As explained in chapter 5, risk measures such as standard variation and beta equate risk to...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
As explained in chapter 5, risk measures such as standard variation and beta equate risk to volatility. In other words, the more volatile the historical returns from specific financial assets, the riskier the asset is deemed to be. Historical volatility patterns are also used in models such as value at risk models. The Swiss franc appreciated sharply against the euro at the time of the Eurozone's debt crisis in 2010/11, mainly due to its status as a safe haven in times of stress. The potentially negative impact of a strong currency on the country's exporter competitiveness was part of the motivation for the decision of the Swiss central bank set a goal of keeping its currency from rising beyond 1.20 francs to the euro in September 2011. On January 15, 2015 the Swiss National Bank announced that the cap would be dropped. The move came as a shock for the markets and had a dramatic impact on currency markets and regional stock exchanges. The franc appreciated sharply against the US $, reaching a gain of 25% against the dollar at one point during the day of the announcement and closing the day with a gain of about 12%. The Swiss franc also appreciated against regional currencies, including the euro, the Hungarian forint and especially the Polish zloty. The Swiss stock exchange, as well as stock exchanges in Poland and Hungary, also dropped sharply, with the Swiss Performance Index (SPI) closing 8.6% down on the day of the announcement. As a result, several currency traders and hedge funds suffered dramatic losses. For example, the Everest Capital LLC Global hedge fund was closed due to losses, the currency broker Alpari went into administration and the Asia Macro fund from Aspect Capital Ltd. lost about 11% in January 2015. Many of these institutions used value at risk model (VAR) risk modelling. Value at risk models estimate the largest loss that an institution is likely to lose in one day, given a specific probability. For example, a one day 1% VaR of $8 million refers to the largest loss that the portfolio manager is likely to lose 99% of the time. VaR modelling is largely based on past volatility. Since the Swiss franc's daily movements since 2011 had been artificially low, the maximum predicted losses on for Swiss franc traders would also have been very small. The time period 2011-15, when the Swiss central bank capped the Swiss/euro exchange rate, provides a vivid example of a period of low volatility, where the risk models based on past volatility suggest that risk has decreased substantially. Consequently, it will signal to risk managers that it is appropriate to increase risk taking, for example through increased use of leverage. This was apparently what happened in the case of many currency traders and hedge funds. The market movement on January 15, 2015 underlines the danger of basing risk measurement on past volatility. It also points to the importance of taking a multi- dimensional approach to risk modelling and risk management. Since market conditions change constantly, risk modelling cannot rely solely on historical risk patterns and must be complemented by, for instance, scenario analysis. Questions 1. In modern portfolio theory, the quantification of risk/risk measurement is based on past volatility. Explain the limitations of using past volatility as a measure of risk, referring to the Swiss central bank decision in this case study. 2. Do examples like this mean that volatility is never a good indication of risk? As explained in chapter 5, risk measures such as standard variation and beta equate risk to volatility. In other words, the more volatile the historical returns from specific financial assets, the riskier the asset is deemed to be. Historical volatility patterns are also used in models such as value at risk models. The Swiss franc appreciated sharply against the euro at the time of the Eurozone's debt crisis in 2010/11, mainly due to its status as a safe haven in times of stress. The potentially negative impact of a strong currency on the country's exporter competitiveness was part of the motivation for the decision of the Swiss central bank set a goal of keeping its currency from rising beyond 1.20 francs to the euro in September 2011. On January 15, 2015 the Swiss National Bank announced that the cap would be dropped. The move came as a shock for the markets and had a dramatic impact on currency markets and regional stock exchanges. The franc appreciated sharply against the US $, reaching a gain of 25% against the dollar at one point during the day of the announcement and closing the day with a gain of about 12%. The Swiss franc also appreciated against regional currencies, including the euro, the Hungarian forint and especially the Polish zloty. The Swiss stock exchange, as well as stock exchanges in Poland and Hungary, also dropped sharply, with the Swiss Performance Index (SPI) closing 8.6% down on the day of the announcement. As a result, several currency traders and hedge funds suffered dramatic losses. For example, the Everest Capital LLC Global hedge fund was closed due to losses, the currency broker Alpari went into administration and the Asia Macro fund from Aspect Capital Ltd. lost about 11% in January 2015. Many of these institutions used value at risk model (VAR) risk modelling. Value at risk models estimate the largest loss that an institution is likely to lose in one day, given a specific probability. For example, a one day 1% VaR of $8 million