Based on Gelblum’s estimates, Zimt’s net income in 2010 will most likely be:

A. highest if Zimt is deemed to have control of Oxbow.

B. highest if Zimt is deemed to have significant influence over Oxbow.

C. independent of the accounting method used for the investment in Oxbow.

Zimt, AG is a consumer products manufacturer headquartered in Austria. It complies with IFRS. In 2009, Zimt held a 10 percent passive stake in Oxbow Limited that was classified as held for trading securities. During the year, the value of this stake declined by €3 million. In December 2009, Zimt announced that it would be increasing its ownership to 50 percent effective 1 January 2010.

Franz Gelblum, an analyst following both Zimt and Oxbow, is curious how the increased stake will affect Zimt’s consolidated financial statements. Because Gelblum is uncertain how the company will account for the increased stake, he uses his existing forecasts for both companies’ financial statements to compare various alternative outcomes.

Gelblum gathers abbreviated financial statement data for Zimt (Exhibit 1) and Oxbow (Exhibit 2) for this purpose.

Transcribed Image Text:

EXHIBIT 1 Selected Financial Statement Estimates for Zimt AG ( Millions) Year ending 31 December Revenue Operating income 2010* 1,700 153 Net income 75 31 December 2010* Total assets 1,421 Shareholders' equity 735 *Estimates made prior to announcement of increased stake in Oxbow. 2009 1,500 135 66 2009 1,254 660 EXHIBIT 2 Selected Financial Statement Estimates for Oxbow Limited ( Millions) Year ending 31 December 2010* Revenue 1,350 Operating income 135 Net income 68 Dividends paid 22 31 December 2010* Total assets 1,283 Shareholders' equity 706 *Estimates made prior to announcement of increased stake by Zimt. 2009 1,200 120 60 20 2009 1,200 660