Pilot Air Freight Corporation moves freight through a network of company-owned and company-franchised locations at airports...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Pilot Air Freight Corporation moves freight through a network of company-owned and company-franchised locations at airports and other sites. Franchisees included LJL Transportation, Inc., which is owned by Louis Pektor and Leo Decker. The franchise agreement required LJL to assign all shipments to the Pilot network. The agreement also provided that "Pilot shall allow Franchisee an opportunity to cure a default within ninety (90) days of receipt of written notice!" After eight years as a Pilot franchisee, LJL began to divert shipments to Northeast Transportation, a com- peting service owned by Pektor and Decker. On learning of the diversions, Pilot terminated the franchise agreement. LJL filed a suit in a Pennsylvania state court against Pilot, alleging breach of contract and asserting a right to cure. The court issued a summary judgment in Pilot's favor, and a state intermediate appellate court affirmed. LJL appealed. LANGUA LENT MA OF S IN THE LANGUAGE OF THE COURT Justice TODD. THE There is no Pennsylvania case law directly governing the resolution of the particular question presented in this appeal* * *. Courts from other jurisdic- tions appear to be in accord that* * * a termination clause affording the right to notice and cure is* * * a cumulative remedy which does not bar the non-breaching party from exercising a. In the "Conducting Business with the Court" section, click on "Supreme Court Opinions." On that page, in the "Caption" box, type "LJL"; in the "Month" pull-down menu, select "January"; in the "Year" pull-down menu, choose "2009"; and click on "Search." In the result, click on the link to access the opinion. The Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania maintains this Web site. CASE 36.2 CONTINUED other remedies available to it in the event of a breach by the other party going directly to the heart of the contract, and destroying the fundamental trust upon which the contractual rela- tionship is built. *[This] view [is] consistent with the law. *regarding the effect of material breaches, and likewise consistent with the policy requiring good faith and honesty in the perfor- mance and enforcement of contractual relations. .. * Self-dealing is the antithesis [exact opposite] of that [policy] and it violates the relationship of trust necessarily underlying such agreements. [Emphasis added.] The franchisee's breach of its implied duty of honesty and fidelity [goes] to the heart of the contract. Merely requiring the franchisee to retroactively undo its wrongdoing * * would not be an adequate remedy. [Emphasis added.] *Consequently, we have no difficulty in concluding that when there is a breach of con- tract going directly to the essence of the contract, which is so exceedingly grave as to irreparably damage the trust between the contracting parties, the non-breaching party may terminate the contract without notice. *. Requiring such notice before termination under such circum- stances would be a useless gesture, as such a breach may not reasonably be cured. Such a breach is so fundamentally destructive, it understandably and inevitably causes the trust which is the bedrock foundation and veritable lifeblood of the parties' contractual relationship to essentially evaporate. We find our law does not require a non-breaching party to prolong a contractual relationship under such circumstances. DECISION AND REMEDY The Pennsylvania Supreme Court affirmed the lower court's judgment. A franchise agreement may be terminated immediately when there is a material breach of the contract so serious it goes directly to the heart and essence of the contract, rendering the breach incurable. THE ETHICAL DIMENSION From an ethical perspective, if LL had been allowed to invoke the right-to-cure provision, could it have undone its wrongdoing so that the franchise relation- ship could have continued? Why or why not? WHAT IF THE FACTS WERE DIFFERENT? Suppose that Pilot hod terminated its franchise agreement simply because it no longer wished to be bound. Would refusing to allow LIL to invoke the right-to-cure provision in that circumstance have been valid? Pilot Air Freight Corporation moves freight through a network of company-owned and company-franchised locations at airports and other sites. Franchisees included LJL Transportation, Inc., which is owned by Louis Pektor and Leo Decker. The franchise agreement required LJL to assign all shipments to the Pilot network. The agreement also provided that "Pilot shall allow Franchisee an opportunity to cure a default within ninety (90) days of receipt of written notice!" After eight years as a Pilot franchisee, LJL began to divert shipments to Northeast Transportation, a com- peting service owned by Pektor and Decker. On learning of the diversions, Pilot terminated the franchise agreement. LJL filed a suit in a Pennsylvania state court against Pilot, alleging breach of contract and asserting a right to cure. The court issued a summary judgment in Pilot's favor, and a state intermediate appellate court affirmed. LJL appealed. LANGUA LENT MA OF S IN THE LANGUAGE OF THE COURT Justice TODD. THE There is no Pennsylvania case law directly governing the resolution of the particular question presented in this appeal* * *. Courts from other jurisdic- tions appear to be in accord that* * * a termination clause affording the right to notice and cure is* * * a cumulative remedy which does not bar the non-breaching party from exercising a. In the "Conducting Business with the Court" section, click on "Supreme Court Opinions." On that page, in the "Caption" box, type "LJL"; in the "Month" pull-down menu, select "January"; in the "Year" pull-down menu, choose "2009"; and click on "Search." In the result, click on the link to access the opinion. The Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania maintains this Web site. CASE 36.2 CONTINUED other remedies available to it in the event of a breach by the other party going directly to the heart of the contract, and destroying the fundamental trust upon which the contractual rela- tionship is built. *[This] view [is] consistent with the law. *regarding the effect of material breaches, and likewise consistent with the policy requiring good faith and honesty in the perfor- mance and enforcement of contractual relations. .. * Self-dealing is the antithesis [exact opposite] of that [policy] and it violates the relationship of trust necessarily underlying such agreements. [Emphasis