QUESTION: Compute the one-dimensional utility values for each alternative for each evaluation measure. The Royal Canadian Air
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
QUESTION: Compute the one-dimensional utility values for each alternative for each evaluation measure.
Transcribed Image Text:
The Royal Canadian Air Force is considering buying a new weapon system to use on its fighter aircraft for close-in air to air attack/defense after longer-range missiles have been expended. The existing Status Quo is the M61 20-mm gun, which are installed in the current aircraft but will need to be refurbished at a cost of $50 million. There are two additional alternatives: internally mounted twin 30 mm guns and a new high-tech laser system. There are three evaluation measures that the Air Force will use for this decision: cost of implementing across the fleet ($millions), capability, and survivability. The last two measures are constructive measures defined as follows: Table 1: Constructive Measures Capability Less effective Same as status quo More effective Very effective (specific values are defined for these categories in measurable terms) Score -1 0 1 2 For the following analysis, assume a range from $50M to $250M ($M = $million) for cost across the service and a range from 1 to +2 for the (constructed) evaluation measure scale capability and from 1 to +1 for survivability. Note that preferences are monotonically increasing for capability and survivability ("more is better"), while preferences are monotonically decreasing for cost ("more is worse"). The scores for each of the three alternatives on these three evaluation measures are as follows: Survivability Low Medium High N/A Table 2: Scores of Evaluation Measures for Alternatives Alternative Cost ($M) Survivability 50 1 150 0 250 -1 Status Quo Twin 30-mm guns Laser Capability 0 1 2 A multi-objective utility analysis is being done to evaluate these alternatives. The single dimensional utility function over cost is (normalized) exponential with an R value of $65M. The single dimensional utility function over capability is piecewise linear. The utility increment going from a capability score of -1 to a score of 0 is the same as the utility increment going from a capability score of 0 to a score of +1. The utility increment going from a capability score of +1 to a score of +2 is twice as great as the utility increment going from a capability score of 0 to a score of 1. The single dimensional utility function over survivability is linear from -1 to +1. The utility increment going from a capability score of -1 to a capability score of +2 is twice as great as the utility increment going from a cost per weapon system alternative of $250M to a cost of $50M, while the utility increment going from a survivability score of-1 to a survivability score of +1 is the same as the utility increment going from a capability of -1 to a capability score of +2. The Royal Canadian Air Force is considering buying a new weapon system to use on its fighter aircraft for close-in air to air attack/defense after longer-range missiles have been expended. The existing Status Quo is the M61 20-mm gun, which are installed in the current aircraft but will need to be refurbished at a cost of $50 million. There are two additional alternatives: internally mounted twin 30 mm guns and a new high-tech laser system. There are three evaluation measures that the Air Force will use for this decision: cost of implementing across the fleet ($millions), capability, and survivability. The last two measures are constructive measures defined as follows: Table 1: Constructive Measures Capability Less effective Same as status quo More effective Very effective (specific values are defined for these categories in measurable terms) Score -1 0 1 2 For the following analysis, assume a range from $50M to $250M ($M = $million) for cost across the service and a range from 1 to +2 for the (constructed) evaluation measure scale capability and from 1 to +1 for survivability. Note that preferences are monotonically increasing for capability and survivability ("more is better"), while preferences are monotonically decreasing for cost ("more is worse"). The scores for each of the three alternatives on these three evaluation measures are as follows: Survivability Low Medium High N/A Table 2: Scores of Evaluation Measures for Alternatives Alternative Cost ($M) Survivability 50 1 150 0 250 -1 Status Quo Twin 30-mm guns Laser Capability 0 1 2 A multi-objective utility analysis is being done to evaluate these alternatives. The single dimensional utility function over cost is (normalized) exponential with an R value of $65M. The single dimensional utility function over capability is piecewise linear. The utility increment going from a capability score of -1 to a score of 0 is the same as the utility increment going from a capability score of 0 to a score of +1. The utility increment going from a capability score of +1 to a score of +2 is twice as great as the utility increment going from a capability score of 0 to a score of 1. The single dimensional utility function over survivability is linear from -1 to +1. The utility increment going from a capability score of -1 to a capability score of +2 is twice as great as the utility increment going from a cost per weapon system alternative of $250M to a cost of $50M, while the utility increment going from a survivability score of-1 to a survivability score of +1 is the same as the utility increment going from a capability of -1 to a capability score of +2.
