Consider the following statements by David Cairns, former secretary-general of the International Accounting Standards Committee. 26...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Consider the following statements by David Cairns, former secretary-general of the International Accounting Standards Committee. 26 When we look at the way that countries or companies account for particular transactions and events, it is increasingly difficult to distin- guish in a systematic way so-called Anglo-American accounting from Continental European accounting or American accounting from, say, German accounting. 27 I am increasingly persuaded ... that the distinction between Anglo-American accounting and Continental European accounting is becoming less and less relevant and more and more confused. In reaching this conclusion, I do not dispute that different economic, social and legal considerations have influenced the development of accounting in different coun- tries. I also do not dispute the fact that there have been, and still are, differences in the means by which different countries determine accounting requirements and the form of the resulting requirements. I do believe, however, that those who continue to favour these clas- sifications are ignoring what is happening in the world and how companies actually account for transactions and events. It is increasingly apparent that the different economic, social and legal considerations which have influenced national accounting do not necessarily result in different accounting and that countries are reaching the same answers irre- spective of their different cultural backgrounds (or reaching different answers in spite of the similar cul- tural backgrounds). In fact, there are now probably far more similari- ties between American and German. accounting than there are between American and British accounting. There are many reasons for this not least the increasing practice of stan- dard setting bodies and other regu- lators to share ideas and learn from one another. They do this in the IASC, the UN, the OECD, the EU, and such groupings as G4. This cross-fertilization of ideas is not surprising because standard setting bodies in all countries are having to address the same accounting problems.28 Required 1. Do you agree with Cairns's asser- tion that classifications of account- ing are simplistic and of little relevance in today's world? Are attempts to classify accounting futile and outmoded? Why or why not? 2. Some observers contend that finan- cial reporting is becoming more and more alike among "world-class" companies the world's largest multinational corporations-and especially those listed on the major stock exchanges, such as London, New York, and Tokyo. What is the relevance of this contention for clas- sifications of accounting, and what are the factors that would cause this to happen? Consider the following statements by David Cairns, former secretary-general of the International Accounting Standards Committee. 26 When we look at the way that countries or companies account for particular transactions and events, it is increasingly difficult to distin- guish in a systematic way so-called Anglo-American accounting from Continental European accounting or American accounting from, say, German accounting. 27 I am increasingly persuaded ... that the distinction between Anglo-American accounting and Continental European accounting is becoming less and less relevant and more and more confused. In reaching this conclusion, I do not dispute that different economic, social and legal considerations have influenced the development of accounting in different coun- tries. I also do not dispute the fact that there have been, and still are, differences in the means by which different countries determine accounting requirements and the form of the resulting requirements. I do believe, however, that those who continue to favour these clas- sifications are ignoring what is happening in the world and how companies actually account for transactions and events. It is increasingly apparent that the different economic, social and legal considerations which have influenced national accounting do not necessarily result in different accounting and that countries are reaching the same answers irre- spective of their different cultural backgrounds (or reaching different answers in spite of the similar cul- tural backgrounds). In fact, there are now probably far more similari- ties between American and German. accounting than there are between American and British accounting. There are many reasons for this not least the increasing practice of stan- dard setting bodies and other regu- lators to share ideas and learn from one another. They do this in the IASC, the UN, the OECD, the EU, and such groupings as G4. This cross-fertilization of ideas is not surprising because standard setting bodies in all countries are having to address the same accounting problems.28 Required 1. Do you agree with Cairns's asser- tion that classifications of account- ing are simplistic and of little relevance in today's world? Are attempts to classify accounting futile and outmoded? Why or why not? 2. Some observers contend that finan- cial reporting is becoming more and more alike among "world-class" companies the world's largest multinational corporations-and especially those listed on the major stock exchanges, such as London, New York, and Tokyo. What is the relevance of this contention for clas- sifications of accounting, and what are the factors that would cause this to happen?
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
1. Do you agree with Cairnss assertion that classifications of accounting are simplistic and of little relevance in todays world? Are attempts to classify accounting futile and outmoded? Why or why...
-
importance of workalike balance for women as a leader in healthcare. 1. The purpose of the research; 2. Research question/s; 3. Findings and relevant data; 4. Any recommendations and; 5. The...
-
Elena, a student in F-1 immigration status from Romania, is on the basketball team. She arrived in the U.S. on June 18, 2023 on a full athletic scholarship that includes $10,000 for her room and...
-
How do IFRS rules differ in the reporting of research and development costs? Which is more conservative in the reporting of research and development costs, U.S. GAAP or IFRS?
-
Explain the guidelines for deciding when to stop decomposing DFDs.
-
What would happen to the SML graph in Figure 8.8 if expected inflation increased or decreased? Figure 8.8 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 A Required Rate of Return TH-13.0% SML: r, RF+RPM * b D E F H...
-
Tiger Equipment Inc., a manufacturer of construction equipment, prepared the following factory overhead cost budget for the Welding Department for May 2014. The company expected to operate the...
-
Provide a clear definition of SES (Socioeconomic Status), encompassing its components such as income, education, and occupation. Discuss the societal implications of SES and its role in shaping...
-
Brook Company is an 80% owned subsidiary of Stone Corporation. Brook Company issued $150,000 of 10%, 10 year bonds for $140,000 on January 1, 20X1. Annual interest is paid on January 1 each year....
-
Suppose that Paulie and Vinny each can produce ice cream or t-shirts. The table below shows the quantity of each good that Paulie and Vinny each can produce in one hour, respectively, if they devote...
-
Baltimore City Population; 452,000 The Coffee Institute estimates that 38% of the population living on the east coast of the United States drinks coffee A Baltimore Area consumer expenditure survey...
-
After the Seneca IT team performed hardware upgrades to the computers in a Seneca lab, several computers are beeping when powered on. The pattern is one long and two short beeps. You find out these...
-
Simplify the messy algebra (X-45 (x+2)+ (x-4) (x+2)/ [(x+2)+] Find the domain Graph y = {2x+3 X (-(x-2) + 4, X>1 Clearly show all intercepts and boundary. Values. 1= 36-X y =
-
The after-tax cost of debt is 6%. The cost of preferred stock is 8% and the cost of equity is12.0% The stock price is %40. There are 4 million shares of stock. The market values of the firms...
-
Explain Environmental Management Accounting (EMA) and measurement of physical flows (with examples)
-
Extend Algorithms 3.4 and 3.5 to include as output the first and second derivatives of the spline at the nodes.
-
Refer to Exercise 4. In May 2004, the EU expanded to incorporate 10 Central and East European nations: Cyprus, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, Poland, Slovakia, and...
-
Examine the Web sites of five exchanges listed in Appendix 1-1 that you feel would be most attractive to foreign listers. Which exchange in your chosen set proved most popular during the last two...
-
Analyze the five national accounting practice systems summarized in this chapter. Required: a. For each of the five countries discussed in this chapter, select the most important financial accounting...
-
What is the effect of the moral hazard problem on insurance premiums? Explain your answer.
-
The total cost of government regulations in the U.S. manufacturing sector was estimated by the National Association of Manufacturers to be about $2 trillion in 2012, or $15,400 per family. a. Do the...
-
Who would benefit and who would lose if an informational alternative to licensing doctors were introduced?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App