Air Canada Robert Milton had been fascinated by flying ever since childhood and dreamed of running...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Air Canada Robert Milton had been fascinated by flying ever since childhood and dreamed of running an airline company. But as he grew up and entered the industry, Milton came to see how poorly the major "legacy" airlines performed financially. The romance of flying could not obscure the difficulty of sustaining a profit in this industry. After a series of jobs in the airline industry, Milton joined Air Canada in 1992. While COO of the airline, he became convinced that the various parts of the airline that operated separately could be worth more than the entire company. Milton proposed that the company examine its various functional areas to find unrealized value in divisions that could become stand-alone entities. As a result, Air Canada could consider each business for carving out (separately incorporating each subsidiary and selling a fraction of the shares) or spinning off (divesting through a distribution of all the new company's shares). When Milton became CEO in 1999, he moved to realize his idea. But before Milton set his plan in motion, a series of events rocked Air Canada. Just two weeks after Milton became CEO, Air Canada was the object of a hostile takeover bid that required an unplanned merger with Canadian Airlines, the country's second largest airline, to resolve. The inability to integrate the two airlines quickly brought some infrastructure and labor inefficiencies in the short term. Then, the collapse of the dot-com industries in 2000 curtailed business travel. Just as Air Canada was adjusting to this downturn, the September 11 U.S. terrorist attacks further reduced the number of passengers, and requirèd expenditures for security. Meanwhile, fuel prices began to climb precipitously. Then, in 2003, SARS (Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome) hit China and Canada, wiping out travel to the Far East and to Canada, particularly to Toronto, Air Canada's hub. With declining passenger numbers and little liquidity, Air Canada filed for the Canadian equivalent of U.S. Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Bankruptcy provided a respite for the beleaguered airline and allowed Milton and his team to finalize the restructuring. Management streamlined operations and began breaking up the organization into subsidiaries. The company emerged from bankruptcy in October 2004 as a holding company, ACE Aviation Holdings Inc. with ten wholly owned subsidiaries. By the summer of 2006, Milton was well into the test of his theory that the parts of the airline were worth more than the airline itself. The company had carved out Aeroplan, its frequent flier program, and Jazz, its regional airline, and had publicly discussed spinning off the maintenance unit. The one large asset remaining airline, Air Canada, itself. A comparison of the ACE share price to "the sum of the parts" implied a negative value for Air Canada. Source: Air Canada. (2007, October 15). Retrieved from https://som.yale.edu/case/2007/air-canada Discussion Questions 1. Would carving out the airline capture additional value? What would be the costs and benefits? 2. If Air Canada was sold, what should the structure be? When should the sale take place? 3. Since selling the airline would mean that all the pieces of ACE were carved out, what would become of the holding company and its CEO? L Air Canada Robert Milton had been fascinated by flying ever since childhood and dreamed of running an airline company. But as he grew up and entered the industry, Milton came to see how poorly the major "legacy" airlines performed financially. The romance of flying could not obscure the difficulty of sustaining a profit in this industry. After a series of jobs in the airline industry, Milton joined Air Canada in 1992. While COO of the airline, he became convinced that the various parts of the airline that operated separately could be worth more than the entire company. Milton proposed that the company examine its various functional areas to find unrealized value in divisions that could become stand-alone entities. As a result, Air Canada could consider each business for carving out (separately incorporating each subsidiary and selling a fraction of the shares) or spinning off (divesting through a distribution of all the new company's shares). When Milton became CEO in 1999, he moved to realize his idea. But before Milton set his plan in motion, a series of events rocked Air Canada. Just two weeks after Milton became CEO, Air Canada was the object of a hostile takeover bid that required an unplanned merger with Canadian Airlines, the country's second largest airline, to resolve. The inability to integrate the two airlines quickly brought some infrastructure and labor inefficiencies in the short term. Then, the collapse of the dot-com industries in 2000 curtailed business travel. Just as Air Canada was adjusting to this downturn, the September 11 U.S. terrorist attacks further reduced the number of passengers, and requirèd expenditures for security. Meanwhile, fuel prices began to climb precipitously. Then, in 2003, SARS (Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome) hit China and Canada, wiping out travel to the Far East and to Canada, particularly to Toronto, Air Canada's hub. With declining passenger numbers and little liquidity, Air Canada filed for the Canadian equivalent of U.S. Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Bankruptcy provided a respite for the beleaguered airline and allowed Milton and his team to finalize the restructuring. Management streamlined operations and began breaking up the organization into subsidiaries. The company emerged from bankruptcy in October 2004 as a holding company, ACE Aviation Holdings Inc. with ten wholly owned subsidiaries. By the summer of 2006, Milton was well into the test of his theory that the parts of the airline were worth more than the airline itself. The company had carved out Aeroplan, its frequent flier program, and Jazz, its regional airline, and had publicly discussed spinning off the maintenance unit. The one large asset remaining airline, Air Canada, itself. A comparison of the ACE share price to "the sum of the parts" implied a negative value for Air Canada. Source: Air Canada. (2007, October 15). Retrieved from https://som.yale.edu/case/2007/air-canada Discussion Questions 1. Would carving out the airline capture additional value? What would be the costs and benefits? 2. If Air Canada was sold, what should the structure be? When should the sale take place? 3. Since selling the airline would mean that all the pieces of ACE were carved out, what would become of the holding company and its CEO? L
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 Carving out the airline could potentially capture additional value for Air Canada if the different ... View the full answer
Related Book For
International Marketing And Export Management
ISBN: 9781292016924
8th Edition
Authors: Gerald Albaum , Alexander Josiassen , Edwin Duerr
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these general management questions
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
Refer to all of the facts in Problem 12-6. Required 1. Using the format in the chapters appendix, prepare a statement of cash flows work sheet. 2. Prepare a statement of cash flows for 2014 using the...
