Read the case study Changing Jobs and Changing Loyalties and answer the questions: A) List all factors
Question:
Read the case study “Changing Jobs and Changing Loyalties” and answer the questions:
A) List all factors that support Cynthia taking the job with Crytex.
B) List all factors that support Cynthia remaining with Altrue.
C) For each item in each list, determine whether it is a prudential reason or a moral Identify a primafacie duty to support the view that Cynthia should take the job with Crytex. Show how this duty applies by referring to the items in the list you compiled in question A.
D) Identify a prima facie duty to support the view that Cynthia should stay with Altrue. Show how this duty applies by referring to the items in the list you compiled in question B.
E) What do you think is the morally right thing for Cynthia to do? Defend your position by arguing that the duty you identify in Question D and the factors you identify in Question C override the duties and factors you identified for the opposite position.
F) Now it's time to play Devil's Advocate. Imagine you came to the opposite conclusion. Defend that position by arguing that the duty you identify in Question D and the factors you identify in Question C override the duties and factors you identified for the position you defend in Question E.
G) Explain why you find the argument in Question E more compelling than the argument in Question F.
Income Tax Fundamentals 2013
ISBN: 9781285586618
31st Edition
Authors: Gerald E. Whittenburg, Martha Altus Buller, Steven L Gill