# Question

In criminal trials (e.g., murder, robbery, driving while impaired, etc.) in the United States, it must be proven that a defendant is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. This can be thought of as a very strong unwillingness to convict defendants who are actually innocent. In civil trials (e.g., breach of contract, divorce hearings for alimony, etc.), it must only be proven by a preponderance of the evidence that a defendant is guilty. This makes it easier to prove a defendant guilty in a civil case than in a murder case. In a high-profile pair of cases in the mid 1990s, O. J. Simpson was found to be not guilty of murder in a criminal case against him. Shortly thereafter, however, he was found guilty in a civil case and ordered to pay damages to the families of the victims.

a. In a criminal trial by jury, suppose the probability the defendant is convicted, given guilt, is 0.95 and the probability the defendant is acquitted, given innocence, is 0.95. Suppose that 90% of all defendants truly are guilty. Given that a defendant is convicted, find the probability he or she was actually innocent. Draw a tree diagram or construct a contingency table to help you answer.

b. Repeat part a, but under the assumption that 50% of all defendants truly are guilty.

c. In a civil trial, suppose the probability the defendant is convicted, given guilt is 0.99, and the probability the defendant is acquitted, given innocence, is 0.75. Suppose that 90% of all defendants truly are guilty. Given that a defendant is convicted, find the probability he or she was actually innocent. Draw a tree diagram or construct a contingency table to help you answer.

a. In a criminal trial by jury, suppose the probability the defendant is convicted, given guilt, is 0.95 and the probability the defendant is acquitted, given innocence, is 0.95. Suppose that 90% of all defendants truly are guilty. Given that a defendant is convicted, find the probability he or she was actually innocent. Draw a tree diagram or construct a contingency table to help you answer.

b. Repeat part a, but under the assumption that 50% of all defendants truly are guilty.

c. In a civil trial, suppose the probability the defendant is convicted, given guilt is 0.99, and the probability the defendant is acquitted, given innocence, is 0.75. Suppose that 90% of all defendants truly are guilty. Given that a defendant is convicted, find the probability he or she was actually innocent. Draw a tree diagram or construct a contingency table to help you answer.

## Answer to relevant Questions

DNA evidence can be extracted from biological traces such as blood, hair, and saliva. “DNA fingerprinting” is increasingly used in the courtroom as well as in paternity testing. Given that a person is innocent, suppose ...As of the end of the 2010 NFL season, Indianapolis Colts quarterback Peyton Manning, throughout his 13-year career, completed 65% of all of his pass attempts. Suppose the probability each pass attempted in the next season ...Students in a geography class are asked whether they’ve visited Europe in the past 12 months and whether they’ve flown on a plane in the past 12 months. a. For a randomly selected student, would you expect these events ...Consider a game in which you roll two dice, and you win if the total is 7 or 11 and you lose if the total is 2, 3, or 12. You keep rolling until one of these totals occurs. Using conditional probability, find the probability ...A study of the PSA blood test for diagnosing prostate cancer in men (by R. M. Hoffman et al., BMC Family Practice, vol. 3, p. 19, 2002) used a sample of 2620 men who were 40 years and older. When a positive diagnostic test ...Post your question

0