added.] The franchisee's breach of its implied duty of honesty and fidelity [goes] to the heart of the contract. Merely requiring the franchisee to retroactively undo its wrongdoing * * would not be an adequate remedy. [Emphasis added.] *Consequently, we have no difficulty in concluding that when there is a breach of con- tract going directly to the essence of the contract, which is so exceedingly grave as to irreparably damage the trust between the contracting parties, the non-breaching party may terminate the contract without notice. *. Requiring such notice before termination under such circum- stances would be a useless gesture, as such a breach may not reasonably be cured. Such a breach is so fundamentally destructive, it understandably and inevitably causes the trust which is the bedrock foundation and veritable lifeblood of the parties' contractual relationship to essentially evaporate. We find our law does not require a non-breaching party to prolong a contractual relationship under such circumstances. DECISION AND REMEDY The Pennsylvania Supreme Court affirmed the lower court's judgment. A franchise agreement may be terminated immediately when there is a material breach of the contract so serious it goes directly to the heart and essence of the contract, rendering the breach incurable. THE ETHICAL DIMENSION From an ethical perspective, if LL had been allowed to invoke the right-to-cure provision, could it have undone its wrongdoing so that the franchise relation- ship could have continued? Why or why not? WHAT IF THE FACTS WERE DIFFERENT? Suppose that Pilot hod terminated its franchise agreement simply because it no longer wished to be bound. Would refusing to allow LIL to invoke the right-to-cure provision in that circumstance have been valid?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
The detailed answer for the above question is provided below From an ethical perspective if LJL ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Cost Management Measuring Monitoring and Motivating Performance
ISBN: 978-0470769423
2nd edition
Authors: Leslie G. Eldenburg, Susan K. Wolcott
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Suppose that a car dealership decided it would no longer compensate employees with sales commissions, but instead pay a salary with a bonus for high customer satisfaction ratings. What problems would...
-
Suppose that bound molecules in Exercise 25 have a 2.0% chance of unbinding from the enzyme each second. Find the fraction of molecules that are bound in the long run. What is the probability that a...
-
In August 2010, Massachusetts enacted a 150-day right-to-cure period that mandates that lenders give homeowners who fall behind on their mortgage an extra five months to become current before...
-
Suppose that a 12-inch ruler must have the correct length L to within 0.0002 inch. (a) Write an absolute value inequality for L that describes this requirement. (b) Solve this inequality and...
-
Using the information from the profile model in Problem 7, construct an argument as to why project B is preferable to project C.
-
Which of the following statements is/are correct? (a) The Conduct Committee (previously the Financial Reporting Review Panel (FRRP)) was established by the Financial Reporting Council. (b) The...
-
What are the differences between summary judgment and summary adjudication?
-
PowerSwitch, Inc. designs and manufactures switches used in telecommunications. Serious flooding throughout North Carolina affected Power Switchs facilities. Inventory was completely ruined, and the...
-
For this practice example, please show all calculations and formulas. If completed in Excel, please show calculations and formulas. practice 10: Show the effects of these transactions on the balance...
-
Windemere Limited is a Canadian-controlled private corporation founded 12 years ago by Mr. White who holds all of the shares which he purchased at that time from the company for $1,000. As of...
-
Which of the following is NOT a function of Epidermal GrowthFactor (EGF)? Initiates apoptosis of abnormal cells Stimulates epidermal repair and glandular secretion Promotes division of germanitive...
-
Give three specific examples of how a sponsor might activate their partnership with a sport property. Describe the three endorser characteristics related to congruency, then give an example of an...
-
The ellipse x+2y2 - 16x-16y - 296 = 0 has its center at x =
-
Explain Linear Tape-Open (LTO). Discuss its advantages and drawbacks. List any two current domains where LTO is used. 2. Why are interrupts used in a computer? Highlight the drawbacks of disabling...
-
Tropical View had a January 1 beginning balance in its Prepaid Rent account of $100. During the year the company made payments for prepaid rent of $900. Tropical View recorded rent expense for the...
-
During the current year, Ron and Anne sold the following assets: (Use the dividends and capital gains tax rates and tax rate schedules.) Capital Asset L stock M stock N stock 0 stock Antiques Rental...
-
Speedy Access Services Inc. leases access to high-speed computers to small businesses. It provides the following information for the year: Overhead cost Computer hours Direct labor hours Estimated...
-
For what reason might an exporter use standard international trade documentation (letter of credit, draft, order bill of lading) on an intrafirm export to its parent or sister subsidiary?
-
Conrad Miller owns a small sheet metal business. He produces three different types of sheet metal. Their sizes are similar, but they have different degrees of flexibility. Costs are allocated based...
-
Jumping Juice Ltd. produces two grades of sparkling apple juice. A diagram of the production process appears in Exhibit 9.6. The process begins when the vat is loaded with apples. The incremental...
-
A firm uses variable costing for internal reports and updates these reports daily. It must convert the variable costing results to absorption costing results for external reports. How can this...
-
A system, consisting of \(2 \mathrm{~mol}\) of \(\mathrm{N}_{2}, 5 \mathrm{~mol}\) of \(\mathrm{H}_{2}\) and \(2 \mathrm{~mol}\) of \(\mathrm{NH}_{3}\) initially, is undergoing the following...
-
A thermodynamic system (a) Is a definite quantity of matter (b) Is surrounded by a boundary (c) Can exchange energy with its surroundings (d) All of these.
-
The study of thermodynamics enables us to understand (a) Whether the transformation of energy is feasible or not (b) To what extent the transformation will take place (c) In which direction the...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App