refers to the largest loss that the portfolio manager is likely to lose 99% of the time. VaR modelling is largely based on past volatility. Since the Swiss franc's daily movements since 2011 had been artificially low, the maximum predicted losses on for Swiss franc traders would also have been very small. The time period 2011-15, when the Swiss central bank capped the Swiss/euro exchange rate, provides a vivid example of a period of low volatility, where the risk models based on past volatility suggest that risk has decreased substantially. Consequently, it will signal to risk managers that it is appropriate to increase risk taking, for example through increased use of leverage. This was apparently what happened in the case of many currency traders and hedge funds. The market movement on January 15, 2015 underlines the danger of basing risk measurement on past volatility. It also points to the importance of taking a multi- dimensional approach to risk modelling and risk management. Since market conditions change constantly, risk modelling cannot rely solely on historical risk patterns and must be complemented by, for instance, scenario analysis. Questions 1. In modern portfolio theory, the quantification of risk/risk measurement is based on past volatility. Explain the limitations of using past volatility as a measure of risk, referring to the Swiss central bank decision in this case study. 2. Do examples like this mean that volatility is never a good indication of risk?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Answer 1 The main limitation of using past volatility as a measure of risk is that it is based on historical data which may not be representative of future risk For example the Swiss franc appreciated ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
Read the case study and answer the question below with a one page response. What does a SWOT analysis reveal about the overall attractiveness of Under Armours situation? Founded in 1996 by former...
-
Barbara buys 100 shares of DEM at $35 a share and 200 shares of GOP at $40 a share. She buys on margin and the broker charges interest of 10 percent on the loan. a. If the margin requirement is 55...
-
On January 1 of the current year, Palm Corporation purchases the net assets of Vicki's unincorporated business for $600,000. The tangible net assets have a $300,000 book value and a $400,000 FMV. The...
-
Harper Company sells toys, so its sales are heavily concentrated in the last quarter of the year because of holiday buying. Harper reported total sales for the past three years as follows (all...
-
The equity belongs to Paul because he is the sole owner of the business. Can you explain how the figure for equity by Thursday evening has arisen? You will need to look back at the events of Monday,...
-
Top managers of Video Avenue are alarmed by their operating losses. They are considering dropping the DVD product line. Company accountants have prepared the following analysis to help make this...
-
Detail with the aid of diagrams the design specification and construction details of an artificial sports pitch. Describe how artificial turf surfaces have developed over recent time. Give your views...
-
A store maintains data on customers, products and purchase records in three tables: CUSTOMER, PRODUCT, PURCHASE. The store manager wants to know which product is on its maximum discount for each...
-
The financial manager of Infinity Plc has estimated the Net Present Value (NPV) of an investment project to be 25 million under the assumption that the cash flows associated with the project are...
-
What has changed about beef production in the United States between the 1960s/70s and today? Select 2-3 aspects of beef production and explain why things have changed.
-
Based on the current population's annual growth rates and total fertility rates you can now make some general projections as to the future population geography of the world.
-
1) A ball is thrown vertically upward with a speed of 15 miles per hour. How long is it in the air? Assume it comes back to the same location and air resistance is negligible. 2) A car traveling at...
-
With the broad-based fall in CTKs, the growth in ACTKs from the passenger segment of the industry led to a decline in cargo load factors to 46.2% in March, why would that happen?
-
Pick a Country from this list and answer the question below regarding the country: Philippines, Russia, Mexico How do systems of oppression (in the country you picked from the list above), such as...
-
LSTM networks are: O A subset of RNN networks. O A subset of CNN networks. Time series dependent neural networks. O Oscillators.
-
A liquid flows upward through a valve situated in a vertical pipe. Calculate the differential pressure (kPa) between points A and B. The mean velocity of the flow is 4.1 m/s. The specific gravity of...
-
Wal-Mart founder Sam Walton amassed an enormous fortune in discount retailing, one of the most viciously competitive markets imaginable. How is this possible?
-
Discuss the role of common costs in pricing practice.
-
Olympia Natural Resources, Inc., and Yakima Lumber, Ltd., supply cut logs (raw lumber) to lumber and paper mills located in the Cascades Mountain region in the state of Washington. Each company has a...
-
How closely related do you believe language and thought to be? During the production of Chapter 3 in this book, the authors and editors debated whether we should use the word "autistics" or the...
-
When did human language originate?
-
How do children learn language?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App