarine, named in honor of the Spanish man credited by some as the inventor of the underwater vessel, was 75-100 tons overweight, an excess that could make it difficult or impossible for the submarine to surface after submerging. As a re- sult, the Spanish navy was faced with the challenge of fixing a submarine that ran the risk of disaster whenever it decided to submerge! Navantia admitted the existence of "devia- tions related to the balance of weight" in the vessel and estimated it would take up to two years more to correct the problem, pushing the new delivery date to late 2018. The firm's engineers are trying to determine their best options at this point. It appears that two choices are most likely: Find a way to trim the design of the overall ship, which would be very difficult at this stage in construction, or lengthen the hull of the already 233-foot submarine to com- pensate for the extra weight. The problem with this option is that designers have estimated that for every meter the hull is lengthened, it will end up costing nearly 10 million additional euros (about $14 million dollars). Unfortunately for the Spaniards, indepen- dent agencies report that they have already sunk the equivalent of $680 million into the Isaac Peral, and a total of $3 billion into the entire quartet of S-80 class submarines. reactor is also underperforming. A Strategic Studies Group spokesperson said that the AlIP system has been designed to enable the submarine to operate underway for 28 days but is currently able to man- age only one week. The Group's memo suggests, "The buoyancy problem alone could cost up to half a billion euros to cover redesign and extra construc- tion, without considering the propulsion problem." The submarine setback couldn't have come at a worse time for Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy, who was already caught up in a corruption scan- dal and saw his approval rating hit a record low in 2013. Because of the poor shape of Spain's economy, Rajoy's austerity cuts trimmed the Spanish military budget by 30 percent in 2012, leaving much less room for added ballast. With reports that the S-80 program will be delayed an estimated two years and another general election looming in 2015, Rajoy likely will not see the submarines through to suc- cessful launch. How did such an expensive project get funded at a time when the Spanish military's entire special weap- ons program received a 98% cut? Sheer pride seems to have been a factor: Spain hoped the S-80 class would be a new homegrown breakthrough achieved with- out foreign help. Now that Navantia has entered into a $15 million contract with the Electric Boat Division of America's General Dynamics to help with the rede- sign, that dream seems dead in the water.17 Questions 1. Google "Spain's S-80 class submarine" and read some of the articles posted. In your opinion, how does technical risk cause problems with major defense projects? 2. Why do you think it is common for defense con- tractors to add new features and modifications to current programs? In other words, why do defense agencies contract for one project, only to see it often evolve into something new by the time it is launched? 3. If you were an advisor brought in by the Spanish government, what advice would you offer them in managing their defense projects? The buoyancy problem is not the only difficulty facing the program; an analyst said that that sub- marine's air-independent propulsion (AIP) system
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 The technical risks associated with major defense projects are that the defense projects are always evolved with a theoretical assumption which when ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Fundamentals of Physics
ISBN: 978-0471758013
8th Extended edition
Authors: Jearl Walker, Halliday Resnick
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these general management questions
-
A vessel is filled with gas at some equilibrium pressure and temperature. Can all gas molecules in the vessel have the same speed?
-
A vessel is filled with gas at some equilibrium pressure and temperature. Can all gas molecules in the vessel have the same speed?
-
A man standing on the edge of a swimming pool looks at a stone lying on the bottom. The depth of the swimming pool is equal to h. At what distance from the surface of water is the image of the stone...
-
1. What velocity will a 300 kg snowmobile acquire if pushed from rest by a force of 6240 N [E] for 1.25 s? What average force will stop this snowmobile from moving at this speed in 1.25 s? (v = 26.0...
-
Explain what it means to say that an accounting class is not the same as a math class.
-
If there are 28 students in a classroom and 18 of them are boys, what is the probabilityif a student is picked at randomof selecting a boy?
-
If a well-behaved investment alternative's internal rate of return (IRR) is equal to MARR, which of the following statements about the other measures of worth for this alternative must be true? 1....
-
BONDS ISSUED AT FACE VALUE Ito Co. issued the following bonds: Date of issue and sale: ........April 1, 20-1 Principal amount: ..........$300,000 Sale price of bonds: .........100 Denomination of...
-
n Juods xi(yi - Bxi) = 0 n i=1 a) Step by step, solve for B (Hint: you may want to use the proof starting on pg 10 as your guide)
-
Alex Vera organized Succulent Express at the beginning of February 20Y4. During February, Succulent Express entered into the following transactions: a. Terry Mason invested $30,000 in Succulent...
-
X- Using L from the previous problem, is L2 ? Circle the appropriate answer and justify your answer. YES or NO Consider the language: L5 = { < M > M is a Turing machine that halts when started on an...
-
In what manner are personality-based tests best used in organizations?
-
Write down notes from https://panmore.com/apple-inc-marketing-mix-4ps. Apple and their product ( iPad Air 5th generation) As part of their distribution strategy, Apple must decide if they should...
-
Is there a "Responsibility to protect" when it comes to humanitarian intervention in countries that are sovereign? Is it more important to respect state sovereignty or for their to be interference in...
-
Do you think ethical sensitivity is common among all types of consumers of green goods and products?
-
1. SWOT Analysis of current situation (this can be a chart) but each area MUST be explained 2. In order to win Holiday, develop a strategy to deliver a compelling assortment and innovative...
-
Idea for a Health Promotion Program in Your Community: Directions for completion - Complete the assignment in this Q and A format. Responses must include a minimum of three sentences and should...
-
Several months have passed and the Managing Partner approved and properly filed the Complaint and properly submitted the Request for Production of Documents that you drafted. In fact, it has been 75...
-
In Figure a uniform beam with a weight of 60 N and a length of 3.2m is hinged at its lower end, and a horizontal force F of magnitude 50 N acts at its upper end. The beam is held vertical by a cable...
-
A 10.0 g block with a charge of + 8.00 x 10-5 C is placed in an electric field E = (3000i 600j) N/C. What are the (a) Magnitude and (b) Direction (relative to the positive direction of the x axis)...
-
The magnetic field of a cylindrical magnet that has a pole-face diameter of 3.3 cm can be varied sinusoid ally between 29.6 T and 30.0 T at a frequency of 15 Hz. At a radial distance of 1.6 cm, what...
-
Using Snell's law (i.e., \(n_{o} r_{o} \cos \theta_{0}=n_{1} r_{1} \cos \theta_{1}\) ), show that \[ \left(\sin \left(\frac{\theta_{1}}{2}ight)ight)^{2}=\frac{r_{o}}{2 r_{1}}\left[2\left(\sin...
-
Derive an asymptotic form for \(\Gamma_{h}\) and \(\Gamma_{v}\) when the grazing angle is very small.
-
Deficits and fiscal consolidation As seen in the following table, the 2008 financial crisis left the United States with an enormous federal budget deficit in 2009. There was a substantial fiscal...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App