-
A&W Manufacturing has implemented an activity-based costing system. For warehousing/packaging, the activity cost totals $140,400. ±he number of batches produced is the cost driver for this...
-
Certain item descriptions and amounts are missing from the monthly schedule of cost of goods manufactured and the income statement of Tioga Manufacturing Company. Requirement 1. Fill in the missing...
-
Class Year by Gender Exercise 2.35 deals with the distribution of class Year for students in an introductory statistics course. The StudentSurvey data also has information on the Gender for each...
-
Mountain Sports Inc. borrowed money for two years last week at 12%. The pure rate is 2%, and Mountains financial condition warrants a default risk premium of 3% and a liquidity risk premium of 2%....
-
A 0.025-kg bullet enters a 2.35-kg watermelon with a speed of 217 m/s and exits the opposite side with a speed of 109 m/s. If the melon was originally at rest, then what speed will it have as the...
-
On January 1, 2024, Harlon Consulting entered into a three-year lease for new office space agreeing to lease payments of $5,000 in 2024, $6,000 in 2025, and $7,000 in 2026. Payments are due on...
-
In recent years. DecoStyle, a prominent home decor retailer in Asia, has witnessed a significant uptick in sales, propelling its products to newfound popularity among consumers. Emboldened by this...
-
On January 1, 2024, the general ledger of Dynamite Fireworks includes the following account balances: Accounts Cash Accounts Receivable Supplies Land Accounts Payable Common Stock Retained Earnings...
-
Use an appropriate FUNCTION and calculate the total commission that real estate agents received for selling all houses that cost more than $400,000.
-
What power and political elements are within the criminal justice organization how are communication channels within the criminal justice organization and how could they be improved?
-
CPI for the genres of Action, Casino, and Trivia are $1, $5, and $2 respectively. ARPU for the genres of Action, Casino, and Trivia are $2, $8, and $4 respectively. Conversion rates for the genres of...
-
The different generations in the workforce, focus on approaches for managing and leading criminal justice agencies. Be sure to include the following: Discuss the need for learning organizations in...
-
Suppose you are starting a new business in merchandise industry. Based on transaction analysis, prepare General Journal for the first month of operating. Produce Income statement and Balance sheet in...
-
Suppose that a flow network G = (V, E) violates the assumption that the network contains a path s t for all vertices V. Let u be a vertex for which there is no path s u t. Show that there must...
-
Why might a company not choose outsourcing even when production costs are sufficiently lower?
-
What are the differences and similarities between origin image and the origin biases?
-
In August 2010, Britains GlaxoSmithKline PLC (GSK) was facing the possibility that its highly profitable diabetes drug Avandia would have to be withdrawn from the US market. Sales of Avandia had...
-
What is the ratio T f /T i for this process? A. 1/4 B. 1/2 C. 1 (no change) D. 2 E. 4 F. There is not enough information to decide. p (atm) 4 3- 2 1 0- 0 2 -V (m)
-
Jn Figure 12.22, by comparing the slope of the graph during the time the liquid water is warming to the slope as steam is warming, we can say that A. The specific heat of water is larger than that of...
-
An aluminum ring is tight around a solid iron rod. If we wish to loosen the ring to remove it from the rod, we should A. Increase the temperature of the ring and rod. B. Decrease the temperature of...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App