what is the statement of problem? what is Frye standard and Daubert standard? what is frye case?
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
what is the statement of problem?
what is Frye standard and Daubert standard?
what is frye case? what is daubert case?
Transcribed Image Text:
Posted on June 03, 2019 by Richard Fechter The Florida Supreme Court issued a per curiam opinion on May 23, 2019, reversing its decision seven months earlier in Delisle v. Crane, (Case No. SC16-2182) concerning Florida Statute Section 90.702 and the admissibility of expert witness testimony in the state. The court made a complete about face, rejecting the less rigorous Frye standard established in Delisle in favor of the strict Daubert standard for expert used by federal courts. According to Justice Poston, the federal court system has followed the Daubert standard for 23 years, which has also been adopted by 36 states, and the "grave constitutional concerns" that led to the rejection of Daubert in the Delisle decision were unfounded. By reversing course and reverting back to the Daubert standard, Florida courts will likely need to address more frequent challenges to expert testimony offered by forensic accountants and valuation analysts. This is not only because Daubert applies to expert opinions relating to new scientific principles (as does Frye), but it also applies to many areas of expert testimony that are not always thought of as being scientific in nature, including testimony involving the calculation of economic damages, business valuation and forensic accounting. Moreover, where Frye (unlike Daubert) allows experts to provide testimony that relies solely on their experience and training, Daubert requires that expert opinions be tested and assessed for reliability, rely on methods that have been subject to peer review and are generally accepted in the scientific community. As a result, testifying experts are now under one evidential standard for admissibility in both Florida courts and in Federal courts in the US (Daubert), which the Supreme Court ruled "will promote fairness and predictability in the legal system as well as help lessen forum shopping." Posted on June 03, 2019 by Richard Fechter The Florida Supreme Court issued a per curiam opinion on May 23, 2019, reversing its decision seven months earlier in Delisle v. Crane, (Case No. SC16-2182) concerning Florida Statute Section 90.702 and the admissibility of expert witness testimony in the state. The court made a complete about face, rejecting the less rigorous Frye standard established in Delisle in favor of the strict Daubert standard for expert used by federal courts. According to Justice Poston, the federal court system has followed the Daubert standard for 23 years, which has also been adopted by 36 states, and the "grave constitutional concerns" that led to the rejection of Daubert in the Delisle decision were unfounded. By reversing course and reverting back to the Daubert standard, Florida courts will likely need to address more frequent challenges to expert testimony offered by forensic accountants and valuation analysts. This is not only because Daubert applies to expert opinions relating to new scientific principles (as does Frye), but it also applies to many areas of expert testimony that are not always thought of as being scientific in nature, including testimony involving the calculation of economic damages, business valuation and forensic accounting. Moreover, where Frye (unlike Daubert) allows experts to provide testimony that relies solely on their experience and training, Daubert requires that expert opinions be tested and assessed for reliability, rely on methods that have been subject to peer review and are generally accepted in the scientific community. As a result, testifying experts are now under one evidential standard for admissibility in both Florida courts and in Federal courts in the US (Daubert), which the Supreme Court ruled "will promote fairness and predictability in the legal system as well as help lessen forum shopping."
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Statement of Problem It is a section of the research proposal by which a brief description of the major concern of the study problem is presented It i... View the full answer
Related Book For
Accounting
ISBN: 978-1337899451
27th edition
Authors: Carl S. Warren, James M. Reeve, Jonathan Duchac
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
What standards or tests has the Supreme Court used to evaluate governmental attempts to regulate abortion?
-
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in May 2005 that people can buy wine directly from out-of-state vineyards. The Court held that state laws requiring people to buy directly from wine retailers within the...
-
On 1 July 2015, Richard Ltd acquired all the issued shares of Elizabeth Ltd. The following information relates to the inter entity transactions that have occurred between Richard and Elizabeth to...
-
Which power plant has high load factor?
-
Determine Zi Zo, and Av for the network of Fig. 8.73 if 1DSS = 12 mA, VP = -6V, and yos = 40μS. +18 V 1.8 k2 Z, 1 Z, 15 V
-
Johnson Company uses the allowance method to account for uncollectible accounts receivable. Bad debt expense is established as a percentage of credit sales. For 2011, net credit sales totaled...
-
Focus upon each of the moments of truth in turn.What specific strategies could P&G employ in each one to increase the probability of a sale and repeat business?
-
Provide an explanation in support of or refuting the following statement: Humans would never develop natural immunity to a novel biological agent created in a laboratory Explain how super-antigens,...
-
Project managers should track the details of their projects to be transparent and manage risks as they arise. What is another benefit of tracking in project management?
-
Complete Tsate's Form 1040-SR, Schedules A, B and D, Form 8949, Form 6252 and Qualified Dividends and Capital Gain Tax Worksheet. Tsate Kongia (birthdate 02/14/1954) is an unmarried high school...
-
The city government has collected data on the square footage of houses within the city. They found that the average square footage of homes within the city limit is 1,240 square feet while the median...
-
1. Make a Java Program: 2. Make a class name Bus and make a main class name Main 3. In the Bus class, there should be member variables named: -(integers) = length, capacity, speed -(double) =...
-
Conditions: Imagine that you just started working for a financial organization that provides several financial calculators as web services that are available to third-party developers. Kelsey has...
-
Suppose a company suddenly announces that it will do a project and smart investors (ie., like you) think this project has an NPV of -$50 million. If this company's stock price prior to the...
-
Maria borrowed a loan of $650,000 from Bahama Bank at 10% per annum for a period of 5 years. How much total interest will she pay to the bank at the end of the 5th year? Question 17Answer a. $396,832...
-
Question Content AreaIf merchandise that cost the company $17,000 is expected to be returned in the coming year, the required adjustment _____. a. increases Estimated Returns Inventory and decreases...
-
PROBLEM 3 In this problem, we redesign the inventory program for Trish's bookstore using dictionaries. Note: We will be continuing this redesign in Lab 10. Copy the starter code Lab09P3-starter.py to...
-
During the year land was revalued and the surplus reported as Revaluation surplus; and an asset costing 80,000, written down to 38,000, was sold for 40,000. Identify the cost of any non-current...
-
Based on the following data, determine the cost of merchandise sold for November: Increase in estimated returns inventory ................................ $ 14,500 Merchandise inventory, November 1...
-
On June 1, 2019, Herbal Co. received $18,900 for the rent of land for 12 months. Journalize the adjusting entry (include an explanation) required for unearned rent on December 31, 2019.
-
Assume that the entry closing total revenues of $3,190,000 and total expenses of $2,350,000 has been made for the year. At the end of the fiscal year, Teresa Schafer, Capital has a credit balance of...
-
Identify the sources and discuss the consequences of bank runs, bank panics, and financial crises.
-
Explain why and how the government intervenes in the financial system, and the problems the government safety net creates.
-
In the absence of limits on the behavior of large intermediaries, how might the perception of institutions being too-big-to-fail lead to increased concentration in the banking industry?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App