Read the case study and respond to the questions assigned. 1). Should Smith have received a job
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Read the case study and respond to the questions assigned.
1). Should Smith have received a job offer? Why or why not? Provide adequate justification using relevant legal concepts and case details.
2). Was Smith the victim of discrimination because of her disability?
3). Did she receive appropriate accommodation? Provide adequate justification using relevant legal concepts and case details.
4). Are the employer's standards defensible as a BFOR? Provide adequate justification using relevant legal concepts and case details.
5). Based on the material presented in this chapter, do you think the Human Rights Commission will support her claim of discrimination?
Transcribed Image Text:
Marita Smith works as a data entry clerk in a government department that is undergoing downsizing. Smith, who is severely hearing impaired, has been a productive employee in her department for the last five years. Her performance has always been above average. Smith has received notice that her position is being eliminated as part of the downsizing. Under her union's contract, she must be given preference for any government job that becomes available and for which she is qualified. Smith has been invited to apply for a term position in another government department, which is converting archival data from paper to an electronic database. To qualify for the position, Smith will have to pass an interview, a timed typing test, an accuracy test that involves accuracy in transcribing information from a computer screen, and another accuracy test that involves following written instructions to enter written records into the computer database. These are the same tests that all candidates for the position have had to pass to become eligible for the job. Smith was interviewed one week prior to being administered the three skill tests. The interview protocol followed a standardized form used by all government departments. The three skills tests were administered to groups of nine applicants each. The applicants were seated at desks with computers, which were arranged in three rows of three desks each. The instructions for the tests were given verbally by the test administrator. Smith was provided with the services of a sign language interpreter during the testing and interview sessions. Smith passed the interview but failed the skill tests. Her scores are presented in the table below along with the minimum scores that had to be obtained on each test to receive a job offer. Based on her performance on the tests, Smith did not receive an offer for the job and was laid off when her current job ended. Smith now believes that she was the victim of discrimination based on her physical disability; she claims that during the interview many references were made to her disability and that the interviewer always addressed questions to the sign language interpreter and never made eye contact with her. She feels that she was at a disadvantage in taking the skills tests. e aje Her prospective employer claims that had she passed the tests she would have been hired and her disability would have been accommodated. The employer argues that the testing standards were reasonably necessary for the efficient performance of the work. The standards in the table are being justified as bona fide occupational requirements (BFORS). Smith has now filed a complaint with her provincial Human Rights Commission. Table-Smith's Scores Relative to Standards Needed to Pass Each Test Standards Smith Interview 30 out of 50 points 36 Typing Test 50 words per minute with 5 errors 36 wpm-5 errors or less Accuracy-Following Instructions 7 out of 10 5,5 Accuracy-Transcribing 7 out of 10 Marita Smith works as a data entry clerk in a government department that is undergoing downsizing. Smith, who is severely hearing impaired, has been a productive employee in her department for the last five years. Her performance has always been above average. Smith has received notice that her position is being eliminated as part of the downsizing. Under her union's contract, she must be given preference for any government job that becomes available and for which she is qualified. Smith has been invited to apply for a term position in another government department, which is converting archival data from paper to an electronic database. To qualify for the position, Smith will have to pass an interview, a timed typing test, an accuracy test that involves accuracy in transcribing information from a computer screen, and another accuracy test that involves following written instructions to enter written records into the computer database. These are the same tests that all candidates for the position have had to pass to become eligible for the job. Smith was interviewed one week prior to being administered the three skill tests. The interview protocol followed a standardized form used by all government departments. The three skills tests were administered to groups of nine applicants each. The applicants were seated at desks with computers, which were arranged in three rows of three desks each. The instructions for the tests were given verbally by the test administrator. Smith was provided with the services of a sign language interpreter during the testing and interview sessions. Smith passed the interview but failed the skill tests. Her scores are presented in the table below along with the minimum scores that had to be obtained on each test to receive a job offer. Based on her performance on the tests, Smith did not receive an offer for the job and was laid off when her current job ended. Smith now believes that she was the victim of discrimination based on her physical disability; she claims that during the interview many references were made to her disability and that the interviewer always addressed questions to the sign language interpreter and never made eye contact with her. She feels that she was at a disadvantage in taking the skills tests. e aje Her prospective employer claims that had she passed the tests she would have been hired and her disability would have been accommodated. The employer argues that the testing standards were reasonably necessary for the efficient performance of the work. The standards in the table are being justified as bona fide occupational requirements (BFORS). Smith has now filed a complaint with her provincial Human Rights Commission. Table-Smith's Scores Relative to Standards Needed to Pass Each Test Standards Smith Interview 30 out of 50 points 36 Typing Test 50 words per minute with 5 errors 36 wpm-5 errors or less Accuracy-Following Instructions 7 out of 10 5,5 Accuracy-Transcribing 7 out of 10
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 Indeed Yes before she was even with the concerned union there was an agreement that really guaranteed her a future with the same union She has also worked in the government sector over the past five ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Mary Delaney worked as a data entry clerk at Signature Health Care Foundation, a nonprofit organization that provides physical therapy services to its clients. Shortly after she began her employment,...