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
Engineering Economy
ISBN: 978-0132554909
15th edition
Authors: William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, C. Patrick Koelling
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these finance questions
-
A vehicle accessory shop is considering buying a new style of wheels for $168 and selling them at $369.60 for each wheel. Fixed costs related to this new style of wheel amount to $2465. It is...
-
A highway contractor is considering buying a new trench excavator that costs $250,000 and can dig a 3-foot-wide trench at the rate of 16 feet per hour. With the machine adequately maintained, its...
-
A company is considering buying a new bottle capping machine. The initial cost of the machine is $325,000 and it has a 10-year life. Monthly maintenance costs are expected to be $1200 per month for...
-
A product has a contribution margin of $6 per unit and a selling price of $30 per unit. Fixed costs are $24,000. Assuming the new technology increases the unit contribution margin by 60 percent but...
-
Botburry Sheet Company offers all employees a defined-benefit pension plan. At the end of the current year, Botburrys pension plan trustee reported the following information regarding the changes in...
-
Cherokee Inc. is a merchandiser that provided the following information: Required: 1. Prepare a traditional income statement. 2. Prepare a contribution format income statement. Amount Number of units...
-
Find a form for a voluntary dismissal in a California court.
-
If a computer system does not have relocation hardware yet it implements swapping, then the memory manager will have to use a loader to recomputed the executable image from the absolute image. Would...
-
Many SME service sector companies are under fire with current global economic uncertainty. The pressure is mainly due to intense market competition, significant impact of their product, and change in...
-
Mr. T makes a good recovery and is discharged from the hospital, but a few weeks later you meet him again in the outpatient clinic complaining of headache, blurred vision, and pinkeye. His eyes are...
-
Provide a minimum of three strengths, three weaknesses, three opportunities, and three threats (or more) for Silver Airways. Write a paragraph explanation for each quadrant (Strengths, Weaknesses,...
-
There is a new airline opening up in the hanger next to yours that offers the same flight but for $25 less per flight. They don't have as many flights right now- only one regional jet, investors want...
-
Case Study 2a - Who will I be as a leader? In four weeks, Little Catalysts ELC will have a site visit from a consultant to confer with selected staff. Carol, the Director, wants to see if the service...
-
The units of an item available for sale during the year were as follows: Jan. 1 Inventory 40 units at $165 $6,600 Aug. 13 Purchase 200 units at $180 36,000 Nov. 30 Purchase 60 units at $200 12,000...
-
listen to the This American Life audio clips. 1. In the opening clip, reporter Jacob Goldstein is trying to understand where all the lost money went during the financial crisis. He asks his business...
-
1-2 3 3 02 1. Let A = and B = find 2A-3B. 45-6 7 1 8 2 1 [1-2 -5 2. Given A= 1 0 and B find 3 40 3 4 a. AB b. BA
-
The management of Zigby Manufacturing prepared the following balance sheet for March 31. Cash Accounts receivable Raw materials inventory Assets ZIGBY MANUFACTURING Balance Sheet March 31 Liabilities...
-
Represent each of the following combination of units in the correct SI form using an appropriate prefix: (a) m/ms, (b) k m, (c) k s /mg, and (d) k m N.
-
Spivey just won the Powerball lottery! The $20,000,000 jackpot will be paid in 20 annual installments of $1,000,000 each, with the first payment to be paid immediately. Spivey's opportunity cost of...
-
A 2,000 square foot house in New Jersey j costs $1,725 each winter to heat with its existing oil-burning furnace. For an investment of $5,000, a natural gas furnace can be installed, and the winter...
-
It is estimated that a certain piece of equipment can save $22,000 per year in labor and materials costs. The equipment has an expected life of five years and no market value. If the company must...
-
Estimate the fundamental frequency for the tapered beam of Figure 8.17 where \[ m(x)=m(1-x / L) \] and \[ E A(x)=E A(1-x / L) \] Compare your result to the exact value of \(\omega_{1}=\) \(2.40...
-
Derive the differential equation of motion for a nonuniform plate with varying thickness. Assume that the material properties such as Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio remain constant.
-
For the tapered beam sketched in Figure 8.17 undergoing transverse vibration, estimate the first two natural frequencies using the Rayleigh-Ritz procedure. Assume a trial function of the form...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App