-
For the last five years the sales of Departments D, E, and F have maintained a relatively stable ratio of 13: 17: 21. Department E is forecasting sales of $478,000 for next year. Based on the past...
-
The price of a good during the last five years is: $25 $30 $36 $43 $50 Calculate the index numbers using the last year as the base year and hence comment on the rise in prices during this period.
-
Suppose Nordic Boots was making production decisions for the following six boots: ot Price E(Demand) Std. Dev (Demand) Co Cu Exp. Profit Max. Profit A 220 1000 400 35.2 52.8 1101 39201 52800 230 2000...
-
If the demand function for Noah and Naomi's garden benches is what is their inverse demand function? QDIPI 1,000
-
Sound Portal Corporation sells stereos under a 2-year warranty contract that requires Sound Portal to replace defective parts and provide free labor on all repairs. During 2010, 1,290 units were sold...
-
What is the maximum price an investor will pay for a bond with a face value of $\$ 5,000$ and a coupon rate of $12 \%$, paid annually? Assume the investor seeks a yield of $10 \%$ and the bond will...
-
Simon Products uses both special journals and a general journal as described in this chapter. Simon also posts customers? accounts in the accounts receivable subsidiary ledger. The postings for the...
-
What are some ways a person can save their community?
-
Refer to Exercise 12-25. Stanmore Corporation makes a special-purpose machine, D4H, used in the textile industry. Stanmore has designed the D4H machine for 2017 to be distinct from its competitors....
-
Compare your list with your classmates' lists and discuss the following questions: What are the top five dispositions that an effective educator should have? Which of the dispositions do you feel are...
-
After completing a very difficult rock climb in the morning, Carmella found the afternoon climb unexpectedly easy. This example illustrates the phenomenon of __________.
-
Which of the following are considered internal users of accounting information? a. Creditors b. Investors c. Managers d. Zakat authorities
-
Why would an accrual system help in the accurate computation of zakat?
-
How does the parent-company method modify the new-entity approach? What is the rationale for this modification?
-
How can we most accurately assess personality?
-
Create 25 awesome headlines for one of the two brands on the following slide The brand that was chosen is great value cereal the message that we want to get across is same taste as brand names cereal...
-
The words without recourse on an indorsement means the indorser is: a. not liable for any problems associated with the instrument. b. not liable if the instrument is dishonored. c. liable personally...
-
Bylo Selhi wants to know how many years it well take for his mutual fund investment of $50,000 to reach $500,000 if his mutual fund pays an average of 12 percent per year.
-
The city of Glendale borrows $48 million by issuing municipal bonds to help build the Arizona Cardinals football stadium. It plans to set up a sinking fund that will repay the loan at the end of 10...
-
Describe how to develop a pro forma income statement (Table 6-7).
-
(a) Graph the binomial probability distribution with n = 10 and p = 0.2. Comment on the shape of the distribution. (b) Graph the binomial probability distribution with n = 10 and p = 0.5. Comment on...
-
Assuming = 5, compute (a) P(5) (b) P(X < 5) (c) P(X 5) (d) P(5 X 7) The random variable X follows a Poisson process with the given mean.
-
According to CTIA, 41% of all U.S. households are wireless-only households. In a simple random sample of 300 households, determine the mean and standard deviation number of wireless-only households....
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App